Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Storm Lake, IA
At Paxtons Jewelry, we combine decades of expertise with a passion for exceptional craftsmanship to deliver personalized jewelry solutions. Our team of seasoned professionals, including a graduate gemologist and experienced sales specialists, brings over 100 combined years of industry knowledge to every customer interaction. We pride ourselves on maintaining a curated selection of diamonds, gemstones, and fine jewelry that evolves with emerging trends while honoring timeless designs. Our commitment to community service and personalized attention ensures every client receives both quality products and meaningful service.With a focus on engagement rings, wedding bands, and custom pieces, we help customers celebrate life's milestones with enduring elegance. Our store's heritage, built on family values and technical expertise, positions us as a trusted advisor in jewelry selection and investment. Through transparent consultations and educational guidance, we empower customers to make informed decisions about their purchases. Our dedication to maintaining high ethical standards and exceptional customer care has solidified our reputation as a premier jewelry destination in northwest Iowa.
Services
Engagement Rings
Wedding Bands
Diamond Jewelry
Gemstone Collection
Custom Designs
Jewelry Repair
Appraisals
Estate Jewelry
Watch Sales
Gift Items
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- We offer 40+ years of combined experience in jewelry sales and design
- Our in-house graduate gemologist ensures expert product knowledge
- Family-owned business with deep community roots since 1975
- We maintain a diverse inventory from classic to contemporary styles
- Our team provides personalized, pressure-free shopping experiences
What people say
Excellent customer service
Great selection
Knowledgeable staff
Personalized attention
Beautiful designs
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement ring collection features classic solitaires, modern designs, and vintage-inspired pieces. Each ring is crafted with ethically sourced diamonds and precious metals. Our experts help couples find perfect symbols of commitment that match personal styles and budgets.
Custom Jewelry
We create one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces tailored to individual preferences. From concept sketches to final production, our designers work closely with clients to transform ideas into wearable art. This service includes remounting heirloom stones and creating unique anniversary bands.
Gemstone Jewelry
Our collection includes sapphires, rubies, emeralds, and specialty stones like opals and tourmalines. Each piece showcases natural beauty through expert cutting and setting techniques. We offer both ready-made collections and custom designs featuring colored gemstones.
Jewelry Repair
Our on-site jeweler provides professional repair services for all types of jewelry. Services include resizing, stone replacement, prong repair, and cleaning. We use advanced equipment to restore damaged pieces while maintaining their original integrity and value.
Appraisals
We offer accurate jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate planning, or personal knowledge. Our certified professionals use industry-standard evaluation methods to determine fair market value based on current gemological data and market conditions.
People
Rhonda
Sales Manager
With 40+ years in jewelry sales, Rhonda combines expertise with community leadership. She serves on Buena Vista County's board of supervisors and specializes in helping clients find meaningful diamond pieces.
Gary
Jeweler & Store Manager
A graduate gemologist with 50+ years experience, Gary provides expert guidance on gem selection. His technical knowledge ensures customers find quality pieces that match their budget and personal style.
Teresa
Sales Associate
With 19 years in jewelry sales, Teresa brings warmth and expertise to every customer interaction. Her attention to detail and passion for diamond jewelry make her a valuable member of our service team.
Kim
Sales Associate
Kim returned to the jewelry industry in 2022 with fresh perspective. She specializes in helping customers discover unexpected pieces that become cherished additions to their collections.
Yesica
Customer Service
Bilingual team member since 2023, Yesica helps diverse clients communicate their jewelry needs. Her language skills and friendly approach enhance our commitment to personalized service.
Questions
What types of jewelry do you specialize in?
We specialize in diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, gemstone jewelry, and custom designs. Our inventory includes both classic and contemporary pieces.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
Yes, our on-site jeweler provides repair services including resizing, stone replacement, and prong repair using professional equipment.
Can I get a custom jewelry design?
Yes, we offer custom design services where our experts work with you from concept to completion to create unique, personalized pieces.
Are financing options available?
Yes, we offer financing options to help make your jewelry purchase more accessible. Ask our team for details.
What are your business hours?
We're open Monday-Friday 9am-5:30pm, Saturday 9am-4pm, and closed on Sundays.
Do you provide jewelry appraisals?
Yes, we offer professional appraisal services for insurance or personal valuation purposes using industry-standard evaluation methods.
Reviews (4)
Susan Austin
Feb 20, 2021
Report
My sister took her wedding ring in to get her setting fixed around her diamond. Her husband was fixing it for her fo Valentines Day. Rhonda the clerk helping said it would be sent out and nothing to worry about. Well my sisters husband picked up the ring brought it home to her she said this is not my ring! They took it in today she said this is not my ring i want my ring back!! Rhonda stayed in the back room and would not come out. I assume they were talking to the owner an older man he would not produce her ring. The ring they gave wasnt even her size he just said he would size it? Why would
Katie Schwint
Feb 12, 2021
Report
Great customer service! I have purchased from them for many years. Recently had a small issue and immediately fixed and returned in a short amount of time.
Ashley WolfTornabane
Jul 15, 2020
Report
Paxtons was very helpful recently when I needed a gold chain for a gift! I'm social distancing due to covid, so they sent me pictures and answered questions over the phone before I purchased! Wonderful owners!
(the pendant is also from Paxtons, from years ago!)
(the pendant is also from Paxtons, from years ago!)
Jason Neely
Jun 15, 2020
Report
Very helpful chap that works there, not too terribly expensive either. Good selection of quality stuff.