Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Trusted Jewelry Store & Repair Services in Decatur, IN
Eichhorn Jewelry has served Decatur, Indiana since August 5, 1965, when founder John Eichhorn established the business as a diamond specialist with the motto 'Always Think Diamonds.' As a family-owned enterprise, we have maintained generational continuity through Eileen Eichhorn, current president, and her sisters Kate Dyer and Laura Ditto, alongside nephew Matt Dyer. Our expertise spans custom jewelry design, estate collection curation, and comprehensive repair services, supported by two full-time Graduate Gemologists on staff. We specialize in transforming inherited or outdated jewelry into personalized creations while maintaining USPAP-compliant appraisal standards.

Through facility upgrades in 1999 and 2003, we expanded private diamond rooms and showrooms to better serve our local clientele and nationwide customers who continue patronage despite relocation. Our commitment to quality remains evident in services like hand engraving, pearl restringing, and ring removal/resizing that competitors have discontinued. With decades of collective experience, we uphold traditional craftsmanship while adapting to modern jewelry needs.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Gemstone Appraisal Watch Repair Pearl Restringing Jewelry Repair Estate Jewelry Sales Diamond Savings Plan Ear Piercing Gift Wrapping Layaway Services
Details
  • Year established: 1965
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1965 with generational jewelry expertise
  • Two Graduate Gemologists on staff for accurate valuations
  • USPAP-compliant appraisal reports for insurance purposes
  • Custom design transforming heirloom pieces into modern jewelry
  • Specialized repair services including ring removal and resizing
Associations and certifications
  • Graduate Gemologist (GIA)
  • National Association of Jewelry Appraisers
  • International Society of Appraisers
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Transform inherited or outdated jewelry into personalized pieces using existing gemstones or metals. Our designers work with yellow gold, white gold, rose gold, platinum, and silver to create modern designs while preserving sentimental value. Services include CAD modeling, wax prototyping, and hand fabrication for unique one-of-a-kind creations.
Gemstone Appraisal
USPAP-compliant appraisal services performed by Graduate Gemologists for insurance replacement, estate division, or liquidation purposes. We provide detailed reports on diamonds, colored gemstones, and precious metals with market value analysis updated every three years to reflect current pricing fluctuations in the jewelry industry.
Watch Repair
Comprehensive watch maintenance including battery replacement, crystal repair, band adjustments, and movement cleaning. Our technicians service all brands while maintaining original craftsmanship standards. Specialized repairs for vintage and luxury timepieces ensure continued functionality and value preservation for mechanical and quartz movements.
Pearl Restringing
Professional restringing service for pearl necklaces and bracelets using silk thread or durable cord. We replace clasps, knots between pearls, and restore original luster while maintaining proper tension. Complimentary service available for customers purchasing Orienta Start-Her Pearls with professional cleaning and maintenance recommendations included.
Jewelry Repair
Complete repair solutions for damaged jewelry including prong replacement, stone setting, resizing, and clasp repair. Our bench jewelers use traditional techniques to restore broken chains, cracked rings, and worn mountings while preserving structural integrity. Emergency ring removal and resizing services available for urgent situations.
People
Eileen Eichhorn
President
Third-generation jewelry expert with Graduate Gemologist certification and NAJA/ISA accreditations. Specializes in diamond grading and estate jewelry valuation while overseeing daily operations and customer service standards.
Matt Dyer
Sales Manager
Certified Graduate Gemologist managing sales operations and client consultations. Focuses on custom design projects and appraisal services while maintaining technical expertise in gemstone identification and market valuation.
Kate Dyer
Sales Associate
Experienced sales professional providing personalized jewelry selection assistance and customer support. Handles estate collection acquisitions and client communications while maintaining family business values.
Laura Ditto
Controller
Financial manager overseeing business operations and accounting functions. Ensures fiscal responsibility while supporting customer financing options and payment plan administration.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer?
We provide custom design, appraisals, watch repair, pearl restringing, jewelry repair, estate sales, and gift services with Graduate Gemologist expertise.
How can I get jewelry appraised?
Schedule an appointment with our certified appraisers for USPAP-compliant evaluations of diamonds, gemstones, and precious metals for insurance or estate purposes.
Do you repair broken jewelry?
Yes, our bench jewelers handle all repairs including resizing, stone replacement, clasp repair, and emergency ring removal with same-day service when possible.
Can you create custom jewelry?
Transform heirlooms into modern designs using your existing metals and stones. Our designers work with gold, platinum, and silver for personalized creations.
What payment options are available?
We offer layaway plans for non-sale items and accept major credit cards, checks, and cash for purchases and services.
Reviews (5)
Jolene Shutt
Sep 10, 2020 Report
The people there are very friendly , they make sure you love what your getting , they work well with you , very happy customer!!! thank you guys !! jolene and christopher shutt
Monica Davis
Feb 11, 2020 Report
These folks are honest, happy and helpful. I like giving the silver coins as gifts for baby showers and birthdays. I love being in the Diamond Clubs.
Christine Nix
Oct 31, 2019 Report
Very helpful, knowledgeable, friendly family! Amazingly beautiful pieces at very reasonable prices. Glad I found this little gem of a store recently! Definitely will be back.
Debbi Hoover Gerardot
Oct 29, 2019 Report
I took a vintage ring in to see if they could repair some of the filigree on the side, which was too thin to do anything with. they happened to have another vintage mounting that they were able to use with the top of my ring. it looks so great and is much nicer than my original mounting. Love it!
Lacey
Jul 13, 2019 Report
Unimpressed with the repair of my boyfriends watch, we sent his Invicta to Eichhorns to replace the glass, and a pin in the band was broken. Although they did have to send out for the glass, and that repair was satisfactory, the replacement of the pin was not. When receiving the watch after repairs were made, the link in the band where the pin was replaced was damaged, it looked as if the pin was hammered into the link, and the price of the repair was more than the watch itself, disappointing to say the least.
*Eichhorn did take back the watch to polish out the imperfections they made when