Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
34 Years
experience
Objective Financial Advisers in Chicago
Founded in 1992, Mentor Capital Management has dedicated itself to providing objective financial advice free from conflicts of interest. Our firm operates exclusively on client-paid fees for financial planning and investment advisory services, ensuring our recommendations prioritize client interests above all else. With over 25 years of experience managing client investments and $200 million under management, we specialize in crafting tailored strategies for wealth preservation, tax optimization, and retirement planning. Our team of certified professionalsincluding CFPs, CPAs, and FINRA-licensed advisorsbrings decades of combined expertise in navigating complex financial landscapes.

We adhere to a strict fiduciary oath, focusing on long-term client relationships built through transparent communication and data-driven decision-making. Our investment philosophy emphasizes disciplined asset allocation, cost efficiency, and emotional restraint to maximize portfolio performance. We serve both individual clients and small-business owners, addressing unique challenges through comprehensive financial planning and succession strategies. Our commitment to continuous education and ethical standards positions us as trusted partners in achieving financial objectives across generations.
Services
Investment Management Financial Planning Small-Business Services Tax Planning Retirement Planning
Details
  • Year established: 1992
Highlights and features
  • We operate exclusively on client-paid fees with no product sales conflicts
  • Our team includes CFP, CPA, and FINRA-certified professionals
  • 25+ years managing client investments with $200M under management
  • We adhere to a strict fiduciary oath for all client relationships
  • Our data-driven investment philosophy minimizes emotional decision-making
Associations and certifications
  • SEC Registered Investment Advisor
  • CFP Board
  • FINRA
Services
Investment Management
Our investment management service focuses on creating diversified portfolios aligned with client risk tolerance and financial goals. We employ evidence-based strategies emphasizing asset allocation, cost efficiency, and long-term market trends. With over 25 years of experience managing $200 million in assets, we help clients minimize risk while optimizing returns through disciplined rebalancing and tax-efficient investing.
Financial Planning
We develop comprehensive financial plans addressing tax optimization, retirement strategies, and estate planning. Our approach combines cash flow analysis, risk management, and investment planning to create personalized roadmaps toward financial independence. We help clients navigate complex decisions about education funding, home purchases, and wealth transfer while maintaining flexibility for life changes.
Small-Business Services
Our small-business services address retirement planning, succession strategies, and employee benefit optimization. We help business owners select appropriate retirement plans, structure succession transitions, and implement tax-efficient compensation strategies. Our fiduciary approach ensures recommendations focus on both business sustainability and owner financial security during and after business ownership.
People
Daniel B. Carey
President
Daniel B. Carey, CFP, serves as President and Chief Compliance Officer of Mentor Capital Management. With over 20 years in financial advisory, he specializes in wealth management and investment strategy. A Notre Dame graduate and former SEC-registered advisor, he focuses on comprehensive financial planning for individuals and families.
Sarah Bodach
Operations Manager
Sarah Bodach, FPQP, serves as Operations Manager and Paraplanner at Mentor Capital. With FINRA Series 65 certification, she supports client service operations and financial planning processes. Her background in communication and logistics brings organizational expertise to client relationship management and investment implementation.
Daniel G. Kaster
Director of Tax
Daniel G. Kaster, CPA, leads tax strategy at Mentor Capital Management. With Silicon Valley public accounting experience, he specializes in high-net-worth tax planning and investment coordination. His expertise includes stock option planning, compliance, and integrating tax considerations with broader wealth management strategies.
John S. Davis
Chief Mentor
John S. Davis founded Mentor Capital Management in 1992 and served as president for 31 years. As Chief Mentor, he guides advisor development based on decades of fee-only financial planning experience. His career spans roles at American Express and leadership positions in community organizations.
Questions
What makes Mentor Capital different from other financial advisors?
We operate as a fee-only fiduciary with no product sales conflicts, focusing solely on objective advice tailored to client needs.
What investment approach do you use?
We employ disciplined asset allocation strategies emphasizing cost efficiency, diversification, and long-term market trends to optimize portfolio performance.
Do you work with small business owners?
Yes, we provide specialized retirement planning, succession strategies, and tax optimization services for small-business owners and their employees.
What credentials do your advisors hold?
Our team includes Certified Financial Planners (CFP), Certified Public Accountants (CPA), and FINRA Series 65 licensed professionals.
How are your fees structured?
We use a transparent fee-only model based on assets under management, with no commissions or hidden charges.