Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
43 Years
experience
Family-Owned Jewelry Store in Baldwin, WI
Fennern Jewelers has been a family-owned and operated business since 1983, serving Baldwin, WI, and the surrounding communities. Our commitment to providing high-quality jewelry and exceptional customer service remains unchanged after four decades. We specialize in diamonds, gemstones, gold and silver jewelry, watches, clocks, and gifts, with expertise in custom design, sizing, repair, and refurbishment. Our team includes a Certified Master Watchmaker and graduate Goldsmith, ensuring precision in every service. We pride ourselves on quick turnaround times, as demonstrated by our ability to fulfill special orders within days rather than months.

The original bank vault in our 1922 building safeguards valuable merchandise, reflecting our dedication to security. Our late co-founder Nancy Fennerns legacy of personalized service continues through our team, including her daughter Allison, who now leads sales. Community involvement remains central to our values, with decades of participation in local events like Windmill Days and the Festival of Lights. We believe in supporting local economies by offering customers the opportunity to shop small while maintaining high standards of craftsmanship and value.
Services
Diamond Jewelry Gemstone Jewelry Custom Design Jewelry Repair Watch Repair Sizing Services Refurbishing Gift Items Clock Sales Battery Replacement
Details
  • Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned and operated since 1983
  • Custom jewelry design expertise
  • Fast turnaround on special orders
  • Deep community involvement
  • Certified Master Watchmaker on staff
What people say
The best! Quick turnaround Perfect wedding ring Personalized service Amazing customer service
Services
Custom Design
Our team creates bespoke jewelry tailored to your vision, using high-quality materials and craftsmanship. From engagement rings to heirloom pieces, we collaborate closely with clients to ensure unique, meaningful designs. With decades of experience, we transform ideas into timeless creations.
Jewelry Repair
We offer comprehensive repair services for all types of jewelry, including resizing, stone replacement, and restoration. Our skilled artisans use advanced techniques to maintain the integrity and beauty of your cherished pieces, ensuring they last for generations.
Watch Repair
As a certified horology expert, we repair and maintain watches of all brands. Services include battery replacement, movement repair, and water resistance testing. Our precision ensures your timepiece remains accurate and functional for years to come.
Diamond Sales
We provide a curated selection of high-quality diamonds, from classic solitaires to unique cuts. Our knowledgeable staff guides you through the 4Cs to find the perfect stone for any occasion, ensuring value and satisfaction in every purchase.
Gift Items
Our store features a variety of gift options, including clocks, decorative items, and specialty jewelry. Whether for anniversaries, holidays, or everyday celebrations, we offer thoughtfully curated products to suit every taste and budget.
People
Eric Fennern
President
Eric Fennern, a Certified Master Watchmaker and Goldsmith, founded the store in 1983. With decades of experience, he combines technical expertise with a passion for customer service, ensuring every client receives personalized attention and quality craftsmanship.
Allison Fennern
Lead Sales
Allison Fennern, Eric's daughter, leads sales and business operations. Growing up in the jewelry industry, she brings generational knowledge and a commitment to community-focused service, continuing her family's legacy of excellence.
Marge Weiske
Sales
Marge Weiske has been part of the team since 1989, known for her warm personality and exceptional customer care. Her dedication to creating a welcoming environment makes her a beloved representative of the Fennern Jewelers family.
Nancy Fennern
Vice-President
Nancy Fennern co-founded the business and was instrumental in its success until her passing in 2021. Her dedication to customer service and community engagement left a lasting impact on the store and Baldwin residents.
Questions
What services do you offer?
We offer jewelry and watch sales, custom design, repairs, sizing, refurbishment, and gift items. Our Certified Master Watchmaker also provides battery replacement and watch repair services.
Are you family-owned?
Yes, Fennern Jewelers has been family-owned since 1983. Eric and Nancy Fennern founded the store, and their daughter Allison now leads sales operations.
Do you create custom jewelry designs?
Yes, we specialize in custom jewelry design. Our team works closely with clients to create unique pieces tailored to their preferences and occasions.
How long have you been in business?
We have been serving Baldwin, WI, since 1983. Our family's jewelry expertise spans over 50 years, including Eric Fennern's parents' store in Amery, WI.
Can you repair watches?
Yes, we offer comprehensive watch repair services, including battery replacement, movement repair, and water resistance testing, performed by our Certified Master Watchmaker.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Baldwin, WI, and surrounding communities, providing both in-store and local customer support for all jewelry and watch needs.
Reviews (4)
Jana Engle
Nov 24, 2021 Report
Great local jeweler. Always willing to order anything for you and is usually available to pick up within a week or so.
Stephen Clausen
Nov 15, 2021 Report
A wonderful trip back to a time when merchants actually listened to the customers and appreciated their business.
Renee Kessel
Aug 03, 2021 Report
I don't visit this store nearly often enough. Always friendly and informative service with a smile. Highly recommend
Becky Apold
Dec 21, 2020 Report
They were very helpful and pleasant to talk with. Willing to look information up. Some of the nicest professionals I have ever dealt with.