Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Reedley, CA
Since 1922, Mennonite Insurance has served the Anabaptist community with competitively priced, superior insurance products and exceptional service. Our mission is rooted in the Christian principle of mutual aid, providing peace of mind through financial responsibility and personalized support. We specialize in home, auto, church, and property insurance tailored to Mennonite, Brethren in Christ, and other Anabaptist communities across California, Oregon, Washington, and Arizona. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our B++ (Good) rating from A.M. Best and decades of trusted service. We prioritize building genuine relationships, ensuring policyholders receive quality coverage and timely claims processing.Through partnerships with Mennonite Disaster Service and West Coast Mennonite Central Committee, we extend our mission of relief and community support. Our team of experienced agents, including bilingual specialists, offers personalized guidance to meet unique insurance needs. With offices in Reedley, California, we combine local expertise with a deep understanding of the values and traditions of the communities we serve. Our monthly newsletter keeps clients informed on insurance best practices and relevant updates. For generations, we have been the trusted choice for insurance solutions that align with faith-based principles and mutual care.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Church Insurance
Condo Insurance
Renters Insurance
Flood Insurance
Earthquake Insurance
Umbrella Coverage
Landlord Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1922
Highlights and features
- We have 102 years of experience serving Anabaptist communities with specialized insurance solutions.
- Our policies combine competitive pricing with B++-rated financial stability from A.M. Best.
- We offer bilingual support and culturally informed service for Mennonite and Brethren communities.
- Our claims process prioritizes prompt, compassionate resolution during times of need.
- We reinvest in community resilience through partnerships with Mennonite Disaster Service.
Associations and certifications
- A.M. Best B++ Rating
What people say
Great people, great services
Excellent auto quote
Check for referrals
Professional and caring
Reliable agent
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your home with customized policies covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability. Our plans include specialized options for mobile homes, second dwellings, and earthquake risks. We ensure financial security through A.M. Best-rated protection tailored to Anabaptist community values.
Church Insurance
Comprehensive coverage for churches including property damage, liability, and vehicle insurance. Policies address unique needs like volunteer protection and disaster recovery, supporting over 100 years of community service through partnerships with Mennonite Disaster Service.
Auto Insurance
Affordable auto and motorcycle insurance with flexible coverage options. Our policies include accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, and multi-policy discounts while maintaining alignment with faith-based principles of mutual responsibility.
Renters Insurance
Cost-effective protection for personal property and liability in rented residences. Policies cover theft, fire, and water damage with customizable limits, ensuring peace of mind for non-commercial renters in Anabaptist communities.
Flood Insurance
Specialized flood coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program. Policies protect against rising water damage for homes, churches, and properties in high-risk areas, with expert guidance on mitigation strategies.
People
Kevin Lucke
President/CEO
With 32 years of insurance experience, Kevin leads with expertise in claims, underwriting, and executive leadership. A graduate of George Fox University, he combines technical knowledge with community values to guide Mennonite Insurance's mission-driven approach.
Dalia Jimenez
Licensed Agent
Dalia brings 30+ years of insurance expertise, holding CISR designation and bilingual Spanish capabilities. She specializes in personalized policy solutions, focusing on property & casualty, life, and health insurance for Anabaptist communities.
Claudia Fletes
Licensed Agent
With 25 years in insurance, Claudia combines underwriting expertise with client-focused service. She prioritizes cost-effective solutions while maintaining deep connections within the Mennonite community through personalized policy guidance.
Yolanda Hernandez
Licensed Agent
A Fresno State graduate with 20+ years in insurance, Yolanda provides tailored coverage solutions. Her bilingual Spanish skills and CISR designation support comprehensive service for clients across California and the West Coast.
Marcus Mahling
Sales and Marketing
Marcus leverages diverse insurance experience from claims restoration to sales consulting. His community-focused approach builds relationships through educational outreach and customized insurance solutions for West Coast Anabaptist congregations.
Questions
What communities do you serve?
We specialize in insurance for Mennonite, Mennonite Brethren, Brethren in Christ, and other Anabaptist communities across California, Oregon, Washington, and Arizona.
How do I file a claim?
Report claims through our website or contact our Reedley office directly at (559) 638-2327 for prompt assistance with documentation and processing.
Do you offer bilingual support?
Yes, our team includes Spanish-speaking agents to provide accessible service for all policyholders in the communities we serve.
What insurance types are available?
We offer home, auto, church, condo, renters, flood, earthquake, and umbrella insurance, along with liability coverage for Anabaptist communities.
How does your mutual aid model work?
As a mutual insurance company, policyholders share in our financial success through competitive pricing and community reinvestment programs supporting disaster relief initiatives.
Can I get a referral bonus?
Yes, our referral program rewards you with cash payments when referred clients sign up for qualifying insurance policies through our agency.
Videos
Reviews (2)
Jennifer Powers
Aug 11, 2016
Report
Jerry is excellent over at Mennonite Insurance Services, Inc if you are looking for a auto quote in Reedley, CA there is a reliable agent for you!
Sheila H.
Jun 27, 2016
Report
I would like to express our gratitude to Mennonite Aid Plan for their swift response to a claim we were forced to file due to a burglary of our home while we were gone. We discovered our daughter's wedding rings were among the missing items, We were trying to determine what we should do since we figured it would take awhile to process and we knew the rings might have to be reordered and resized. We didn't have to make any decision. To our amazement Mennonite aid Plan processed the claim and we were able to replace the rings along with other items that were stolen. Mennonite Aid Plan
