Business Details
32 Years
experience
Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY
J & S Reeve Cottages has provided waterfront vacation rentals on Long Island's North Fork since 1994. Our family-owned business offers six uniquely designed cottages with self-catering amenities, accommodating up to six guests each. Each property features direct water access with complimentary kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards for exploring Peconic Bay. We maintain a three-acre property with meticulously landscaped gardens and prioritize thorough cleaning protocols between stays. Our on-site residency allows personalized guest support while maintaining a tranquil environment away from typical hotel settings.We emphasize local area expertise, offering guidance on nearby wineries, dining options, and recreational activities. Our commitment to cleanliness includes alcohol-based disinfectants for all surfaces and rigorous laundry cycles for linens and towels. The cottages feature modern conveniences including high-speed WiFi and fully equipped kitchens. We accommodate pets with designated fee structures and maintain seasonal availability calendars for flexible booking options. Our location provides convenient access to North Fork attractions while maintaining a peaceful retreat atmosphere.
Services
Waterfront Vacation Rentals
Self-Catering Cottages
Complimentary Water Activities
Pet-Friendly Stays
Local Area Guidance
Details
- Year established: 1994
Highlights and features
- We have operated waterfront cottages since 1994 with firsthand local knowledge
- Complimentary water equipment included with all rentals
- Pet-friendly accommodations with designated outdoor spaces
- On-site management ensures personalized guest support
- Thorough cleaning protocols using alcohol-based disinfectants
What people say
Tranquil waterfront setting
Clean accommodations
Complimentary water equipment
Personalized service
Convenient location
Services
Waterfront Vacation Rentals
Our waterfront cottages offer direct access to Peconic Bay with six unique accommodations. Each property sleeps 4-6 guests with two bedrooms and one bathroom. Modern amenities include full kitchens, screened-in porches, and high-speed WiFi. The three-acre property features landscaped gardens and designated pet areas.
Complimentary Water Activities
All guests receive free access to kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards for exploring Reeves Creek and Peconic Bay. No additional fees apply for water equipment usage. The property provides launch facilities and safety equipment for all water activities.
Self-Catering Cottages
Each cottage features fully equipped kitchens with cooking utensils, dishware, and refrigeration. Outdoor barbecue facilities available at all properties. Self-catering options allow guests to prepare meals while maintaining vacation flexibility.
Pet-Friendly Accommodations
We welcome pets with designated cottage options and outdoor spaces. Maximum two pets allowed per reservation with applicable fees. Pet-friendly amenities include designated relief areas and nearby walking trails.
Local Area Guidance
Our on-site management provides personalized recommendations for local wineries, restaurants, and attractions. Guests receive detailed information about nearby beaches, golf courses, and cultural sites. We offer transportation guidance for car rentals and public transit options.
People
Sandy Reeve
Co-Owner
Native Aquebogue resident with over 25 years of vacation rental experience. Provides personalized guest support and local area expertise. Manages day-to-day operations and guest communications.
John Reeve
Co-Owner
Longtime Aquebogue resident overseeing property maintenance and guest experience. Combines local knowledge with hospitality expertise. Available for guest assistance and property inquiries.
Questions
How do I book a cottage directly?
Visit our website to access live availability calendars and book securely online without third-party fees.
Are pets allowed in the cottages?
Yes, we accept up to two pets per reservation with applicable fees and designated cottage options.
What water activities are included?
All rentals include complimentary kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards for exploring Peconic Bay.
What nearby attractions are accessible?
We're near 40+ wineries, local beaches, golf courses, and North Fork attractions within 30 minutes.
What cleaning protocols are followed?
We use alcohol-based disinfectants for all surfaces and maintain rigorous laundry cycles for linens and towels.
Videos
Reviews (4)
Donna Soper Curran
Oct 25, 2021
Report
Had the pleasure of spending the weekend with my family here on 10/22. John was there when we came in and as well as to send us off. The tranquil well kept cottage on the beautiful farm was amazing. Waking up and stepping outside to the beautifully maintained yard along the Peconic was priceless. Can't wait to return next year.
Kang T.
Jun 10, 2021
Report
Beautiful and serene property. Super friendly and welcoming owners, John and Sandy. They keep the property nice and clean. Each cottage is like a mini home with a backyard and they are well-kept lawns and gardens. Some of the cottages are by the waterfront and the others are welcome to sit by the water as well. The pictures speak for a thousand words. I will be back.
Cathi Sauer Tramantano
May 15, 2021
Report
Such a peaceful setting. We rented Cottage 6 - the one bedroom. Cute and cozy decor. The grounds are lovely, with lounge chairs and picnic table behind each cottage. There are also lounge chairs at the waterfront. And kayaks, paddleboards and canoes available to use for free. The waterway is peaceful and quiet for kayaking. It is a very short ride into Mattituck and other areas. We would definitely give this a 5 star rating.
Claudia Cotarelo
May 09, 2021
Report
Enjoyed our stay at J&S. John and Sandy are gracious hosts. Quite ,serene space. Loved it. We’ll be back!