Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
20 Years
experience
Vintage & Estate Jewelry Store in Belmar, NJ
Belmar Jewelers was founded in 2006 with a commitment to providing exceptional jewelry services rooted in decades of expertise. Our owner, Joe Carl, has dedicated over 40 years to mastering the intricacies of vintage, antique, and estate jewelry, offering clients personalized guidance in selecting or selling treasured pieces. We specialize in curating a diverse collection spanning Victorian, Edwardian, Art Deco, and contemporary styles while delivering expert repairs, free Sunday appraisals, and competitive pricing. Our mission is to combine the warmth of a family-owned business with the precision of a seasoned professional, ensuring every customer receives transparent evaluations, no-obligation consultations, and meticulous craftsmanship.

Located in Belmar, New Jersey, we serve communities across Monmouth and Ocean Counties, offering both in-store and online shopping experiences through Etsy and Shopify platforms. From GIA-certified engagement rings to heirloom restoration, our services prioritize client education, ethical practices, and long-term relationships built on trust and integrity.
Services
Jewelry Appraisals Jewelry Repairs Gold & Silver Buying Vintage Jewelry Sales Watch Repairs
Details
  • Year established: 2006
Highlights and features
  • We offer 40+ years of specialized jewelry expertise.
  • Free Sunday 'Roadshow' style appraisals with no obligation.
  • Expert jewelry and watch repair services using precision techniques.
  • Extensive local service area covering Monmouth and Ocean Counties.
  • Curated collection includes GIA-certified diamonds and historical pieces.
What people say
Expert appraisals Unique vintage selection Knowledgeable staff Competitive pricing Free Sunday evaluations
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Our free Sunday 'Roadshow' style appraisals evaluate gold, diamonds, gemstones, and antiques with expert analysis of historical value and market worth. We provide written insurance appraisals updated to current standards, helping clients understand their assets without obligation. Services include family heirloom assessment and coin collection evaluations.
Jewelry Repairs
Expert repair services cover ring sizing, chain welding, clasp replacement, and gemstone setting. We refurbish worn pieces, restring pearls, and perform precision watch battery replacements. Our craftsmen handle delicate antique restorations while maintaining structural integrity and aesthetic value for all jewelry types.
Gold & Silver Buying
We purchase gold and silver jewelry, diamond pieces, luxury watches, and coin collections. Our no-pressure evaluations determine fair market value for items ranging from modern designs to historical artifacts. Customers receive immediate payment for accepted items following transparent, obligation-free consultations.
Vintage Jewelry Sales
Our curated inventory spans Victorian, Edwardian, Art Deco, and Mid-Century Modern eras, featuring GIA-certified diamonds and gemstone pieces. Online and in-store shopping options include engagement rings, wedding bands, and collectible items. We guarantee authenticity and provide historical context for every vintage and antique piece.
Watch Repairs
Comprehensive watch maintenance includes battery replacement, band adjustments, and mechanical repairs. We service luxury and heirloom timepieces using specialized tools to preserve functionality and value. Our technicians handle both modern and vintage watch models with precision craftsmanship.
People
Joe Carl
Owner
With over 40 years in the jewelry industry, Joe Carl established Belmar Jewelers to share his passion for historical jewelry. He specializes in identifying period-specific craftsmanship and has consulted for jewelers nationwide. His expertise ensures accurate valuations and personalized service for every client.
Questions
What jewelry eras do you specialize in?
We carry pieces from Victorian, Edwardian, Art Deco, Retro, and Mid-Century Modern periods, along with contemporary designs.
Do you offer free appraisals?
Yes, we provide free 'Roadshow' style appraisals every Sunday with no appointment needed or obligation to sell.
What services are available for broken jewelry?
We repair broken chains, replace clasps, resize rings, reset stones, and restore damaged antique pieces using professional techniques.
Can I sell gold or silver items?
Yes, we buy gold and silver jewelry, coins, and watches. Our experts evaluate items for fair market value payments.
Are your online shops different from the physical store?
Our Etsy and Shopify shops feature unique items separate from in-store inventory. Contact us to check availability for specific pieces.
What areas do you serve?
We serve all of Monmouth and Ocean Counties, including Belmar, Asbury Park, Red Bank, and Long Branch locations.
Reviews (7)
Mark Haviland
Jun 20, 2021 Report
Just a most wonderful store, when it comes to jewelry, and for watch repair and purchases. The exceptionally polite managers and staff are simply wonderful to deal with. It's like a throwback to the classic retail store, but in the best possible way.
Mary Rospos
Oct 08, 2019 Report
Belmar Jewelers is the best!!! A few years back, they appraised all my fine jewelry FOR FREE. A few dozen written appraisals completely free of charge!!! Today I went in to get some watch batteries replaced. Not only did he replace the battery on the watch I needed right away on the spot, but he refused to let me pay for it!!!! I can't say enough about the friendly over-the-top service! And their jewelry is exquisite!!!!! I would never shop anywhere else for jewelry!!!!
Sarah G.
Jan 21, 2019 Report
Joe and his team gave me a free appraisal of several pieces of gold jewelry and watches. They paid for the gold jewelry by weight. He and his staff have a friendly, relaxed attitude and happily provided information.

Belmar Jewelers has a beautiful selection of jewelry at all price ranges. Joe can describe how the quality of stone, metal and setting goes into the value of a vintage piece. Next time I need to purchase jewelry I will go to Belmar Jewelers first!
Jeff & Mary L.
Nov 30, 2017 Report
We purchased a vintage ring online from Belmar's Etsy shop for our 15th wedding anniversary, and it's absolutely gorgeous! I had wanted this ring for well over a year, and am even more in love with it now that it's on my finger. Highly recommend this shop!
Joe H.
Oct 15, 2017 Report
Honest and fair priced! I always trust Belmar Jewelers. Great and helpful staff too. Give them a try!
Susan L.
Jul 17, 2017 Report
I am only sorry that I did not find Belmar Jewelers sooner! I have received the best customer service, the most reliable jewelry repairs and most competent advice for the past few years. I urge everyone to find out for themselves.
Joe S.
Jan 25, 2017 Report
A wonderful place in the heart of quaint Belmar. !! Amazing friendly service!!! Great value!!!!I stopped in to buy something for my wife and sister for Christmas. They were busy but Karen and Joe were so nice and helpful, showing me different things and making suggestions (I'm a guy, you know?). I marveled at their selection of vintage jewelry. They also order pieces if what they have isn't quite what you're seeking. Will come back again and again!