Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Key West Real Estate Experts
Key West Realty has been serving the unique real estate needs of Key West, Florida, since our establishment. As a locally owned and operated firm, we specialize in providing personalized solutions for buyers, sellers, and renters in one of the most distinctive Caribbean-adjacent markets in the world. Our team combines deep local expertise with decades of collective experience in property transactions, offering comprehensive services that include buyer representation, property management, renovation coordination, and relocation assistance.

We pride ourselves on maintaining the highest standards of client service while leveraging our insider knowledge of Key West's historic neighborhoods and luxury properties. Our commitment to transparency, ethical practices, and community engagement has made us a trusted partner for both first-time buyers and seasoned investors seeking property in this exclusive island destination.
Services
Real Estate Sales Property Rentals Buyer Representation Seller Assistance Relocation Services Mortgage Guidance Market Analysis Property Management Investment Properties Luxury Home Sales
Highlights and features
  • We have over 20 years of experience serving Key West's unique real estate market
  • Our agents specialize in historic property transactions and renovation coordination
  • We offer personalized buyer representation for out-of-state clients
  • Our team maintains the highest ethical standards in property transactions
  • We provide comprehensive relocation assistance for new island residents
Associations and certifications
  • Realtor
Services
Real Estate Sales
Key West Realty provides comprehensive real estate sales services specializing in residential and investment properties. We offer expert market analysis, strategic pricing guidance, and professional marketing to maximize property exposure. Our agents facilitate smooth transactions through skilled negotiation and thorough documentation oversight.
Buyer Representation
Our buyer representation service connects clients with ideal Key West properties matching their specific requirements. We assist with property tours, market comparisons, and offer preparation while protecting buyers' interests throughout the negotiation and closing process. Our local expertise benefits both first-time and seasoned investors.
Property Rentals
We manage short- and long-term rental property listings in Key West's most desirable neighborhoods. Our rental services include property showcase, tenant screening assistance, and lease administration for both residential and commercial spaces throughout the Florida Keys market.
Relocation Assistance
Key West Realty offers specialized relocation services for clients transitioning to the Florida Keys. Our support includes neighborhood guidance, school district information, and local resource connections to ensure a smooth transition to island living for both residential and business relocations.
Investment Properties
Our investment property services cater to clients seeking vacation rental opportunities and income-generating assets. We provide market trend analysis, potential return calculations, and property management connections for multi-family units, commercial spaces, and luxury residences in Key West's unique market.
People
Timothy R. Henshaw
Lead Agent
Timothy R. Henshaw brings over 25 years of Florida Keys real estate experience to Key West Realty. His expertise in luxury property transactions and island market dynamics makes him a trusted advisor for buyers and sellers seeking insider knowledge of the local real estate landscape.
Questions
What areas do you service for real estate transactions?
We specialize in Key West and the Florida Keys, covering all residential, commercial, and investment property transactions within this unique island market.
Can you help buyers who live out of state?
Yes, our team provides comprehensive support for long-distance buyers, including virtual tours, document processing, and local market guidance to complete transactions remotely.
What types of properties do you handle?
We work with all property types including single-family homes, multi-family units, luxury estates, vacation rentals, commercial properties, and land parcels throughout the Florida Keys.
Do you offer property management services?
While we don't directly manage properties, we connect owners with trusted local management companies experienced in vacation rental operations and tenant relations.
How do you determine property pricing?
Our pricing strategy combines comparative market analysis, recent local sales data, and professional expertise to set competitive prices that attract qualified buyers.
Can you assist with financing options?
We maintain relationships with local lenders specializing in Florida Keys properties and can connect you with mortgage professionals offering competitive rates and terms.
Reviews (1)
Allison H.
Aug 14, 2019 Report
The worst experience ever! Trying to find a place to rent. First meeting she has 4 group of people looking at one place. She was 15-20 min late. second viewing I was there at 10:00 sharp. She was early, and took the person upstairs to show the place. I guess the someone was there super early. She did NOT GIVE me an apt number to meet her. After 10 min of standing there, I had to call the office to know where they are at. She does not give out her cel number. I could've even get a hold of her. When I found out where it was, I went upstairs. But now She almost didn't want to show me the