Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Premier Destination for Fine Jewelry in Port Clinton, OH
At Catawba Island Jewelers, we combine decades of expertise with the warmth and integrity our clients deserve. As a family-owned business serving the Lake Erie Shores & Islands region, we specialize in bringing your vision to life through custom-designed jewelry and an unmatched selection of diamonds. Our team, led by Certified Diamontologist Kristie Pooley, provides personalized guidance and expert craftsmanship for engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. With membership in the prestigious Retail Jewelers Organization (RJO), we maintain the highest standards of quality and service. Our on-site master jeweler ensures exceptional attention to detail for repairs and restorations.We take pride in our perfect 5-star rating, earned through dedicated one-on-one service and a commitment to making every client feel like family. From watch repairs to heirloom preservation, we offer comprehensive solutions to meet all jewelry needs. Our showroom in Port Clinton serves communities across northwest Ohio, including Lakeside Marblehead, Toledo, Cleveland, and Columbus. Whether you're preparing for a proposal or seeking timeless treasures, we deliver trusted expertise that reflects our deep connection to the local community.
Services
Engagement Rings
Wedding Bands
Custom Jewelry Design
Watch Repair
Jewelry Appraisals
Diamond Selection
On-Site Repairs
Heirloom Restoration
Highlights and features
- We offer over 25 years of personalized jewelry expertise.
- Our owner is a Certified Diamontologist with GIA training.
- On-site master jeweler handles complex repairs and restorations.
- Member of the prestigious Retail Jewelers Organization (RJO).
- Proven by perfect 5-star reviews from satisfied clients.
Associations and certifications
- Retail Jewelers Organization (RJO)
What people say
Most perfect ring
100% satisfied
Gentle and helpful
Perfect 5-star rating
Beautiful ring
Services
Engagement Rings
We specialize in helping couples find or create perfect engagement rings. Our Certified Diamontologist guides clients through diamond selection and custom design options. With access to an unmatched collection through our RJO membership, we ensure quality and value while creating meaningful symbols of commitment.
Custom Jewelry Design
Our custom design service transforms personal visions into unique jewelry pieces. Working directly with clients, we develop detailed designs that capture individual stories and styles. Using computer-aided design and traditional techniques, we create one-of-a-kind treasures that reflect personal significance and enduring quality.
Watch Repair
We provide professional watch repair services for various brands including Seiko. From battery replacements to complex movement repairs, our skilled technicians maintain precision and functionality. Our on-site service ensures proper handling of valuable timepieces while preserving their appearance and working mechanisms.
Jewelry Appraisals
Our appraisal services offer accurate evaluations for insurance and estate purposes. Utilizing industry-standard guidelines, we document piece specifications, materials, and market values. Clients receive detailed reports that meet professional appraisal standards while maintaining clear communication about their jewelry's worth.
Heirloom Restoration
We specialize in restoring family heirlooms while preserving original character. Our master jeweler carefully repairs and reinforces older pieces using traditional techniques. This service ensures generational treasures maintain their beauty and structural integrity while meeting modern wearability standards.
People
Kristie Pooley
Owner & Certified Diamontologist
With over 25 years in the jewelry industry, Kristie brings hands-on expertise as a Certified Diamontologist through GIA training. She specializes in diamond grading and jewelry display, ensuring personalized service and expert guidance for every client.
Carlo
Master Bench Jeweler
Our on-site master jeweler Carlo handles complex repairs and custom creations. With extensive experience in diamond setting and restoration, he maintains exceptional quality control through meticulous attention to detail and traditional craftsmanship techniques.
Questions
What types of jewelry do you specialize in?
We specialize in engagement rings, wedding bands, fine jewelry, custom designs, and timepieces. Our collection features diamonds and precious stones set in various metals, with options for both modern and classic styles.
Do you offer custom design services?
Yes, we provide custom jewelry design services where our experts work directly with clients to create personalized pieces that reflect individual stories and preferences using computer-aided design tools.
What repair services do you offer?
We offer comprehensive repair services including ring resizing, stone setting, clasp repairs, and heirloom restoration. Our on-site master jeweler handles both simple and complex repairs with precision.
Are your diamonds certified?
Our diamonds come with certification documentation through our Retail Jewelers Organization (RJO) network, ensuring quality and authenticity standards for every diamond we offer.
What are your hours of operation?
We're open Tuesday-Friday 11AM-6PM, Saturday 11AM-4PM. Our showroom in Port Clinton provides personalized service during these hours, with emergency assistance available when needed.
Reviews (4)
Rebecca Jessen
Aug 14, 2021
Report
Wonderful! Needed a jewelry fix while out for the day and Kristie helped out on the spot. She is a miracle worker!
Rebecca Anderson
Jan 26, 2021
Report
Had an heirloom diamond ring repaired and stone replaced, and was very happy with the beautiful results. Very much appreciated the caring and timely service!! Highly recommend to everyone!
Carlton Cook
Oct 29, 2020
Report
Great service, very knowledable, and helpful. Even finished the repair work ahead of schedule. Highly recommended for others to bring their business to this great shop. Top notch Jeweler!
Annette Liebold
Sep 23, 2020
Report
Great place to shop, love the jewelry she has. Kristie is very helpful . Stop by and check out her shop.