Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Orthodontist in Indianapolis, IN
At Cottingham Orthodontics, we believe that every smile tells a story and deserves to shine with confidence. Founded by Dr. Karen L. Cottingham, our practice combines decades of specialized expertise with cutting-edge technology to deliver personalized orthodontic solutions for patients of all ages. Dr. Cottingham's journey began with a childhood dream of transforming lives through dental care, which she fulfills daily through her compassionate approach and commitment to excellence. Our team prioritizes patient comfort and education, utilizing iTero Element digital imaging and advanced treatment methods to create healthy, lasting smiles. With two convenient locations in Indianapolis and Avon, Indiana, we serve families through comprehensive care options including traditional braces, clear aligners, and early intervention therapies. Our practice exceeds standard continuing education requirements while maintaining active memberships in prestigious organizations like the American Association of Orthodontists.

Beyond clinical excellence, we emphasize community service through partnerships with Smiles Change Lives and the Make-a-Wish Foundation, reflecting our belief that exceptional care extends beyond the office walls. Every treatment plan is tailored to individual needs, ensuring patients receive both technical precision and emotional support throughout their orthodontic journey. From initial consultation to final results, we maintain transparent communication about treatment timelines, financial options, and oral hygiene practices. Our office environment blends professionalism with warmth, creating a space where patients feel valued as individuals rather than case numbers.
Services
Braces Clear Aligners Early Orthodontics Adult Treatments Emergency Care
Highlights and features
  • We offer personalized treatment plans tailored to individual needs
  • Our practice utilizes iTero Element digital imaging technology
  • Dr. Cottingham maintains active membership in major orthodontic associations
  • We provide comprehensive care for patients of all ages
  • Our team emphasizes both technical excellence and emotional support
What people say
Miracle worker Knowledgeable and friendly Best smile they could Genuinely happy for me Changed my life
Services
Braces
Traditional metal braces remain our most effective solution for comprehensive tooth alignment. Using precision brackets and archwires, we correct complex bite issues and misalignments through regular adjustments. Patients receive detailed guidance on maintaining oral hygiene and dietary restrictions during treatment.
Clear Aligners
Custom-crafted clear aligners offer a discreet alternative for straightening teeth without traditional brackets. These removable trays gradually shift teeth into optimal positions while allowing normal eating and cleaning routines. Treatment includes regular progress check-ups.
Early Orthodontics
Specialized early intervention treatments address developing bite problems in children aged 7-11. We monitor growth patterns and implement phased treatments when needed to create proper space for permanent teeth and guide jaw development.
Adult Treatments
Comprehensive solutions for adult patients seeking improved alignment and bite function. We address unique considerations like existing dental work and bone density while offering aesthetic options that fit professional lifestyles and treatment timelines.
Emergency Care
Immediate assistance for urgent orthodontic issues including broken brackets, loose wires, and appliance discomfort. Our team provides prompt solutions through same-day appointments or temporary care instructions for after-hours incidents.
People
Karen L. Cottingham
Orthodontist
Dr. Cottingham earned her dental degree from the University of Alabama at Birmingham and orthodontic specialty training at Indiana University. With over two decades of experience, she combines technical expertise with personalized care while maintaining active involvement in professional organizations.
Questions
What orthodontic options do you offer for adults?
We provide traditional braces, clear aligners, and customized treatment plans for adults seeking improved alignment and bite function.
How often are orthodontic adjustment appointments needed?
Most patients require adjustments every 4-8 weeks depending on their specific treatment plan and progress.
Do you accept dental insurance for orthodontic treatment?
Yes, we work with most major insurance providers and offer flexible payment plans to accommodate various budgets.
What should I do for orthodontic emergencies after hours?
Contact our office immediately for urgent issues - we provide guidance for temporary care and schedule same-day appointments when needed.
How long does typical orthodontic treatment last?
Treatment duration varies by case complexity but typically ranges from 12-36 months with consistent patient compliance.
Can I schedule a consultation at either office location?
Yes, we offer complimentary consultations at both our Indianapolis and Avon, IN locations for your convenience.
Videos
Reviews (4)
Louise
Dec 15, 2021 Report
Dr .Cottingham is a GREAT Orthodontics. The Dr.C and staff are all very professional and friendly. They put your dental concern first .I had braces put on my bottom teeth only. My concern was to straightened and tightened, my bottom teeth. Dr.C made it happen ,what a difference and let me say Im a senior who would refer Dr.Cottingham to the world,
Thank you so much for my beautiful smile.,you hooked me up.
Grateful LJackson
Taylorzvlogz
Aug 24, 2021 Report
I went here for a Consultation and I was there for about 2 hours but they were so nice and made sure to check up on us pretty often. Amazing place. Totally recommend
Kelli Carter
Jul 15, 2021 Report
Get your orthodontics at Cottingham's!! SERIOUSLY, not only is she such an amazing and bright woman, so are her staff! Just got my braces off today after 2 years and I feel fantastic!! Let me tell you, my teeth needed some serious care and they CARED! She has an office in Indy as well as Avon so it's pretty convenient for many and you just can't find a more caring set of people! I gave Cottingham a huge hug before I left as I'm so grateful! At almost 29 years old now, I had wanted braces all my life. They made my dream come true! Can't thank them enough!!!
Sarah S.
Jun 30, 2021 Report
I have nothing bad to say about her orthodontic skills..my son's teeth look much better. During one of my son's first appointments she said to me "you have a terrible underbite. Bite down. Oh nevermind, it looks good." They also expected a 9yo to tell me what the plan was. We had already paid for our whole service time so we were stuck. She smacks and pops gum the whole time during consultations. She is unprofessional and rude. The scheduling is not flexible so be ready to miss a lot of school.