Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Family Dentist in Fishers, IN
At Pence Family Dentistry, we pride ourselves on treating every patient like family. With decades of combined experience, our team delivers personalized dental care using cutting-edge technology and innovative techniques. We specialize in cosmetic, implant, and sedation dentistry, ensuring patients receive comprehensive solutions tailored to their unique needs. Our commitment to continuing education allows us to offer advanced treatments while maintaining a focus on preventive care.

We serve the Indianapolis area with offices in Fishers, Carmel, and Noblesville, prioritizing patient comfort and long-term oral health. Our practice fosters trust through transparent communication, ethical practices, and a dedication to exceeding expectations in every visit.
Services
Cosmetic Dentistry Dental Implants Sedation Dentistry General Dentistry Restorative Dentistry In-House Clear Aligners Periodontal Treatment TMJ Therapy Emergency Dentistry Special Needs Dentistry
Highlights and features
  • We offer personalized dental solutions with over 20 years of local experience.
  • Our team utilizes advanced technology for precise, comfortable treatments.
  • We specialize in anxiety-free dentistry with multiple sedation options.
  • Our holistic approach addresses oral health's connection to overall wellness.
  • We maintain 5-star patient satisfaction through transparent, empathetic care.
Associations and certifications
  • American Academy of Implant Dentistry
What people say
Kind and considerate staff No pain experienced Life-changing dental experience Anxiety diminished over time Outstanding service quality
Services
Cosmetic Dentistry
Transform your smile with customized cosmetic solutions including porcelain veneers, teeth whitening, and bonding. Our artistic approach combines aesthetic precision with functional benefits, addressing gaps, discoloration, and misalignment. Patients achieve natural-looking results that boost confidence while maintaining oral health integrity through durable, biocompatible materials.
Dental Implants
Restore missing teeth with permanent dental implants that mimic natural tooth structure. Using titanium posts and custom crowns, we provide stable, long-lasting solutions that prevent bone loss and maintain facial contours. Advanced CBCT scanning ensures precise placement, while guided surgery minimizes recovery time for optimal patient comfort.
Sedation Dentistry
Overcome dental fear with tailored sedation options including laughing gas, oral conscious sedation, and IV sedation. Our trained professionals ensure safe, comfortable experiences for anxious patients while maintaining responsiveness during procedures. This approach enables comprehensive treatment in fewer visits without compromising safety or effectiveness.
In-House Clear Aligners
Straighten teeth discreetly with cost-effective, custom-made aligners produced onsite. Digital scanning eliminates traditional molds, while shorter treatment times and immediate adjustments improve efficiency. Ideal for minor to moderate alignment issues, this solution offers removable, nearly invisible correction without metal braces' discomfort or visibility.
Periodontal Treatment
Address gum recession and periodontal disease through non-surgical and surgical interventions. OralDNA testing identifies bacterial threats, guiding personalized treatment plans that include scaling, root planing, and gum grafting. Our focus on early intervention prevents tooth loss while restoring tissue health and reducing systemic health risks associated with untreated periodontal disease.
People
Dr. Orey Pence
DDS, Lead Dentist
Dr. Pence combines artistic skill with technical expertise in cosmetic and restorative dentistry. With advanced training in implant placement and sedation techniques, he creates functional, aesthetically pleasing smiles while prioritizing patient comfort and long-term oral health.
Dr. Dale Behner
DDS, Sedation Specialist
Dr. Behner specializes in anxiety-free dentistry with extensive experience in IV sedation and complex restorative cases. His compassionate approach helps fearful patients achieve optimal oral health through personalized treatment plans and meticulous attention to comfort.
Dr. Richard Weber
DDS, New Team Member
Dr. Weber brings additional expertise in general and cosmetic dentistry, expanding our capacity to serve patients. His integration into the practice maintains our commitment to comprehensive, family-centered care with the same high standards of excellence.
Questions
What dental services do you offer?
We provide comprehensive care including cosmetic dentistry, dental implants, sedation dentistry, general checkups, restorative treatments, and emergency services.
Do you treat anxious patients?
Yes, we specialize in sedation dentistry with multiple anxiety-free options to ensure comfortable experiences for nervous patients.
Are dental implants worth the investment?
Implants offer permanent tooth replacement that preserves bone structure and functions like natural teeth, making them a durable, long-term solution.
How can I schedule emergency dental care?
Call our Fishers office at 317-842-2337 for immediate assistance with dental emergencies during business hours.
Do you accept dental insurance?
We work with most insurance providers and offer financing options to help patients access necessary treatments affordably.
What areas do you serve?
We treat patients from Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Indianapolis, and surrounding Central Indiana communities.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Linda Steele
Dec 14, 2021 Report
Going to the dentist has not always been a pleasant experience for me but Dr. Pences staff immediately helped me feel at ease. The Hygienist was was so gentle and the staff was so friendly. If you are on the fence, do not hesitate, they will ease your fears and take the best care of all your dental needs.
Robin Beaty
Nov 04, 2021 Report
Fun at the dentist? Yes, please! Pence Family Dentistry is the place for relaxed, thorough, and gentle dental care. Start at the front welcoming area with my girl Cherida, shes amazing! Head on back for the most gentle, thorough cleaning youve ever had with the best in the business. Cutting edge technology with laid back style that will keep you coming back. Well, at least every 6 months
Joel Lesher
Oct 18, 2021 Report
Friendly, upbeat atmosphere with a skilled staff that goes out of their way to ensure comfort and satisfaction. Highly recommend!
Bryan Sheedy
Oct 16, 2021 Report
Just had an early morning visit with my hygienist - greeted with courtesy and friendliness - work performed professionally and expertly and within expected timeframe allowing me to continue my busy schedule. Great operation, well run and super customer focused !
Betsy Terpening
Jun 28, 2021 Report
I used to hate dentists until I met Dr. Behner several years ago! Dr. Behner is starting his retirement process and Dr. Pence is taking over his practice. I love Dr. Pence just as much as Dr. Behner! Both of them put me at ease with all of the dental work I have had and still need! The assistants and hygienists have all been there for many years and that says something about the practice! I would highly recommend Dr.Pence.