Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Classic Italian Dining Since 1931 in Tuckahoe
Roma Restaurant has been a cornerstone of Tuckahoe, New York's culinary scene since May 1931, when it was founded by George Tavolilla. Our establishment has evolved through three generations of family stewardship, with John Tavolilla expanding our reputation before passing the torch to his sons, Michael and John. We specialize in classic Italian cuisine, offering a diverse menu that includes salads, appetizers, seafood, steaks, chops, pasta, nightly Blackboard Specials, and our signature brick oven pizza. Our commitment to consistency, excellent food, and reasonable prices has made us a beloved destination for both locals and visitors.

We welcome families and accommodate parties of all sizes in our two large dining rooms and cozy bar area. Our takeout services ensure our culinary traditions reach beyond our walls, while our catering division brings Roma's flavors to events across the region. For over eight decades, we've maintained active community involvement, fostering relationships that span generations of patrons. Our warm atmosphere and dedication to quality continue to define our identity as a family-owned institution. We remain committed to preserving the standards set by our founders while adapting to serve contemporary tastes.
Services
Italian Restaurant Catering Services Takeout Available Brick Oven Pizza Blackboard Specials
Details
  • Year established: 1931
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 80 years of authentic Italian culinary tradition.
  • Our menu features house-made brick oven pizza since inception.
  • Three generations of family ownership ensure consistent quality.
  • We provide catering services for events of all sizes.
  • Our Blackboard Specials showcase daily fresh, seasonal ingredients.
Services
Italian Restaurant
Roma Restaurant provides authentic Italian dining with a menu featuring house-made pasta, seafood, steaks, and nightly Blackboard Specials. Our warm atmosphere accommodates families and groups in two spacious dining rooms. Three generations of culinary expertise ensure consistent quality and traditional preparation methods.
Brick Oven Pizza
Our signature brick oven pizza features thin-crust recipes perfected since 1931. Using imported Italian ingredients and traditional baking methods, we create pizzas with distinctive flavor and texture. Customers nationwide enjoy our frozen pizzas shipped directly from Tuckahoe.
Catering Services
Roma Restaurant offers full-service catering for events ranging from family gatherings to corporate functions. Our menu includes classic Italian dishes scaled for any group size, with pricing options to suit various budgets while maintaining restaurant-quality presentation.
Takeout Available
All menu items are available for takeout, allowing customers to enjoy Roma's authentic Italian cuisine at home. Our packaging preserves food quality during transport, with special attention to maintaining optimal serving temperatures for pasta, pizza, and entrees.
Blackboard Specials
Daily Blackboard Specials highlight seasonal ingredients and traditional Italian preparations. These rotating offerings showcase our chefs' creativity while maintaining the restaurant's commitment to authentic flavors and quality standards established in 1931.
People
George Tavolilla
Founder
George Tavolilla established Roma Restaurant in 1931, creating a foundation for three generations of family ownership. His vision for authentic Italian cuisine shaped the restaurant's identity and community presence.
John Tavolilla
Former Owner
John Tavolilla expanded the restaurant's reputation through decades of dedicated service. He maintained his father's standards while growing the business into a regional dining destination before passing leadership to his sons.
Michael Tavolilla
Co-Owner
Michael Tavolilla represents the third generation of family ownership, continuing the tradition of quality Italian cuisine. He oversees daily operations while preserving the restaurant's historical integrity and community connections.
John Tavolilla
Co-Owner
John Tavolilla carries forward the family legacy as co-owner, maintaining the standards established by his grandfather and father. He focuses on customer relations and menu development while honoring traditional preparation methods.
Questions
When did Roma Restaurant open in Tuckahoe?
Roma Restaurant opened in May 1931 and has operated continuously at its Columbus Avenue location for over 90 years.
What type of cuisine does Roma Restaurant serve?
We specialize in classic Italian cuisine featuring house-made pasta, brick oven pizza, seafood, steaks, and traditional Italian entrees prepared using family recipes.
Are catering services available for special events?
Yes, our catering division provides Italian cuisine for events ranging from small gatherings to large functions with customized menu options and pricing.
What are Roma Restaurant's operating hours?
We're open Tuesday through Sunday from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM, with Monday designated as our weekly closing day for staff rest and preparation.
Can I order food for takeout?
All menu items are available for takeout with packaging designed to maintain quality during transport while preserving optimal serving temperatures.
Reviews (7)
Thom
Jan 01, 2022 Report
We stopped by after paying our respects at a funeral home down the road, have not been in the area for over 15 years (at least)... and the pizza was still as great as we remembered!!!
Gerri
Dec 03, 2021 Report
Last night we had pepperoni pizza and it was absolutely delicious. Thin crust and amazing. Can't wait to go back again
Paul Juliano
Nov 29, 2021 Report
I have taken so many people who are not from the area to Romas to show them my view on what thin crust pizza should taste like. Romas never dissapoints while their food is great its the pizza that is their staple. The slices themselves are small (as they should be) because they dont serve single slices, you have to buy a pie and you will likely be able to eat the whole thing, even when Im full from the pie I still find myself eating slices because there just that good. If you like onions I strongly recommend an onion pie. Unlike other places that just throw raw Onion on pizza this place chops the
Danielle D.
Sep 22, 2021 Report
Would rate 0/5 stars if Google gave me the opportunity. My family and I used to love going there however this past weekend we had a HORRIBLE experience with the waitress- she had gave my grandmother an attitude from the start, forgot an order for someone in my party AND over charged us (added 3 extra drinks, good thing we checked). When my cousin went back in to correct the bill - the owner came out and said dont come back here! Just wow! Please do not go if you are looking for a nice, enjoyable dinner/experience!!
Mary Westmoreland
Jan 23, 2021 Report
Huge portions of delicious fresh Italian homemade meals. Perfect meeting place for family and friends to eat. Plenty of parking. Very accommodating to special menu requests.
Kent F.
Jan 12, 2021 Report
Best pizza ever! Better than Naples, Italy. Over 80 years of experience handed down over 3 generation. Romas signature Thin crust pizza is always cooked to perfection.
Mrs. Cassidy
Dec 02, 2020 Report
Love, love, love this place! Pizza is to die for. Thin with a flavorful sauce. The Caesar salad is delicious with an abundance of cheese and the dressing is perfect. I highly recommend the clams oreganatta,.The waitstaff is friendly, and attentive, as are the owners. You are made to feel very welcome, like family. Have been going here for years and am so glad they have remained a staple in Tuckahoe,