Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
43 Years
experience
Custom Jewelry Store in Rochester, NY | Charisma Jewelers
Charisma Jewelers has been a trusted name in fine jewelry since 1983, rooted in a legacy that began with our founders' partnership in 1966. Our team combines decades of expertise with a personal touch, offering custom engagement rings, wedding bands, and designer jewelry crafted to the highest standards. As GIA-trained professionals, we source diamonds directly from international cutters to ensure exceptional quality and value. Our commitment to customer satisfaction is reflected in our 7,000-square-foot showroom, featuring over 2,261 ring designs and a curated selection of luxury collections.

We prioritize transparency in pricing, ethical sourcing, and education to help clients make informed decisions. With flexible financing options and a focus on community, we strive to make every jewelry experience memorable. Our family-owned business continues to innovate while maintaining the personalized service that has defined us for generations.
Services
Custom Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Diamond Selection Jewelry Repair Estate Jewelry
Details
  • Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1983 with GIA-trained diamond experts
  • Direct diamond sourcing from global cutters for competitive pricing
  • 2,261+ engagement ring designs available for customization
  • Exclusive Lashbrook wedding band collection with US-based craftsmanship
  • Wells Fargo financing options for flexible purchasing
What people say
Exceptional selection Expert guidance Beautiful craftsmanship Generous financing Efficient repairs
Services
Custom Engagement Rings
Create a unique engagement ring tailored to personal style and budget. Clients select from 2,261+ designs with options for any metal, setting, and diamond. Skilled artisans craft each piece locally in Rochester, NY, combining traditional techniques with modern innovation. All rings undergo rigorous quality checks to ensure lasting beauty and structural integrity.
Wedding Bands
Explore designer wedding bands from Lashbrook and Simon G., featuring platinum, titanium, and 14K gold collections. Choose from polished, matte, or textured finishes with optional diamond accents. Each band is handcrafted for comfort and durability, complementing engagement ring sets perfectly.
Diamond Selection
Discover certified diamonds sourced directly from global cutters in Antwerp and Tel Aviv. Our GIA-trained experts guide clients through the 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, carat) to find stones that match quality and budget. Available options include lab-created diamonds for sustainable choices.
Jewelry Repair
Professional repair services for resizing, stone replacement, polishing, and restoration of heirloom pieces. In-house technicians use modern equipment to maintain original craftsmanship while ensuring structural safety. Emergency repair services available for urgent needs.
Estate Jewelry
Curated collection of vintage and estate jewelry with documented histories and provenance. Each piece undergoes appraisal to verify authenticity and market value. Available items include Art Deco rings, Victorian brooches, and mid-century modern earrings.
People
Neil Giudice
Co-Owner
Neil Giudice co-owns Charisma Jewelers with Gaetano Maenza, continuing the legacy started by their fathers in 1966. He specializes in diamond sourcing and client relations, bringing over 35 years of industry experience.
Gaetano Maenza
Co-Owner
Gaetano Maenza co-founded Charisma Jewelers after studying at the Gemological Institute of America. He oversees store operations and jewelry design, combining business acumen with technical expertise in gemology.
Questions
Do you offer custom jewelry design services?
Yes, our team creates fully customized rings and jewelry with in-store consultations and CAD modeling.
Can I finance my purchase?
Yes, we offer Wells Fargo financing with approved credit for qualified purchases.
What types of diamonds do you carry?
We stock GIA-certified natural diamonds and lab-created options from trusted global suppliers.
Are repair services available?
Yes, we provide resizing, polishing, and stone replacement services with turnaround times under a week.
How long has the store been in business?
We've served Rochester since 1983, with roots dating back to 1966 in the jewelry industry.
Reviews (4)
Peter Pietrantoni
Dec 21, 2021 Report
I've been shopping with Charisma Jewelers within the last few years. Every visit is greeted with friendly and knowledgeable staff. There is a reason my family still buys and continues to buy from Charisma for their jewelry needs. When I came in to purchase my fiancee's engagement ring, I had the privilege of working with Marco who helped me with setting and diamond selection to ensure it was a sparkling as could be. We've just recently purchased bands for our wedding this upcoming year, and again we went back. They've certainly earned customers for life with both of us. Thanks again for everything
Lucky Rabbitsfoot
Jul 28, 2021 Report
My ring my fiancee purchase from them was better than expected 110% Very happy Great place! Staff very helpful Thank you
Melanie Dries
Jul 15, 2021 Report
One of the best shopping experiences we have had in a long time. We were not only extremely satisfied with the service provide and the weddings rings we purchased but also very impressed with Halis memory and level of customer service. My fianc purchased my engagement ring with Hali in July/August of 2020. I am allergic to most metals resulting in my inability to wear anything other than sterling silver or stainless-steel for long periods of time. Hali helped him pick out the perfect ring and had it made in sterling silver with my favorite cut. We returned to Charisma for our wedding rings in
Jake Daniels
May 07, 2021 Report
Today I picked up the engagement ring I intend to present to my girlfriend and ask her to marry me. The staff was wonderful, they helped me to make an informed and intelligent purchase while working withing my budget. The ring is absolutely stunning, as is everything in their show room. Thank you so so much. Even if she says no, ill still keep the ring and and wear it on one of my toes and pretend my feet are married... it's that pretty.