Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Dining & Takeout in Montrose, PA
At Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria, we take pride in delivering a dining experience rooted in family tradition and decades of culinary expertise. Founded in 1991 by Wendy and Tony Bartok, our establishment reflects a lifelong dedication to quality food and hospitality. After a 10-year hiatus focused on family and diverse business ventures, we reopened in 2013 with a renewed vision to combine our extensive industry knowledge with a passion for homemade Italian cuisine. Our renovated space and carefully crafted menu showcase our commitment to excellence, while our market expansion in 2020 demonstrates adaptability without compromising our core values.

We prioritize fresh ingredients, personalized service, and creating an environment where customers feel at home. With over 30 years in the restaurant industry, we bring proven expertise to every dish we prepare. Our approach balances tradition with innovation, ensuring both classic favorites and modern conveniences like our grab-and-go market options. Transparency in sourcing, preparation, and customer communication remains central to our operations. We measure success through customer satisfaction and the trust our community places in our family-run business.
Services
Pizza Wings Subs Catering Frozen Meals Salads Burgers Wraps Pasta Calzones
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • 30+ years combined experience in the restaurant industry
  • Homemade recipes using quality ingredients
  • Family-friendly atmosphere with diverse menu options
  • Convenient fresh/frozen market items available daily
  • Flexible catering services for events
What people say
Amazing homemade taste Perfect family portions Friendly staff Great catering options Consistent quality
Services
New York Style Pizza
Our signature pizza features hand-tossed dough topped with homemade sauce and quality cheeses. Available in multiple sizes with customizable toppings, this classic dish combines traditional techniques with modern flavors. Perfect for pizza enthusiasts seeking authentic taste.
Family Style Entrees
Serving 5-20 people, these hearty platters feature baked pasta, meats, and sides. Ideal for gatherings, they showcase our kitchen's versatility and portion control expertise. Requires 3-day advance notice for preparation.
Fresh Market Items
Chilled and frozen ready-to-eat options include pizzas, salads, and weekly specials. Designed for convenience without sacrificing quality, these meals maintain restaurant-grade standards for home consumption.
Wings
Available in traditional or boneless varieties with multiple sauce options. Served with celery and choice of dressing, these wings demonstrate our attention to classic pub fare preparation techniques.
Sub Sandwiches
8-inch sub rolls filled with meats, cheeses, and fresh vegetables. These sandwiches highlight our commitment to quality ingredients through house-roasted meats and homemade dressings.
People
Wendy Bartok
Co-Owner
Co-founder with 30+ years in the restaurant industry, Wendy brings expertise in operations and customer service. She graduated from Elk Lake High School in 1986 and has worked in food service since her teens.
Tony Bartok
Co-Owner
Co-founder and Montrose Area High School graduate (1985), Tony has decades of restaurant experience. He oversees kitchen operations and maintains the establishment's culinary standards since opening in 1991.
Questions
What catering options are available?
We offer family-style entrees serving 5-20 people with 3-day advance notice. Options include pasta dishes, meats, and sides.
Are gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer a gluten-free pizza option with certified GF dough, though cross-contamination may occur with other ingredients.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Wednesday-Thursday 11am-7pm, Friday-Saturday 11am-8pm. Closed Sundays through Tuesdays.
Do you offer takeout and delivery?
Yes, we provide takeout daily. Delivery availability should be confirmed by calling our main phone number.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover for all in-house and phone orders.
Reviews (5)
Ro Forrest
Oct 30, 2021 Report
Just driving by and decided to stop for lunch. Ordered burgers and some of those delish garlic fries. Great burgers! And those garlic fries ..you get your money's worth. Noticed freezers full of prepared food for popping in the oven at home. The folks behind the counter are friendly, helpful and pleasant.. Don't miss this experience.
Linda Short
Jul 23, 2021 Report
Great service food and service. Didn't realize they didn't have dine in but they offer picnic tables which was nice.
Alphascrub
Apr 25, 2021 Report
Pizza is ok. Prices are moderate for local restaurants. Their wings and none pizza food is honest better than the pizza. They do off a cold section where you can purchase decent quality meals to heat up or finish cooking yourself. Their daily menu options aren't bad either. I would honestly rate it higher if you could order more of its menu after 2pm.
Steven Yetter
Jul 30, 2020 Report
Great food and prices. Their menu offers a variety of dishes and they have some of the best pizza in the area. The people there are extremely friendly and make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in until the time they say goodbye and tell you to "watch your step". I love this place.
David S. Channin Md
Jan 04, 2020 Report
Small, clean, quiet, neighborhood Italian restaurant with pretty darn good food. Large portions for the most part; available in half servings, too. Very fast and friendly service. BYOB! Modest prices. Very popular with the locals.