Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
8 Years
experience
Expert Property Management Services in Victor, NY
Established in 2018, The Key to Rentals is a full-service property management company serving Monroe, Ontario, and Wayne Counties. Our team combines over 30 years of real estate, lending, and property management expertise to protect and enhance investment properties. We specialize in marketing analysis, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting. Our services include electronic payment systems, security deposit administration, and owner portals for transparent financial tracking. We maintain strict compliance with Fair Housing laws and work with in-state, out-of-state, and international property owners.

Our commitment to quality is demonstrated through professional contractor partnerships and detailed property inspections. We require landlords insurance and provide comprehensive lease documentation. Our local market knowledge ensures properties are competitively priced and maintained to high standards. We offer flexible payment options including electronic funds transfer and check remittances. Our founder Paul Rowan personally oversees operations, ensuring personalized service and accountability.
Services
Property Management Tenant Screening Rent Collection Maintenance Coordination Financial Reporting Lease Documentation Market Analysis Property Inspections
Details
  • Year established: 2018
Highlights and features
  • We offer 30+ years of real estate management experience
  • Our electronic payment systems streamline rent collection
  • We provide detailed property inspections and maintenance coordination
  • Our owner portals enable transparent financial tracking
  • We serve in-state, out-of-state, and international property owners
Associations and certifications
  • NYS Licensed Real Estate Broker
What people say
Rented within a week Very professional User friendly website Fantastic experience Great follow through
Services
Property Management
We provide comprehensive property management for residential investments. Our services include marketing analysis, tenant placement, and financial administration. We handle day-to-day operations while maintaining legal compliance and property standards.
Tenant Screening
Our screening process verifies income, checks credit history, and conducts background investigations. We ensure tenants meet financial requirements and maintain property care standards through detailed applications.
Rent Collection
We offer electronic payment systems and traditional check remittances. Our portal tracks payments and generates reports while enforcing timely collection and distribution schedules.
Maintenance Coordination
We manage maintenance requests through trusted local contractors. Our system includes reserve funds for emergencies while requiring owners to plan for major replacement costs.
Financial Reporting
Our owner portal provides real-time financial tracking with customizable reports. We handle security deposit accounting and monthly payment distributions through secure electronic transfers.
People
Paul Rowan
Property Manager, Owner
Established The Key to Rentals in 2018 with over 30 years of real estate experience. Specializes in property management, investment protection, and tenant relations across upstate New York.
Questions
What property management services do you offer?
We provide tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, financial reporting, lease documentation, and property inspections for residential properties.
Which areas do you service?
We serve Monroe, Ontario, and Wayne Counties including Victor, Fairport, Pittsford, Brighton, and surrounding New York communities.
How does rent payment work?
Tenants can pay electronically through our portal or use cash payments at designated retail locations. Rent is due on the first of each month.
What tenant screening process do you use?
We conduct credit checks, background checks, and income verification for all applicants aged 18+ to ensure qualified tenants.
How are maintenance requests handled?
We coordinate repairs with local contractors and maintain $500 reserves for emergency maintenance while requiring owners to plan for major expenses.
Reviews (6)
Kyle Kirchgraber
Sep 23, 2021 Report
Professional, timely, and diligent with the properties managed. You can call/email with any concern and it will be handled promptly, along with any sort of "emergency" and he will be over to assist instantly. This is the exact way property managers should function!
Kelly Jutsum
Sep 14, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
We have had an excellent experience with Key to Rentals, especially with Paul who helped us out. He was responsive and flexible with timing and our situation (as we were moving from out of town); professional but kind, definitely the best experience I have ever had finding a place to live!
William Wunderle
Jun 09, 2021 Report
Being Active Duty Military I have rented through a lot of different agencies (more then 6). The Key to Rentals has been fare the best company I have worked with. Paul is not only the owner of the company but also the property manager. When I had issues with my rental it was taken care of fast. I would recommend everyone to use this company. Very professional 10/10.
Sheila Burns
Jan 18, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness
I have known Paul for many years and you can rely on him as a professional resource for property management. He is responsive, thorough, and timely with all aspects of his business. Highly recommend Paul if you need help with anything related to property management!
Lora Lee C.
Nov 23, 2020 Report
I chose to work with Paul and the team after a previous property manager let me down. What a delight! He gets back to me quickly, really knows his business and has been so helpful I look forward to many happy years with The Key to Rentals managing my property. Oh, his rates are fair as well. The online portal is perfect for me as an out of state landlord, I can easily see what is the status of repairs and rent payments. 10/10 would pick him again.
Kimberly Kwoka
Oct 17, 2020 Report
Paul from The Key to Rentals is the best! He is extremely professional and always puts his clients needs first. He makes sure properties are always property maintained and managed. Paul
is very responsible and tentative to his clients needs,
he addresses any concerns quickly and ensures they are handled properly. I highly recommend working with Paul at The Key to Rentals for any and all of your property management needs.