Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Custom Jewelry & Fine Jewelry Store in Casper, WY
Fagan Diamond Jewelers has been serving the Casper, Wyoming community as a trusted local jewelry destination since our founding. Specializing in custom-designed fine jewelry and premium gemstones, we combine artistic craftsmanship with technical expertise to create meaningful pieces for life's milestones. Our team of skilled jewelers offers comprehensive services including engagement ring design, jewelry repair, gemstone replacement, and professional cleaning, all performed with meticulous attention to detail. We maintain a curated selection of high-quality diamonds, colored gemstones, and precious metal jewelry while prioritizing natural stones for superior durability and value. Committed to customer satisfaction, we provide a 30-day exchange policy, free repair estimates, and a layaway program to accommodate various budgets.

Through our personalized design consultations, we transform client visions into unique wearable art using advanced CAD technology and traditional goldsmithing techniques. Our dedication to quality extends to using only ethically sourced materials and maintaining rigorous craftsmanship standards that ensure lasting beauty. As a locally owned business, we emphasize community connections while offering nationwide access to specialty gems through our supplier network. Transparency remains central to our operations, with clear pricing and honest guidance throughout every customer interaction. This combination of technical proficiency, ethical practices, and personalized service has established us as a respected authority in the regional jewelry industry.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Engagement Rings Jewelry Repair Gemstone Replacement Watch Battery Replacement Jewelry Cleaning Ring Sizing Scrap Gold Trading Layaway Program 30-Day Exchange
Highlights and features
  • We offer custom jewelry design with CAD technology and traditional craftsmanship
  • Our 30-day no-questions-asked exchange program ensures customer satisfaction
  • Skilled jewelers provide same-day ring sizing and professional repairs
  • We use only natural gemstones for superior durability and value retention
  • Layaway program available for budget-friendly fine jewelry purchases
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Transform personal visions into unique wearable art through our collaborative design process. Using CAD technology and traditional goldsmithing, we create one-of-a-kind pieces from engagement rings to heirloom restorations. Our experts guide clients through material selection and design refinement to ensure perfect results.
Jewelry Repair
Professional restoration for damaged or worn pieces including clasp repair, retipping, and resizing. Our skilled technicians use precision tools to fix broken chains, replace settings, and reinforce structural integrity while preserving original craftsmanship and material quality.
Gemstone Replacement
Restore brilliance to jewelry with lost or damaged stones. We source exact matches or upgrade to premium alternatives from our extensive inventory of diamonds and colored gemstones. Expert setting techniques ensure secure placement and natural appearance.
Jewelry Cleaning
Deep cleaning services that remove buildup while protecting delicate settings. Our ultrasonic technology and manual polishing techniques revive luster and inspect for potential issues. Regular maintenance extends jewelry lifespan and maintains investment value.
Ring Sizing
Precise resizing for perfect fit using professional equipment that maintains band integrity. Available for both simple and complex designs, our jewelers complete most adjustments within 24 hours while preserving original craftsmanship and structural strength.
Questions
What jewelry design options do you offer?
We provide full custom design services using CAD technology plus carry a selection of fine jewelry featuring diamonds, colored gemstones, and precious metals.
Can you repair damaged jewelry?
Yes, our skilled jewelers perform all standard repairs including sizing, stone replacement, clasp repair, and structural reinforcement with same-day options available.
Do you offer financing options?
We provide a layaway program for budget-friendly purchases but don't offer traditional financing arrangements for jewelry purchases.
What gemstone quality do you use?
We exclusively use natural gemstones in our showroom for superior durability, value retention, and authentic beauty compared to synthetic alternatives.
Can I trade in old jewelry?
Yes, we buy scrap gold and allow trade-ins for store credit toward new purchases, repairs, or custom design projects.
What makes your jewelry store different?
As locally owned jewelers, we combine personalized service with technical expertise, offering custom design capabilities, quality guarantees, and community-focused business practices.
Videos
Reviews (6)
Jennifer Silva
Jan 19, 2021 Report
I broke my wedding ring at work. I brought it in and they were awesome. They took the time to walk me through my options and had the patience to explain everything to me. They are amazing.
Lynette Williams
Oct 10, 2020 Report
Fair price for labor. My rings were refurbished and replated stones tightened and for less than 1/3rd of the price offered everywhere else!
Mel Maerz
Jul 11, 2020 Report
You took your time to get it right,and I really appreciate that. You've done a GREAT JOB. And thank you.
Carolea Radke
Nov 22, 2018 Report
I buy all my jewelry hat Fagan diamond jewelers because I trust the quality of the jewelry as well as the integrity of the owner north again. She had a very precious ring that was my grandmothers that was crumbling from the metal is being so old and she told me I have a choice to lock it in the safe or put it in the picture window. But I wanted to wear it so she was able to make the ring an exact duplicate of the way it was originally. You can trust her with your diamonds and that youre getting great quality. Shes also very creative when it comes to designing jewelry if you want something
Derry Iglehart
Aug 27, 2018 Report
Had a ring repaired by Nora! Excellent job and price was very reasonable! I will enjoy having the pleasure to shop there
again.
Ursula Wilkerson
Jun 09, 2018 Report
This is by far the best quality, high end, custom and repair jewelry store in the State of Wyoming by far! Nora Fagan has been at it for decades and started from scratch. She is a fourth generation Wyomingite and helps us keep it local. What a talent she is and has gotten much help recently from her right hand man and talented jeweler himself. They make quite the team serving folks from all over the State and farther. It is like "Breakfast at Tiffany's" without the breakfast...that is across the street. When folks compliment my jewelry I always recommend Fagan Diamond Jewelry....they have more