Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
25 Years
experience
Your Trusted Florida Keys Real Estate Agent
As a licensed Florida real estate agent since 2001, I have dedicated my career to helping clients navigate the unique real estate landscape of the Florida Keys. With over two decades of experience, I specialize in residential, commercial, and vacation property transactions across the Upper, Middle, and Lower Keys, including Key West. My commitment to client education is reflected in my weekly market reports, which have provided comprehensive market insights to buyers and sellers since 2008.

As a member of Coldwell Banker Schmitt's Elite Agent Circle and $250M Club, I combine industry expertise with personalized service, offering professional photography, aerial property views, and single-agency representation to ensure my clients' interests remain my top priority.
Services
Residential Sales Commercial Properties Vacation Rentals Market Analysis Property Management
Details
  • Year established: 2001
Highlights and features
  • We provide weekly market reports with actionable insights since 2008
  • Our single-agency representation prioritizes client interests above all
  • Professional aerial photography showcases properties in their best light
  • 20+ years of localized market expertise across all Florida Keys regions
  • Proven track record as top 100 agent in Coldwell Banker Schmitt's network
Associations and certifications
  • Coldwell Banker Schmitt Elite Agent Circle
  • $250M Club
What people say
Knowledgeable Responsive Professional Patient Excellent Communication
Services
Residential Sales
Specializing in Florida Keys residential property transactions, I leverage 20+ years of local market expertise to help homeowners maximize their investment returns. My comprehensive marketing strategy includes professional aerial photography, targeted online exposure across 740+ platforms, and personalized weekly listing updates. As a single-agency representative, I ensure sellers receive undivided advocacy throughout the sales process while buyers benefit from tailored property matching based on specific lifestyle requirements.
Commercial Properties
Navigating Florida Keys commercial real estate requires specialized knowledge of local zoning regulations and market trends. I provide strategic guidance for investors seeking income-generating properties, including vacation rentals and retail spaces. My services include detailed market analysis, ROI projections, and negotiation expertise to secure optimal terms. With access to exclusive listings and off-market opportunities, I help investors build diversified portfolios aligned with their financial goals.
Vacation Rentals
Whether acquiring a second home or investment property, my vacation rental expertise ensures clients understand both personal use benefits and income potential. I provide comparative market analyses, rental income projections, and property management guidance. My local market knowledge helps identify properties with strong rental demand in prime locations across the Florida Keys' most desirable communities.
Market Analysis
Accurate pricing is critical for successful real estate transactions. My comparative market analyses incorporate current MLS data, historical sales trends, and neighborhood-specific factors to determine optimal pricing strategies. Sellers receive weekly activity reports tracking showings and buyer feedback, while buyers gain insights into emerging market opportunities through my proprietary Friday Market Reports.
Property Management
For out-of-town investors, my property management services ensure optimal asset performance while minimizing owner involvement. Services include tenant screening, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting. I maintain detailed records of property performance metrics and market conditions to help owners make informed decisions about their Florida Keys real estate investments.
People
Amy Puto
Real Estate Agent
Licensed since 2001, Amy has been a top-producing agent in the Florida Keys, specializing in residential and commercial properties. She developed her expertise working with her mother before establishing her independent practice. A Coldwell Banker Schmitt Elite Agent Circle member, she provides personalized service and market insights through her weekly reports.
Questions
What areas of Florida Keys real estate do you specialize in?
I specialize in Upper, Middle, and Lower Keys properties including Islamorada, Marathon, Key West, and surrounding communities.
How do you help first-time buyers in the Florida Keys?
I provide personalized guidance through local market nuances, financing options, and property selection tailored to lifestyle needs.
What makes your seller services unique?
My single-agency representation ensures undivided advocacy, while weekly listing updates keep sellers informed about showings and market activity.
How can I track Florida Keys real estate market trends?
Subscribe to my Friday Market Report for comprehensive weekly updates on new listings, price changes, and sales activity.
Do you offer property photography services?
Yes, my husband Jerry provides professional photography and aerial views to showcase properties effectively.
What experience do you have with vacation rental properties?
I've helped numerous clients acquire and manage successful vacation rental investments across the Florida Keys.
Reviews (3)
Kathy Thomas
Jan 07, 2016 Report
Amy & her team are top notch! Amy and her partner (husband) took us out in the heat of July 100 degrees our more searching for our "vacation" home now, retirement later. We didn't find what we were looking for, but I enjoy getting weekly emails from her. Amy is very professional and dedicated to her search for us!! When we do find what we are looking for- Amy will be our person!!! Looking forward to working with her in the future!
Don S.
Oct 22, 2015 Report
Although I haven't bought yet, Amy has been doing a great job keeping me abreast of the entire keys market conditions, listings, sales, pricing, etc. She has also responded personally to any questions I've had. When I'm ready to get more serious about buying, Amy will be my realtor.
Don Scott
North Carolina
Brooke Jubb
Aug 27, 2015 Report
Amy is AWESOME! We have known and worked with Amy since 2010. She represented us when we bought our house and then when we sold it. She is so great to work with because she really knows the industry and the area inside and out. She comes across as low pressure which is really nice, but she really gets the job done! From the beginning I knew we could trust her. She got the deals done and to our satisfaction. On a personal note, she is just a really great person - warm, funny and caring. We really like her and consider her a friend. When we are ready to buy again in the Keys, we will definitely be