Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
34 Years
experience
Custom Jewelry & Fine Watches in Middleton, WI
Chalmers Jewelers has been celebrating life's happiest moments since 1992, offering unparalleled expertise in custom jewelry design and fine timepieces. Our team combines decades of experience with cutting-edge CAD technology to transform personal visions into exquisite wearable art. We maintain rigorous quality standards through our Accredited Gem Lab, which performs gemological testing and appraisals as set forth by the American Gem Society. Our commitment to ethical practices is demonstrated through our participation in the Kimberley Process for conflict-free diamonds and our use of 100% recycled gold and silver certified by SCS Global.

With two Wisconsin locations in Middleton and Madison, we provide personalized service that prioritizes customer satisfaction through transparent communication, flexible financing options, and meticulous attention to detail in every custom creation.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Fine Jewelry Watch Sales
Details
  • Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
  • We offer a proprietary custom design process with CAD visualization and wax modeling
  • Our team maintains American Gem Society accredited gemological testing capabilities
  • We guarantee conflict-free diamonds through Kimberley Process-certified suppliers
  • Our jewelers use 100% recycled precious metals verified by SCS Global certification
  • We provide in-house financing options for all jewelry purchases
Associations and certifications
  • American Gem Society
  • Kimberley Process
  • SCS Global
What people say
Knowledgeable staff Great selection Custom design process Pressure-free environment Exceptional attention to detail
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Our proprietary design process transforms personal visions into unique jewelry pieces through six structured stages. Customers collaborate with designers using CAD software for 3D visualization, followed by wax modeling and precious metal casting. The process concludes with hand-setting of stones under 40x magnification and final polishing. This service accommodates complete customization of engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry while maintaining ethical sourcing standards.
Engagement Rings
We offer extensive selection of engagement rings ranging from classic solitaires to contemporary designs. Our inventory includes diamond settings from renowned designers like FANA and Sylvie, with options for custom modifications. The service includes diamond certification, metal purity verification, and personalized engraving options. Customers receive comprehensive guidance through the selection process with no-pressure consultation.
Wedding Bands
Our wedding band collection features traditional and modern designs in various precious metals including platinum, gold, and palladium. The service includes custom band creation with specialized finishes like milgrain edging and hand engraving. We offer matching sets for couples with options for both contemporary and vintage-inspired styles, available in standard and custom widths.
Fine Jewelry
The fine jewelry collection includes necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and fashion rings from established designers such as John Hardy and Montblanc. Pieces feature certified gemstones and precious metals with documentation of ethical sourcing. The service includes jewelry appraisal, cleaning, and maintenance programs for long-term care of valuable pieces.
Watch Sales
Our watch department carries premium brands including Ball Watch and Raymond Weil, featuring mechanical and quartz movements in various styles. The service includes watch authentication, warranty registration, and after-sales maintenance through authorized service centers. Inventory spans aviation-inspired chronographs, dive watches, and dress timepieces with complications.
Questions
What is the custom jewelry design process?
Our six-step process includes consultation, CAD visualization, wax modeling, metal casting, stone setting, and final finishing. The entire process typically takes less than four weeks with multiple review opportunities.
Do you offer jewelry appraisals?
Yes, our Accredited Gem Lab provides professional appraisal services using American Gem Society standards for insurance and valuation purposes.
Are your diamonds ethically sourced?
All diamonds come through Kimberley Process-certified suppliers to guarantee conflict-free origins, with documentation available for verification.
What payment options are available?
We offer in-house financing options and accept major credit cards for all jewelry purchases and services.
What are your store hours?
Middleton location: Mon-Fri 10am-6pm, Sat 10am-5pm. Madison location: Mon-Fri 11am-6pm, Sat 10am-5pm. Both closed Sundays.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Stacie Clark
Dec 31, 2021 Report
They are great to work with! They aren't typical salespeople. They made me feel really comfortable in a situation where I normally do not because they don't act like making a sale is all-important to them. They educated me about gemstones and are going to design a custom ring for a very reasonable price. They could use more organization.
Chad Haanen
Dec 20, 2021 Report
No returns on non-custom made jewelry that was never worn is pretty low. Hasn't been 30 days and now I'm stuck trying to peddle this thing that they had just sitting on a shelf. Honestly very disappointing and felt like a kick in the face while I was already down.
Honestly would have been happy with 80% back. I went there because my family has a long tradition of getting our rings there. That tradition is over.
Also, dishonest. Store manager lied to me about exchange policy. He claimed I could exchange for full value, only to change his story later over the phone said only half value. These guys
Matt Quirt
Dec 19, 2021 Report
Chalmers has always been my go to place for jewelry. On top of the gorgeous pieces, the staff goes above and beyond to ensure you have a great experience. Thank you for everything!
Bradley Rhode
Dec 17, 2021 Report
Growing up around the Madison area, we have all heard the ad "Chalmers Jewelers....in Middleton" My recent experience was with the Madison East location but the employee that did amazing was from the Middleton location for the day. I guess lucky me as he was extremely helpful, polite and outgoing. I needed a watch band resized that wasn't… purchased there and is a high end watch. I had already tried a local, chain type jewelry store and they tried but got pins stuck and the watch was unwearable. One call to Chalmers and William was happy to help. He was able to reassure me that if I brought
Dawn Judd
Dec 14, 2021 Report
Was able to create and design 2 pendants from an heirloom ring. I received them within 2 weeks, and absolutely love them! Thank you for the amazing service!