Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
43 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Westbury, NY
From Italy With Love Jewelers has been a trusted family-owned jewelry destination on Long Island since 1983. Our team of experts brings decades of combined experience in curating exceptional pieces, from diamond engagement rings to designer timepieces. We pride ourselves on offering personalized service, ensuring every customer finds the perfect jewelry for life's most meaningful moments. Our affiliations with the Gemological Institute of America and the Better Business Bureau underscore our commitment to quality and ethical standards.

Whether you're seeking a custom creation or a classic design, our knowledgeable staff guides you through every step. With a legacy of excellence recognized by local communities, we remain dedicated to exceeding expectations through craftsmanship and care. Our extensive inventory includes bridal jewelry, fashion accessories, and luxury watches, catering to diverse tastes and occasions. By blending tradition with innovation, we continue to serve generations of customers who value integrity and artistry in every piece.
Services
Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Diamond Necklaces Timepieces Custom Jewelry Loose Diamonds Fashion Jewelry Bridal Sets Designer Watches Diamond Earrings
Details
  • Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1983 with deep roots in Long Island
  • Experts with combined 30+ years of jewelry experience
  • Affiliated with top industry organizations for quality assurance
  • Extensive selection of bridal, fashion, and luxury timepieces
  • Personalized service for custom and ready-to-wear jewelry
Associations and certifications
  • Jewelers of America
  • Gemological Institute of America
  • Jewelers Vigilance Committee
  • Better Business Bureau
What people say
Excellent customer service Beautiful selection Highly recommend Nail it Love them like family
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement rings feature hand-selected diamonds and premium metals, offering classic solitaires to modern halo designs. Each piece undergoes rigorous quality checks to ensure brilliance and durability. Expert consultants guide couples through customization options for a truly unique symbol of commitment.
Wedding Bands
From traditional gold bands to contemporary two-tone designs, our wedding bands complement every style. We offer matching sets for couples seeking coordinated pieces that reflect their shared journey. Durable materials and precise craftsmanship ensure lasting comfort and beauty.
Timepieces
We curate renowned watch brands like Movado and Bulova, combining functionality with timeless elegance. Our collection includes dress watches, sports models, and limited editions for collectors. Certified pre-owned options provide exceptional value for discerning buyers.
Custom Jewelry
Our custom design process transforms ideas into wearable art using CAD technology and hand-rendered sketches. Clients collaborate directly with artisans to create one-of-a-kind pieces from heirloom stones or new concepts. Full transparency in material sourcing and pricing ensures peace of mind.
Diamond Necklaces
Our diamond necklaces range from delicate chains to statement pendants featuring conflict-free stones. Each piece is crafted to maximize light performance while maintaining secure settings. Seasonal collections introduce fresh designs for special occasions and everyday wear.
Questions
What types of jewelry do you specialize in?
We specialize in engagement rings, wedding bands, diamond necklaces, luxury timepieces, and custom-designed jewelry for all occasions.
Do you offer jewelry repair services?
While our primary focus is retail jewelry sales, we can assist with basic maintenance and refer customers to trusted local repair specialists.
Can I get a custom jewelry design?
Yes! Our designers create custom pieces using CAD technology and traditional craftsmanship. Schedule a consultation to discuss your vision.
What are your store hours?
We're open Monday-Saturday 10 AM-6 PM, Thursday until 8 PM. Closed Sundays and major holidays.
Do you provide diamond certification?
All our diamonds come with grading reports from reputable labs like GIA and IGI for transparency and value assurance.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, bank transfers, and financing options for qualified purchases. Cash payments welcome for in-store transactions.
Reviews (5)
Adam Garyn
Nov 03, 2021 Report
It was my first time at this jewelry store . I had a Seiko watch that need a pins for one end. This was so much better than going to maceys were I originally had bought the watch under a year. The repair was only $5 dollars from good and wonderful jeweler named Sarkis. Thank you I will be back.
Nicholas DiCamillo
Mar 30, 2021 Report
My parents have been going to this place for years and I recently purchased a wedding band for my fianc. They were extremely helpful throughout the process and got us exactly what we wanted. Wouldnt go anywhere else.
Brandon Abbott
Dec 30, 2020 Report
Jeff was great. My gold chain was broken and he was able to fix it and clean it up on the spot and was not looking for anything in return! Nice store inside would definitely recommend.
Adam S.
Jul 28, 2020 Report
Had to come here and leave a review for Ron. I had no idea what I was looking for in a wedding band but he helped me find something masculine, unique, and customized to my tastes, all at a good price. Even my fianc liked it so thats a good sign, Id highly recommend. Thanks Ron!
Philip Gauthier
Jul 26, 2020 Report
Jeff is the best. Shopping for engagement rings was 10x more overwhelming than I initially anticipated. However the chaos stopped the second I sat down with Jeff. From the moment I walked into the store I felt like I was welcomed and being taken seriously. Jeff walked me through every step of the process. I told him what my fianc liked and what I wanted and the rest was history. We picked out a perfect setting to start with and made some changes to it to make it perfect, picked out the diamond and that was it. The end result was an absolute perfect engagement ring that my fianc is obsessed