Business Details
42 Years
experience
Your Trusted Local Pharmacy in Sebastian, FL
Bay Street Pharmacy is a second-generation pharmacist-owned family business established in 1984. We take pride in providing personalized care to every patient, ensuring that each visit exceeds expectations. With two pharmacists on duty at all times, we offer expert consultation and counseling on prescription and non-prescription medications. Our services include compounding, immunizations, compliance packaging, medication therapy management, and free home delivery for patients in the Indian River area. We handle medical equipment needs, from supply to delivery and setup, making healthcare solutions accessible and convenient. Our dedicated team, including pharmacists Theresa Tolle, Cheryl Grage, Lynn Littleton, Maurice Wilson, and Tina Finnegan, prioritizes individual care and community support.We utilize cutting-edge technology while maintaining the warm, compassionate service reminiscent of traditional 'mom and pop' pharmacies. Located in Sebastian, Florida, we serve Northern Indian River and South Brevard counties, committed to improving health outcomes through personalized attention and professional expertise. Our partnership with Ulta Lab Tests expands access to over 1,500 lab tests without requiring a prescription. Every aspect of our operation reflects our motto: 'Where caring people care for you.'
Services
Prescription Refills
Compounding
Immunizations
Medical Equipment Delivery
Home Delivery
Flu Shots
Medication Therapy Management
Compliance Packaging
Rapid Antigen Testing
Health Screenings
Details
- Year established: 1984
Highlights and features
- We offer 2 pharmacists on duty for expert consultation
- We provide free home delivery for medications and medical equipment
- Our pharmacists have decades of combined community-focused experience
- We handle full-service medical equipment supply and setup
- We offer compounding services unavailable elsewhere
What people say
Professional and friendly staff
Family-owned pharmacy
Warmth and compassion
Cutting-edge technology
Excellent service
Services
Prescription Services
We provide prescription refills, transfers, and synchronized medication schedules. Our pharmacists ensure accurate dispensing, offer counseling on usage, and coordinate home delivery. Patients receive personalized consultations and access to the RxLocal app for prescription tracking. Our medication therapy management program helps patients optimize therapeutic outcomes through comprehensive medication reviews.
Medical Equipment
Bay Street Pharmacy offers ambulatory aids, diabetic supplies, respiratory equipment, and compression garments. We handle delivery, setup, and billing for wheelchairs, nebulizers, and more. Patients receive guidance on equipment use while managing conditions like diabetes and COPD. Our services ensure timely access to essential medical devices without insurance barriers.
Immunizations
We administer flu, COVID-19, RSV, pneumonia, tetanus, shingles, and travel vaccines. No appointments needed for most immunizations. Our staff provides education on vaccine importance and schedules. Services protect individual and community health through CDC-recommended preventive care while accommodating walk-in availability.
Compounding
Specializing in non-commercial compounds, we create hormone replacement therapies, pain creams, and veterinary medications. Our pharmacists collaborate with physicians to customize dosage forms and flavors. Unique formulations like fungal solutions and ear drops offer alternatives when commercial products fail, ensuring patient-specific treatment efficacy.
Health Screenings
We conduct blood pressure checks, cholesterol screenings, blood glucose tests, and hemoglobin A1c assessments. Patients receive immediate results and guidance for managing chronic conditions. Our partnership with Ulta Lab Tests provides access to 1,500+ lab panels without prescriptions, offering affordable diagnostic options for uninsured or high-deductible plan holders.
People
Theresa Tolle
Owner and Chief Pharmacist
Theresa Tolle owns Bay Street Pharmacy since 1999, prioritizing personalized patient care. She specializes in healthcare industry knowledge and community pharmacy operations while emphasizing compassionate service through faith-driven values.
Lynn Littleton
Pharmacist
Lynn Littleton has served since 2005, offering expertise in complex prescriptions and compounding. She previously managed Medicine Shoppe in Roseland while balancing family life with 5 children and grandchildren.
Maurice Wilson
Pharmacist
Maurice Wilson joined in 2018 after managing Walmart pharmacies for 25 years. He values patient interaction time while maintaining interests in horology and outdoor activities.
Cheryl Grage
Pharmacist
Cheryl Grage has worked at Bay Street since 2006 after supervising Pathmark Supermarket Pharmacy. She emphasizes patient relationships while enjoying family time and Hallmark movies.
Tina Finnegan
Pharmacist
Tina Finnegan joined after completing a University of Florida residency. She focuses on community service expansion while balancing family life with her husband and daughter.
Questions
Do you offer home delivery services?
We provide free home delivery for medications and over-the-counter items to patients in the Indian River area.
What immunizations do you offer?
We administer flu, COVID-19, RSV, pneumonia, tetanus, shingles, and travel vaccines with no appointment needed.
What are your business hours?
We're open Monday-Friday 9am-6pm, Saturday 9am-1pm, and closed Sundays.
Do you provide medical equipment?
We offer medical equipment supply, delivery, setup, and billing for oxygen systems, wheelchairs, diabetic supplies, and more.
What makes you different from chain pharmacies?
We combine cutting-edge technology with personalized service, maintaining the warm, individualized care of traditional independent pharmacies.
Can I order lab tests directly?
Through Ulta Lab Tests, you access 1,500+ lab panels without prescription requirements at discounted prices.
Reviews (6)
Russell Horn
Jan 07, 2022
Report
It's very surprising to find a pharmacy that actually cares about people. I'm new to the neighborhood and when I had to change pharmacy, I found out there is a problem with my health insurance because of a change over on social security was in the process of doing. It temporarily left me without drug coverage. Teresa, the owner found a way to get me my medicine.
Robert Scott
Oct 18, 2021
Report
This is the best pharmacy! Support local pharmacies. These folks care about every single customer like family. You won't get this kind of service at chains.
Tari Hampe
Oct 17, 2021
Report
This hands-on, owner-operated pharmacy is a gem! We have never been treated with such warmth and compassion. Their technology is cutting edge while their customer service is reminiscent of the good ole days of "mom and pop" pharmacies. Thank you Bay Street Pharmacy!
Lady Z.
Jun 01, 2021
Report
Best pharmacy in Sebastian! The entire staff is attentive to the needs of their customers...they're never too busy. It's a hometown pharmacy that truly cares about the services they provide and supports the community in many ways. And congratulations to Theresa Tolle on her election for the 2021 president-elect/2022 presidential position for the American Pharmacist Association!!
Stuart Gorrie
May 15, 2021
Report
Expensive prescriptions. They do not accept GOODRX which resulted in a $76 price as opposed to $30 at pharmacies that accept GOODRX. Additionally one prescription was only half filled so I had to go back to have it fixed.
Tony
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Theresa and her staff are amazing. My roommate and I live in Vero Beach and he has stage 4 lung cancer. His daughter and I have encountered many difficulties through this process. After his 3rd round of treatment we were trying to get more meds. I was put in touch with baystreet pharmacy in Sebastian as Vero had no meds. I spoke with Theresa, the owner, at 4pm on Friday and she assured me he would get his meds asap. She gave me her cell so the doc could contact her and sure enough we had the meds at 9am the next morning. Her attention to detail and heart for patient care is unmatched. If you are
