Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Lititz, PA
Since 1890, Gibbel Insurance has served friends and neighbors in Lancaster County and beyond, providing personalized insurance solutions. Our experienced independent agents deliver competitive pricing, customized coverage, and dedicated service across personal and business insurance needs. As a fourth-generation, locally owned agency, we prioritize long-term relationships and community commitment while offering comprehensive protection options including health, life, auto, home, and commercial insurance.Our team combines decades of expertise with a client-centric approach to ensure clients receive tailored advice and reliable support. We actively educate clients on risk management through resources addressing common insurance misconceptions and industry-specific challenges. With office hours Monday-Friday 8am-5pm and appointments available evenings and Saturdays, we maintain accessibility while upholding our founding philosophy of personalized service and competitive pricing.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Business Insurance
Landlord Insurance
Flood Insurance
Employee Benefits
Rental Insurance
Boat Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer 125+ years of local insurance expertise and community knowledge
- Our team provides personalized service with competitive pricing comparisons
- We maintain relationships with top 30 insurance carriers for optimal coverage
- Fourth-generation family leadership ensures long-term commitment and stability
- We specialize in customized risk management solutions for unique exposures
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your primary residence with comprehensive coverage against property damage, liability claims, and personal belongings loss. Our policies include specialized options for secondary homes and rental properties. Our experienced agents help customize coverage limits and deductibles to match individual risk profiles while maintaining competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships.
Business Insurance
Safeguard commercial operations with tailored insurance packages covering property damage, liability, workers' compensation, and business interruption. We specialize in solutions for Pennsylvania's construction industry and small businesses needing health insurance options. Our agents provide risk assessments and policy comparisons to ensure adequate protection for diverse business exposures.
Auto Insurance
Secure liability and collision coverage for personal and commercial vehicles with customizable options for classic cars, motorcycles, and fleet management. Our independent agency compares rates across multiple providers to find cost-effective solutions while maintaining required coverage levels. We also assist with certificate of insurance requests and additional insured endorsements.
Life Insurance
Establish financial security for loved ones through term and permanent life insurance policies. Our agents evaluate individual needs to recommend appropriate coverage amounts and policy structures. We offer solutions for estate planning, final expense coverage, and business succession planning while emphasizing long-term value and policyholder protection.
Health Insurance
Access individual and group health insurance plans including specialized options for Pennsylvania small businesses. Our advisors help navigate coverage options, network providers, and premium costs to find suitable solutions. We provide ongoing support for policy renewals and changes in coverage requirements while emphasizing cost-effective healthcare protection.
People
Ethan Gibbel
President
Fourth-generation leader with over 25 years of insurance experience. Manages agency operations since 2010 while maintaining commitment to local service and community involvement. Focuses on maintaining family legacy of personalized insurance solutions.
Jim Gibbel
Former Managing Partner
Led agency operations from 1963-2010. Established foundation for current service standards during 47-year tenure. Mentored next generation leadership while expanding product offerings to meet evolving client needs.
Questions
How do I get an insurance quote?
Contact us via phone at 717-626-8555 or through our website's 'Get a Quote' feature. Our agents will assess your needs and provide customized options within one business day.
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide home, auto, life, health, business, landlord, flood, boat, motorcycle, and employee benefits insurance. Our independent agency offers policies from multiple carriers to meet diverse coverage needs.
How do I file a claim?
Submit a 24-hour claim request through our website or contact our office during business hours. Our team will guide you through documentation requirements and coordinate with insurers for timely resolution.
Do you offer after-hours service?
We provide appointments evenings and Saturdays by arrangement. Emergency claims assistance is available through our after-hours phone system for urgent situations.
How can I obtain a certificate of insurance?
Complete our online certificate request form or contact our office directly. Allow 48 hours for processing standard requests. Additional insured endorsements require carrier approval and may incur extra fees.
Reviews (7)
Alicia Labuski
Dec 28, 2021
Report
While purchasing a new home, Gibbel Insurance was recommended by my real estate agent. I was looking into two other agencies when I originally talked to Bill Barshinger about setting up a homeowner's policy. Bill was the only agent to get back to me in a timely manner and provide me with an affordable policy. During a time when everything is automatic and owned by large corporations, it is refreshing to work with a local company and talk to local people. While I hope I do not have to file any claims in the near future, I am confident that my future interactions with Gibbel Insurance will be as
Rebecca Spatz
Jun 19, 2021
Report
Gibbel Insurance has been our insurance agency/broker for more than 14 years. They have always been responsive and provided great customer service. Carol is absolutely the best! She takes the time to answer your questions, explain coverage options and keeps your interest in mind all while remaining calm & professional. Rates are competitive and customized coverages are provided.
Darylanne Boyle
Apr 25, 2021
Report
Ive used Gibbel Insurance for years and years. Always a great company to deal with and so professional! Today I had the pleasure to start my day with Beverly Leontis!! She emailed me reminding me of my upcoming auto policy renewal. She said she could save me hundreds and thats exactly what she did!! . My upcoming bill was $845.00 for 6 months... now its $495.00!! With the same company no less!! Happy Friday to me!! Beverly was absolutely wonderful !!! Worked most of her day on my policy with the utmost professionalism and knowledge and a wonderful personality!! Bev was my angel for
Synergy Auto
Jan 22, 2021
Report
The level of service I receive from Gibbel Insurance Agency exceeds that of any vendor I've worked with. The team is top notch, and I cannot recommend them highly enough.
Margaret Conner
Nov 02, 2020
Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness
Mr. Gibbel was able to assist me in both my auto and homeowners insurance needs for years. I recommend Gibbel Insurance Agency to everyone! They care about their customers and take the time to make sure all your needs are taken care of in a timely and professional matter.
Mr. Gibbel was able to assist me in both my auto and homeowners insurance needs for years. I recommend Gibbel Insurance Agency to everyone! They care about their customers and take the time to make sure all your needs are taken care of in a timely and professional matter.
Jack Rutt
Oct 20, 2020
Report
Having recently moved to Lititz from another state I was, of course, needing to establish new property, casualty and general liability personal insurance. My research identified a number of very reputable agencies in and around Lititz. I made inquiries to three and all came back promptly with very professional and competitive proposals. Then a friend asked if I had inquired with Gibbel Insurance here in town. I had not, so I used their website to request a proposal. I soon received a phone call from Ethan who asked questions that gave him more details of my situation but also indicated he wanted
Jana Becker
Jul 07, 2020
Report
Fantastic customer service. Each person I've dealt with here has went above and beyond to help me get the best rate and provides all of the
information I need to make a decision. Highly recommend working with GIbbel Insurance!!
information I need to make a decision. Highly recommend working with GIbbel Insurance!!
