Business Details
49 Years
experience
Custom Handcrafted Furniture in Libertyville, IL
Since 1977, O'Reilly's Furniture & Amish Gallery has been dedicated to providing high-quality, handcrafted furniture that combines timeless craftsmanship with personalized customization. Founded by Gary O'Reilly, our business has maintained a commitment to exceptional service and durable, American-made products that meet the unique needs of every customer. Our team collaborates with skilled Amish artisans to create solid wood furniture designed to last generations, while also offering premium upholstery options from trusted brands like England Furniture, Omnia Leather, and Smith Brothers of Berne. With over 45 years of experience, we specialize in custom dining sets, bedroom collections, home office furniture, and living room pieces, all tailored to individual preferences through extensive material, style, and configuration choices. Our Libertyville showroom showcases a wide selection of handcrafted pieces, and our knowledgeable staff provides expert guidance throughout the design process.We prioritize quality over quantity, ensuring every item meets rigorous standards while remaining accessible through competitive pricing. The transition to new ownership in 2018 preserved our family-operated ethos, maintaining direct relationships with craftsmen and customers alike. This continuity guarantees that clients receive the same attention to detail and personalized service established in our founding year. Our focus on American manufacturing supports local economies while delivering heirloom-quality furniture that transcends trends. This enduring approach has fostered multi-generational customer relationships, with families returning for decades to furnish their homes with pieces built to withstand time.
Services
Dining Sets
Bedroom Sets
Home Office Furniture
Occasional Tables
Entertainment Centers
Sofas
Chairs
Sectionals
Recliners
Custom Upholstery
Details
- Year established: 1977
Highlights and features
- We offer 45+ years of expertise in custom furniture design and craftsmanship
- Our direct partnerships with Amish artisans ensure heirloom-quality construction
- We provide exclusive access to premium upholstery brands like England Furniture
- Our family-operated business maintains personalized service through ownership transitions
- We guarantee precise customization through 1,200+ fabric and wood finish options
What people say
Quality and value
Friendly atmosphere
Super delivery
Outstanding service
Lifetime durability
Services
Custom Solid Wood Furniture
Our custom solid wood furniture combines traditional Amish craftsmanship with modern customization options. Each piece is constructed from 100% natural wood using time-tested joinery techniques that ensure longevity. Customers can personalize dimensions, wood species, stains, and hardware to create furniture that perfectly matches their space and style preferences while maintaining heirloom durability.
Custom Upholstery
We offer extensive upholstery customization through partnerships with American manufacturers England Furniture, Omnia Leather, and Smith Brothers. Clients choose from 1,200+ fabric and leather options, multiple frame styles, and specialized comfort features. This service combines old-world craftsmanship with modern materials to create durable, comfortable seating solutions tailored to individual specifications.
Amish Dining Sets
Our Amish dining sets feature handcrafted tables and chairs built to withstand generations of use. Each set is customizable in wood type, table shape, chair style, and finish. The collection includes formal dining sets, casual kitchen tables, and specialty pieces like server buffets, all maintaining the exceptional craftsmanship standards established by Amish artisans.
Bedroom Sets
We create complete bedroom sets featuring handcrafted bed frames, dressers, nightstands, and wardrobes. All pieces maintain consistent construction quality and design aesthetics while allowing individual customization. The Amish-made bedroom collections emphasize functional storage solutions combined with timeless styling that complements various interior design preferences.
Home Office Furniture
Our home office furniture line includes custom desks, bookcases, and storage units designed for both functionality and durability. Crafted from solid wood with customizable configurations, these pieces accommodate modern work requirements while maintaining classic aesthetics. The collection balances practical workspace organization with heirloom-quality construction techniques.
People
Gary O'Reilly
Founder
Established the business in 1977 with a commitment to quality craftsmanship and customer service. Built lasting community relationships through personalized attention to client needs. Maintained direct involvement with Amish artisans to ensure product excellence. Retired in 2018 while preserving the family-operated business ethos.
Mike Walsh
Owner
Assumed ownership in 2018 while maintaining original business values. Preserved connections with Amish craftsmen and expanded customization options. Focuses on combining traditional techniques with modern materials. Ensures continued emphasis on quality, affordability, and personalized customer experiences through showroom operations.
Questions
How does the furniture customization process work?
Our customization process begins with selecting your preferred furniture type, followed by choosing wood species, fabric options, dimensions, and design details through consultations with our showroom specialists.
What upholstery brands do you offer?
We partner with three American manufacturers: England Furniture for traditional upholstery, Omnia Leather for premium leather options, and Smith Brothers of Berne for innovative seating technologies.
Are all products made by Amish craftsmen?
Our wood furniture line is crafted by Amish artisans using traditional techniques, while upholstery options come from American manufacturers maintaining similar quality standards through different production methods.
What warranty options exist for purchased furniture?
Upholstery from Smith Brothers includes a limited lifetime warranty. Wood furniture carries a 1-year warranty covering craftsmanship defects. All products are covered by our commitment to resolving any quality concerns post-purchase.
Can I order furniture not shown in the showroom?
Yes, our customization capabilities allow creating pieces beyond showroom displays. Amish craftsmen can produce virtually any wood furniture design, while upholstery brands offer extensive configuration options beyond displayed samples.
Reviews (5)
Beth Koehn
Jul 28, 2021
Report
I am thrilled with the console table we had custom made. The piece is exactly what I wanted and extremely well made. The sales staff at the store were wonderful. We have other pieces of furniture we are still looking to get and I will be more than happy to give my money to a local business.
Andrea Kruger
Feb 01, 2021
Report
Best customer service for some furniture we purchased here at O'Reilly's. Mike, the owner and his delivery team took wonderful care of us and gave us fantastic pricing. We will continue to purchase from them in the future as they stand by what they sell. Hands down best quality and pricing in the area! Thanks so much!
Marley Lunt
Jun 05, 2020
Report
Hands down my favorite furniture store!!! I ordered a custom Amish dinning room table and chairs and they turned out beautiful. Mike was very helpful and patient as I took a few months to figure out the exact look I wanted. They can order pretty much any look you want and do a great job finding the best price with the many vendors they work with.
Kaitlin Walsh
Dec 04, 2019
Report
Purchased a small dining set and and a few other items, by far the sturdiest furniture Ive ever owned. Compliments every time we have guests over on the look and quality. Excellent delivery service as well.
Adam Stokes
Jul 27, 2018
Report
Very happy with our first purchase from O'Reilly's! Everyone was easy to work with, our couch was ready right when we were told it would be, and they were able to deliver the same day it arrived in their store. They even disposed of our old couch for us! We looked at at least half a dozen furniture shops, and they were the only one selling the high quality we wanted. We already have plans for a few more future purchases.