Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
45 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry & Coin Destination Since 1981
At Coin & Jewelry Gallery, we are committed to providing a hassle-free shopping experience rooted in decades of expertise. With over 100 years of combined experience in coins, jewelry, bullion, and paper money, our team offers personalized service for appraisals, buying, and collection liquidation. Our in-house GIA-trained jeweler specializes in custom designs and repairs, ensuring each client receives tailored solutions.

As Gainesville's trusted destination since 1981, we have built a reputation on integrity, fairness, and a deep understanding of rare collector and investment-grade items. Our focus remains on customer satisfaction, offering unique pieces and transparent transactions for both seasoned collectors and first-time buyers.
Services
Custom Jewelry Appraisals Coins & Bullion Jewelry Repairs Rare Coin Sales Gemstone Resetting Watch Maintenance Estate Jewelry Precious Metals Trading Engagement Rings
Details
  • Year established: 1981
Highlights and features
  • Over 100 years combined experience in jewelry and coin expertise.
  • In-house GIA-trained jeweler for repairs and custom designs.
  • Hassle-free shopping with exclusive jewelry pieces.
  • Expert appraisals for accurate valuations.
  • Offering rare collector and investment-grade coins.
Associations and certifications
  • Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
  • American Numismatic Association
  • Florida United Numismatics
What people say
Knowledgeable experts Custom work excellence Efficient appraisals Trustworthy service Unique designs
Services
Custom Jewelry
Our GIA-trained jeweler creates tailored pieces using advanced design software. Clients can repurpose existing stones or select from premium materials. Every custom item reflects the wearers unique style while maintaining exceptional craftsmanship standards.
Appraisals
Expert assessments determine market values for jewelry, coins, and precious metals. Our certified professionals provide detailed reports for insurance, estate planning, or sales purposes, ensuring accurate and reliable valuations based on current market trends.
Coins & Bullion
We buy and sell rare coins, gold, silver, and bullion with transparent pricing. Our inventory includes investment-grade options and collector pieces, supported by decades of numismatic expertise for both seasoned investors and new collectors.
Jewelry Repairs
In-house repair services address resizing, stone settings, and restoration needs. Using modern techniques, our specialists maintain original integrity while ensuring wearability and structural durability for heirloom or everyday pieces.
Precious Metals Trading
Gainesvilles trusted source for buying and selling gold, silver, and platinum. We offer competitive rates aligned with market fluctuations, helping clients diversify portfolios or liquidate assets through secure, straightforward transactions.
People
Ann Kelly Santostefano
Owner
A GIA-certified gemologist with expertise in diamond grading and estate jewelry management, Ann brings over four decades of industry experience. She specializes in appraisals and maintaining high-quality inventory standards.
David Hill
Owner & Jeweler
Since 2004, David has provided GIA-trained craftsmanship for custom designs and repairs. His skills include laser welding and MatrixGold software for creating detailed, personalized jewelry pieces.
Questions
What services does Coin & Jewelry Gallery offer?
We provide custom jewelry design, appraisals, rare coin sales, precious metal trading, and jewelry repairs. Our specialized services cater to collectors, investors, and personal shoppers.
Can I get my jewelry appraised locally?
Yes. Our certified appraisers with over 100 years of combined experience offer accurate valuations for insurance, sales, or estate planning within Gainesville and surrounding areas.
Do you create custom engagement rings?
Absolutely. Our in-house jeweler designs bespoke engagement rings using client-provided stones or new materials, ensuring unique, high-quality creations tailored to individual preferences.
Are your precious metal prices competitive?
We guarantee transparent, market-aligned pricing for gold and silver bullion, ensuring clients receive fair value aligned with current market rates.
What are your business hours?
We’re open Monday to Friday from 9:30 AM to 5 PM, and Saturdays from 10 AM to 2 PM. Appointments can be scheduled for personalized assistance.
Reviews (6)
Lane A.
Dec 10, 2021 Report
Fantastic service, friendly, knowledgeable, and very fair. The have an impressive selection of coins and jewelry and its a great place to trade bullion. David is an incredibly talented jeweler with beautiful custom work and repairs and is a pleasure to work with. Vince, Ann, and David are great people and the store is the best in town.
Jesse Whiting
Dec 05, 2021 Report
Called asking them to hold something for me I was right down the road they sold it before I got there can't depend on this company to do anything if it's in your benefit they're all about them lost a lifetime customer will only be shopping at coin kingdom from here on
Rob Lewis
Nov 18, 2021 Report
Knowledgeable, friendly , Great experience, totally awesome.
Made the drive from Jacksonville worth it , will shop here again soon
Andrew Coffey
Nov 16, 2021 Report
Better quality than online jewelry retailers and knowledgeable staff can help customize pieces with fast turnaround. Top notch craftsmanship on service/repair items. Great local shop.
Dan Dasclo
Nov 07, 2021 Report
I have lived many lives through trial and error. Anne and Vince have helped convert "easter eggs" from being "all in one basket," too the sweet melody of "Jing-a-ling-a-ling" in a pants' pocket. Their forethought was even so kind to start a piggy bank for our new born. Simply, thank you both.
Keri R.
Sep 19, 2021 Report
Great customer service, and a wonderful job resizing a ring for me. It looks beautiful! Much nicer than when I dropped it off perfectly polished!