Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Tahlequah, OK
Meigs Jewelry has been a trusted name in Tahlequah for over 60 years, dedicated to creating meaningful experiences through exceptional jewelry services. Our family-owned business specializes in engagement rings, custom designs, and precision repairs, combining tradition with modern technology. With a full-time Master Jeweler and advanced tools like laser welders, we ensure every piece receives meticulous care. Our commitment to community values and personalized service has made us a cornerstone of Northeastern Oklahoma's jewelry industry.

We pride ourselves on transparency, offering free estimates and secure storage for repairs. From diamond education to bespoke creations, our knowledgeable team guides customers through every decision. As stewards of cultural heritage, we also curate the exclusive Igohida collection celebrating Cherokee traditions. With generations of experience, we continue to build lasting relationships through integrity and craftsmanship.
Services
Engagement Rings Custom Jewelry Jewelry Repairs Diamond Sales Jewelry Education Financing Options Igohida Collection Appraisals Watch Repairs Gemstone Settings
Highlights and features
  • We offer 60+ years of jewelry expertise with in-house Master Jewelers
  • Our laser welding technology enables precision repairs previously thought impossible
  • Custom designs created using computerized software and 3D modeling
  • Secure repair process with documented valuation and vault storage
  • Culturally significant Igohida collection celebrating Cherokee heritage
What people say
Exceptional service Quality craftsmanship Knowledgeable staff Beautiful jewelry Personalized experience
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement ring collection features meticulously curated diamonds with various settings and metal options. Customers receive expert guidance on the 4Cs of diamonds and setting styles like pave, halo, and solitaire. We offer both pre-designed collections and custom options to create unique symbols of commitment.
Custom Jewelry
Transform personal visions into reality through our custom jewelry process. Work directly with our Master Jeweler to develop concepts using computer-aided design software. We guide pieces from initial sketches to finished products, incorporating heirloom stones or creating entirely new designs with precision craftsmanship.
Jewelry Repairs
Professional repair services for all jewelry types using advanced laser welding technology. We document each piece's value before repairs, store items securely overnight, and offer both standard (1-week) and expedited (24-hour) service options while maintaining strict quality control throughout the process.
Jewelry Education
Comprehensive educational resources covering diamond characteristics, gemstone properties, and metal durability. Our staff provides guidance on purchasing decisions, care maintenance, and investment considerations through in-store consultations and online learning materials covering the 4Cs and jewelry history.
Igohida Collection
Exclusive line of Cherokee-inspired jewelry featuring welded bracelets and culturally significant designs. This collection celebrates Native American heritage through customizable pieces that symbolize enduring connections between loved ones, combining traditional meaning with contemporary styling.
People
Todd Mutzig
Owner
Third-generation jewelry professional with over 25 years of experience in Tahlequah. Specializes in customer relations and business operations while maintaining family traditions of community service and ethical business practices.
Paula Mutzig
Owner
Active community leader with extensive jewelry industry knowledge. Focuses on client experience and cultural initiatives, particularly the development of the Igohida collection celebrating Cherokee heritage and language preservation.
Justin Scott
Master Jeweler
Certified Master Jeweler with expertise in custom design and precision repairs. Utilizes advanced technology for both traditional and innovative jewelry creation, specializing in transforming conceptual ideas into wearable art through 3D modeling and laser welding techniques.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer?
We provide engagement rings, custom designs, jewelry repairs, appraisals, and the exclusive Igohida collection. Our services also include diamond education, financing options, and watch repairs.
Do you offer custom jewelry design?
Yes, our custom design process includes initial consultations with our Master Jeweler, computer-aided design, and hand-crafted production using both new materials and heirloom stones.
How long have you been in business?
We've served Tahlequah since 1962, combining over 60 years of tradition with modern jewelry technology while maintaining family-owned values and community focus.
What makes your repairs unique?
Our laser welding technology enables precision repairs previously impossible with traditional methods. We document each piece's value before repairs and store items securely overnight during the process.
Do you have financing options?
Yes, we offer financing plans to help customers purchase special jewelry pieces. Our staff can explain available payment options and help determine the best approach for your needs.
What areas do you serve?
Primarily serving Tahlequah and Northeastern Oklahoma, we also assist customers from surrounding regions through our online gallery and in-store appointments.
Reviews (6)
Missy Todd
Oct 26, 2021 Report
You cant find a better jeweler in the state of Oklahoma, in my opinion. Meigs always has a selection of very high quality items youd never assume finding in a privately owned hometown jewelry store. The owners, Todd and Paula are all hands on with their business. Which you just cant beat in todays world. There is no other jewelry store Id consider over Meigs.
Sherron Wilson
Jul 18, 2021 Report
I have made several purchases. The staff is ALWAYS very friendly and knowledgeable. The jewelry I have gotten is absolutely gorgeous. I couldn't ask for a nicer or friendlier place to do business. Thanks Meigs!!!!!
Nick Jones
Jun 26, 2021 Report
Meigs has always had quality pieces that dont disappoint. Recently, Debbie helped me with an anniversary gift. She messaged me asking if she could help, provided recommendations and had the gift wrapped and ready to go when I came in to pick it up. My wife was very happy with the choice, which I call a win! Debbie provided excellent service, I cant think of anything more she could have done!
Evelyn Stetzer
Mar 27, 2021 Report
My fianc and I worked remotely with Todd on the perfect engagement ring. Todd was extremely knowledgeable about how to select a diamond and setting and gave us a lot of direction that only a seasoned local jeweler could help with. From how the ring would work with my finger to picking the diamond shapes that would work with my style, Meigs Jewelry made the whole ring-buying process easy, relational, and the result was STUNNING. Beyond my wildest dreams.
Andrea Worden
Feb 11, 2021 Report
Meigs allowed me to exchange a gift and they made the process easy and pleasant. They also have a great selection of jewelry, many styles.
Joni Lyon
Sep 13, 2020 Report
I recently relocated to North Carolina and had lost my wedding ring during our move. I contacted them and asked if I could arrange a purchase by phone. They accommodated my request immediately and assisted me with the purchase of my new ring. It was super easy and quick. I used their website pictures and worked with staff through text and phone. I highly recommended Meigs whether you live local or out of state. The staff are awesome!