Business Details
44 Years
experience
Your Trusted Fine Dining Experience in Irving, NY
Founded in 1982 by the LaBarbera family, we have dedicated decades to perfecting Italian-American cuisine in Western New York. As owner and head chef, Jeff LaBarbera has cultivated long-standing relationships with premium distributors, ensuring top-quality ingredients reach our tables. Our menu features over 45 staple dishes complemented by daily rotating specials, blending tradition with innovation.With a storied history in the Silver Creek area, we prioritize exceptional service and a commitment to community. Our recent patio expansion reflects our adaptability while maintaining the warmth of our original 1982 vision. Every dish we serve embodies our philosophy that fine dining should be both accessible and unforgettable.
Services
Steak
Seafood
Italian Cuisine
Catering
Outdoor Dining
Details
- Year established: 1982
Highlights and features
- We offer decades of culinary expertise from our owner-chef Jeff LaBarbera.
- Our menu features over 45 staple dishes with rotating daily specials.
- We maintain direct relationships with premium ingredient suppliers.
- Our outdoor patio provides flexible dining options.
- We specialize in catering for private occasions.
Services
Steak
Our steak offerings feature premium cuts like ribeye, filet mignon, and prime rib, prepared with signature techniques. Each dish emphasizes quality sourcing and precise cooking methods. Customers enjoy bold flavors from house-seasoned rubs and house-made sauces.
Seafood
We serve Gulf shrimp, scallops, lobster tails, and seasonal local fish with creative preparations. Dishes include blackened, stuffed, and sauted options. Our seafood jambalaya and cioppino showcase regional influences.
Italian Cuisine
Our menu includes traditional Italian-American favorites like veal parmesan, chicken marsala, and house-made meatballs. Ingredients are sourced for authenticity, with attention to house-prepared sauces and pastas.
Catering
We provide full catering for private events with customized menus from our restaurant offerings. Services include delivery, setup, and staffing for occasions ranging from family gatherings to corporate events.
Outdoor Dining
Our newly opened patio offers al fresco dining with the same menu as our indoor restaurant. Tables are available on a first-come basis, with party size accommodations and waitlist options.
People
Jeff LaBarbera
Owner & Head Chef
Jeff LaBarbera has led The Colony Seafood and Steakhouse Seafood and Steakhouse since 1982, leveraging decades of culinary experience. He personally curates ingredient sourcing and develops daily specials while overseeing kitchen operations.
Questions
What type of cuisine do you offer?
We specialize in Italian-American cuisine with a focus on steak and seafood dishes.
Do you have outdoor seating options?
Yes, our patio is now open with first-come seating and party accommodations.
Are reservations available?
Reservations require direct phone contact as we don't accept online requests.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we provide full catering with customized menus for private events.
What are your business hours?
We're open daily from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM except Tuesdays.
Are there daily specials available?
Yes, our handwritten daily specials rotate regularly and feature creative dishes.
Reviews (7)
Carol Gizowski
Dec 23, 2021
Report
As always, the dinner was absolutely delicious. The service was outstanding. Looking forward to our next meal.
Debra Ehmke
Dec 05, 2021
Report
My husband had is annual Ehmke Well Drillers Christmas Dinner party there last night, and the food, the service and the atmosphere was beyond exceptional. 10 stars if that is possible.
Erica K.
Oct 31, 2021
Report
Great food, drinks and atmosphere! I just left that for another restaurant yesterday but it is very true for both!! I am lucky enough to have had the opportunity to enjoy both locations!!
Barbara Scofield
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Food was excellent and the dcor was lovely. Waitress knowledgeable and friendly. The prices were high so for us it will be just for special occasions.
Joe Wagner
Oct 02, 2021
Report
Service was slow. Waitress was nice but forgot my wife's French onion. Our dinners were both cold had to send back and even when they came back were still cold. Our bill was 170 bucks and for that price I would've thought it would be a lot better. We drove over an hour to this place because we read about it . Won't be back. Very disappointing!!
Peter Igielinski
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Food and service is always good at the Colony. There is a wide variety of menu items so it's hard to chose. But I am never disappointed.
Vicki Schneider
Sep 18, 2021
Report
The food is always tasty, the wait staff friendly, and the environment relaxing and spacious. Last time I was there, I ordered the barbecue ribs. They were especially tasty and tender. I’ve been thinking about them ever since.