Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
25 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Goldsboro Since 2001
Since 2001, Alan Sutton Jewelry has been a family-owned and operated business dedicated to providing exceptional jewelry services and products. Our commitment to quality and ethical practices ensures customers receive not only the finest selections but also a trustworthy shopping experience. With on-site jewelry repair and custom design capabilities, our Master Bench Jeweler creates unique pieces and restores cherished heirlooms. We prioritize customer satisfaction through personalized service and a lifetime Preferred Warranty on engagement rings. Our expertise spans bridal jewelry, diamonds, watches, and fashion collections, all backed by decades of industry experience.

We maintain a strict ethical code emphasizing trust, honesty, and transparency in every transaction. Our team combines technical mastery with deep product knowledge to address all jewelry needs, from appraisals to repairs. As a locally rooted business, we understand the importance of community relationships and strive to exceed expectations in every interaction. Our physical store in Goldsboro, NC, complements our online presence, offering flexible shopping options while maintaining consistent service standards. Through continuous education and staying current with industry trends, we ensure our offerings remain relevant and valuable to customers.
Services
Jewelry Repairs Custom Designs Appraisals Engraving Financing Watch Repairs Diamond Sales Bridal Jewelry Gemstone Guide Insurance Services
Details
  • Year established: 2001
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 2001 with deep industry expertise
  • Ethical practices prioritizing trust and transparency
  • On-site Master Bench Jeweler for custom creations
  • Free lifetime Preferred Warranty on engagement rings
  • Comprehensive services from appraisals to repairs
Services
Jewelry Repairs
Our Master Bench Jeweler performs precise repairs for all jewelry types, from simple resizing to intricate heirloom restoration. Using advanced techniques, we ensure structural integrity while preserving aesthetic value. Customers receive detailed consultations about repair options and timelines.
Custom Designs
Transform ideas into unique jewelry through our custom design process. We collaborate closely with clients, offering CAD modeling and wax prototyping to visualize pieces before crafting. Services include metal selection, gemstone sourcing, and budget planning for personalized creations.
Diamond Sales
We offer certified diamonds with detailed grading reports, including natural and lab-grown options. Our inventory features various cuts, carat sizes, and settings. Customers receive expert guidance on diamond selection for engagement rings, investment pieces, or fashion jewelry.
Appraisals
Professional appraisals determine accurate insurance values for all jewelry types. Our certified appraisers document piece details, material composition, and market value using industry-standard evaluation methods for estate planning or insurance purposes.
Bridal Jewelry
Specializing in engagement rings, wedding bands, and bridal sets, we offer designer collections from ArtCarved and True Romance. Services include ring sizing, diamond matching, and coordination of bridal party jewelry with personalized service for special occasions.
Questions
What services does Alan Sutton Jewelry offer?
We provide jewelry sales, custom designs, repairs, appraisals, engraving, and financing options. Our expertise includes diamonds, engagement rings, wedding bands, and luxury watches.
Is the lifetime Preferred Warranty really free?
Yes, we offer a complimentary lifetime Preferred Warranty on all engagement ring purchases, covering maintenance and repairs to keep your piece in perfect condition.
Can you create custom jewelry pieces?
Our Master Bench Jeweler specializes in custom designs, transforming your ideas into unique, handcrafted jewelry while maintaining strict quality standards.
How do I schedule an appointment?
Visit our website or call (919) 734-1114 to schedule a personalized consultation for jewelry selection, repairs, or custom design discussions.
What about repair turnaround times?
Most repairs are completed within 1-2 weeks, depending on complexity. Our team provides detailed timelines and updates throughout the process.
Reviews (6)
Jessica Pee-Leuk
Jan 07, 2022 Report
My step dad bought me diamond earrings fir my 21st birthday here in December.Since we moved here he always say go here if we need anything but Alan Bailey messed my mom's engagement ring up that my step paid over $500 fix just a month ago instead of standing behind his bad repair he wants to blame my mom who only wore it twice since picking it… up.He talk bad to my step dad who has spent thousands of dollars in this store.We dont trust them fix right and they refuse to refund their bad work.Owner is aware of situation they can take my dad $ no problem when he buying something not same refunding
Anabella Hodsdon
Jan 07, 2022 Report
My fiancé bring my engagement ring there about a month ago pay them over $500 to fix diamonds start falling back out bring back an Allen Bailey man who fix talk down to my boyfriend for his bad work.Owner called my boyfriend to apologize want my boyfriend bring back an he will try to fix.My boyfriend don’t want go back because Allen Bailey not nice man just want refund so we get Jewelry store who knows how fix to fix it.
William Whitmire
Jan 05, 2022 Report
I had a ring fixed from them about a month ago spent over $500 no complaints took a couple a weeks to get back but they had to order exact diamonds to match.My girlfriend had one of the diamonds fall back out… take back today to see if they will put back in and they say it’s going be over a week or more to get back.Young man at front takes ring brings to back and tells me they will call when it ready but going be week or two.I get to my truck go back in because my girlfriend doesnt want to be without ring again for that long.I go back in ask young man to get my ring he brings it back
Sierra Williams
Jun 21, 2021 Report
You guys are my Hero's! My hands don't work very well and I bought a baby yoda necklace and it's a heavy charmed necklace. I bought two magnet clasps from Walmart, I'd barely touch the necklace and it would fall off. I took my necklace to you guys. Not only did you install a new clasp and magnetic closure, but you installed one that I can trust that comes with a clasp to assure the necklace stays on! Your customer service is absolutely outstanding! Your prices are more then fair. I am an extremely happy customer. Thank you so much for fixing my favorite necklace so I don't have to stress about
Jennifer Neher
Feb 13, 2021 Report
My husband and I have purchased many items from Alan Sutton. so much knowledge and talent! They have helped multiple times answering our questions and finding the perfect item. They are very honest people. Love the family atmosphere and feel so special everytime we walk in the door.
Diane Webber
Feb 02, 2021 Report
Thank you Alan for taking the time, your searching and finding me such a beautiful diamond for my 10 year anniversary gift from my husband. Your knowledge, honesty, integrity, and professionalism is always above reproach. I also want to thank your family and staff for always making me feel so special whenever I enter your beautiful store.