Business Details
Trusted Property Management Services in Mishawaka, IN
Choice Property Management has been dedicated to delivering exceptional property management solutions since our inception. With over 25 years of industry experience, our team of certified professionals specializes in residential, multi-family, and commercial property management, ensuring properties are maintained to the highest standards while maximizing investment returns. Our founder, Jackie Stevenson, brings extensive expertise from roles at leading real estate firms and hospitality organizations, combining strategic insight with hands-on operational excellence.We prioritize transparent communication, rigorous tenant screening, and cost-effective maintenance to provide property owners with peace of mind. Our commitment to ethical practices and client satisfaction has earned us recognition, including the Certified Property Manager of the Year Award and multiple community service accolades. By treating every property as if it were our own, we help clients achieve financial health and long-term success in real estate investment.
Services
Residential Property Management
Multi-Family Property Management
Commercial Property Management
Tenant Screening
Maintenance Services
Accounting & Reporting
Eviction Management
Leasing Services
Property Inspections
Rent Collection
Highlights and features
- We offer 25+ years of combined experience in real estate and hospitality management.
- Our team includes Certified Property Managers with rigorous industry credentials.
- We implement tailored solutions to maximize property value and owner returns.
- Our transparent communication ensures clients are always informed and involved.
- We maintain strong community ties through local vendor partnerships and service.
Associations and certifications
- Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM)
What people say
Exceeded expectations
Efficient and courteous
Creative sales programs
Superior work ethic
Positive attitude
Services
Residential Property Management
We manage single-family residential properties with comprehensive services including tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting. Our goal is to protect property value while ensuring steady returns for owners. Certified professionals handle day-to-day operations to provide peace of mind.
Multi-Family Property Management
Specializing in HOA and apartment communities, we maintain property standards, enforce fair resident policies, and optimize operational efficiency. Our team ensures compliance with regulations while fostering positive tenant relationships to preserve community integrity and investment value.
Commercial Property Management
We oversee commercial portfolios of all sizes, focusing on preserving asset value and increasing net operating income. Services include lease administration, vendor coordination, financial management, and property marketing tailored to diverse commercial real estate needs.
Tenant Screening
Our rigorous screening process evaluates credit history, rental background, and income verification to identify qualified tenants. This reduces risk for property owners while ensuring compliance with fair housing laws and maintaining high occupancy standards.
Maintenance Services
We coordinate cost-effective maintenance and emergency repairs using trusted local vendors. Proactive inspections and prompt response to tenant requests help prevent costly issues and maintain property condition for long-term value.
People
Jackie Stevenson
CEO and Founder
Certified Property Manager with 25+ years of experience in real estate and hospitality management. Former executive at CB Richard Ellis and Tharaldson Lodging Company, recognized for leadership excellence and community service.
Questions
What types of properties do you manage?
We manage residential single-family homes, multi-family apartment communities, and commercial properties including retail and office spaces.
How do you screen tenants?
We conduct credit checks, verify income (requiring 2x monthly rent), confirm rental history, and check eviction records to ensure qualified tenants.
What fees are associated with renting?
There's a $50 non-refundable application fee per applicant and a security deposit typically equal to one month's rent.
Are pets allowed in rental properties?
Some properties permit pets with a $500 refundable deposit, but certain breeds are restricted. Multi-family units generally do not allow pets.
What maintenance services do you provide?
We coordinate routine maintenance, emergency repairs, and property inspections using qualified local contractors to ensure timely, cost-effective solutions.
Reviews (5)
Linda Redmond
Oct 16, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality
Personal & professional this company gives it's customers A-1 service highly recommend.
Personal & professional this company gives it's customers A-1 service highly recommend.
Patricia Ervin
Sep 26, 2021
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Jackie takes her job seriously and does her best to accommodate her clients, Since Inlive in another state than my property, I rely heavily on a property manager to make sure the tenants keep the property up and she has done that for me. She also runs her business in a professional manner.
Jackie takes her job seriously and does her best to accommodate her clients, Since Inlive in another state than my property, I rely heavily on a property manager to make sure the tenants keep the property up and she has done that for me. She also runs her business in a professional manner.
Kacie Ewing
Sep 13, 2021
Report
Choice property management just took over our lease in the middle of September 2021. Our lease is over November 30th 2020. We had previously been renting from homeworks since December 2019 as we travel for my fiancs job in construction. Threw homeworks we had to pay a 12$ filter fee that was dropped by our house the 1st of every month. We paid our payment via direct deposit every month on time no issues. Our filter was dropped off every month and changed no issues. When transferring to choice management we received an email from homeworks letting us know of the new renters and that
Elizabeth Ianiero
Jul 03, 2021
Report
Jackie was the property manager for my mothers condo in South Bend. When my father passed away in March, we decided to sell the condo. My mother was not in a position to handle her business affairs, so I agreed to handle from Texas. When Jackie found out that we were interviewing realtors, she sent an emotional and unprofessional email to both my mother and me and then proceeded to give notice to discontinue property management one month before the lease was up. She has repeatedly ignored requests for the contact information for the tenants. I think Jackie is a reliable property manager, but
Jamin Hochstetler
Feb 01, 2021
Report
CPM is the first property management company I have worked with, and I could not be happier with my experience. Jackie is easy to work with, and her team takes care of any issues that arise. When one of my units needed to be renovated, they took care of every single detail while still asking for and respecting my input. They even worked with me to pay off my renovation costs with my monthly distributions instead of up front out of pocket which was great! Highly recommend!
