Business Details
Experience Modern New England Cuisine at Elm Square Oyster Co. Co.
Elm Square Oyster Co. Co. is a vibrant modern New England eatery dedicated to crafting innovative seafood and American dishes using locally sourced, seasonal ingredients. Our culinary team, led by Executive Chef Michael Sherman, meticulously prepares all sauces, seasonings, and condiments in-house to ensure unparalleled quality. By collaborating with regional fishermen, farmers, and artisans, we deliver a distinctive dining experience rooted in authenticity.Our commitment to excellence has earned recognition as a premier gastropub on the North Shore. The bar showcases an extensive selection of American bourbons, small-batch spirits, and craft beers, complementing our thoughtfully curated wine list. With a focus on fresh, inventive cuisine and attentive service, we strive to create memorable moments for every guest.
Services
Dinner
Drinks
Oysters
Kids Menu
Take Out
Highlights and features
- We craft all sauces, seasonings, and condiments in-house for unmatched quality.
- Our menu features locally sourced, seasonal ingredients prepared with culinary expertise.
- Awarded Best Gastropub on the North Shore for our innovative New England cuisine.
- The bar offers an extensive selection of American bourbons and craft beers.
- Dedicated team ensures a memorable dining experience in a vibrant setting.
Services
Dinner
Elm Square Oyster Co. Co. offers dinner service featuring creative seafood and American dishes. Our menu emphasizes locally sourced, seasonal ingredients prepared with culinary precision. Guests enjoy a vibrant atmosphere paired with exceptional service in downtown Andover, MA.
Drinks
Our bar showcases an extensive selection of American bourbons, small-batch spirits, local craft beers, and curated wines. Knowledgeable staff guide guests through drink pairings that complement our New England cuisine in a lively downtown setting.
Oysters
Fresh oysters are a menu highlight, served on the half-shell with house-made sauces during daily happy hours. Our seafood program emphasizes quality and authenticity, featuring creative preparations that showcase regional ingredients.
Kids Menu
A dedicated kids menu offers approachable options for younger diners while maintaining our commitment to fresh, house-made ingredients. The family-friendly environment makes it ideal for casual meals in a historic downtown location.
Take Out
Available via phone orders, our take-out service preserves the quality of scratch-made dishes for home enjoyment. Customers can experience our innovative New England cuisine beyond the dining room in Andover, MA.
People
Michael Sherman
Executive Chef
Graduate of North Shore Community College's culinary program with experience at fine dining establishments. Passionate about seasonal ingredients and New England cuisine, creating innovative dishes daily.
Roseann Williams
General Manager
Scottish native with extensive local restaurant experience. As co-owner, she brings hospitality expertise and ensures exceptional guest experiences through dedicated team management in Andover.
Colin Welch
Bar Manager
New England native with deep whiskey knowledge, curating an extensive bourbon collection and craft beverage program that complements the restaurant's innovative cuisine offerings.
Questions
Do you offer take-out or delivery options?
Take-out is available via phone orders. We currently do not offer delivery services.
Are reservations required for dining?
Reservations are recommended but not required. Confirmations are sent via email for all website bookings.
What makes your oyster selection unique?
We serve fresh, locally sourced oysters on the half-shell with three house-made sauces during daily happy hour specials.
Do you have parking options?
On-street parking is available along Main Street and Elm Street, with additional spaces in nearby town municipal lots.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards and cash for all dining and bar services.
Are there special hours for the bar?
Bar stays open until 11 PM Tuesday-Wednesday and midnight Thursday-Saturday, with occasional variations requiring confirmation by phone.
Reviews (7)
Amanda Berg
Jan 20, 2022
Report
The hostess, manager, chef, and server were all fantastic. Their "made from scratch" menu certainly doesn't disappoint. Their oysters were shucked wonderfully. This was our first visit, and we'll certainly be looking to return!
Jeff
Jan 14, 2022
Report
A+ service! The general manager Roseann and our waiter (didnt catch his name) were both very accommodating and friendly. Great food and drinks too. Definitely coming back here and recommending this place!
David Nash
Jan 11, 2022
Report
What a wonderful dining experience. The food and service were wonderful! What a plus to meet the owner, who by the way stopped by every table and introduced herself. A real treat in Andover
Sophie B.
Jan 10, 2022
Report
My husband and I celebrated our wedding anniversary tonight, and had a great experience at the restaurant. Our waiter was kind and friendly in a genuine way, and the owner, Roseann, seemed to truly care about customer experiences. Delicious food and amazing staff. Definitely going back soon!
Chris Heitmann
Nov 16, 2021
Report
Great local food, atmosphere and people. We like sitting at the bar with Colin tending, but if you prefer tables, outdoor or cozy high tops, all are available and each has their own vibe. The menu is always changing a little, with some core items remaining. Recently weve enjoyed smoked carrots w/goat cheese, deviled eggs, cheese boards, burgers, roasted chicken, sirloin, a fantastic mushroom soup and more I cant remember right now. Im not an oyster person, but have seen many people enjoying them here. Great cozy and classy environment, excellent service and continually innovative menu
Joseph Callesano
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Good not great.
Oysters are full price but pretty good. Service wasn't slow.
Deviled eggs were great, muscles were ok, lacking flavor altogether. Bread was great.
Drinks are hard to mess up so those beers were good.
Waiter was great and attentive. We didn't order a entre based on the apps we got beforehand. Maybe next time.
Oysters are full price but pretty good. Service wasn't slow.
Deviled eggs were great, muscles were ok, lacking flavor altogether. Bread was great.
Drinks are hard to mess up so those beers were good.
Waiter was great and attentive. We didn't order a entre based on the apps we got beforehand. Maybe next time.
Doug Bevan
Oct 28, 2021
Report
Come for the reasonably priced oyster happy hour, stay for the delicious cocktails, tasty full menu, and great service! Its great coming here after a long day at work to relax on the nice patio during warm months, and the dining room is also classy and cozy. This is one of my favorite restaurants in Andover.