Business Details
16 Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry & Gold Buyers in New Kensington, PA
Community Gold Buyers is a family-owned business established in 2010, dedicated to providing fair and transparent services for buying and selling precious metals, jewelry, and collectibles. Our team brings decades of combined experience in the industry, with owners Jeremy and Jerry Gugino rooted in the local Sarver community for over 55 years. We prioritize customer trust through certified scales, free testing, and clear pricing posted daily. Our A+ Better Business Bureau rating and seven consecutive Trib Total Media Readers' Choice Awards for Best Cash for Gold reflect our commitment to excellence. We operate with full compliance to state regulations, including mandatory transaction documentation and a five-day holding period for purchased items.Our staff, including jewelry expert Jane Favero, offers personalized service to ensure customers receive accurate valuations and competitive payouts. We maintain a secure, welcoming environment with two gold-buying stations to streamline transactions. Our price-match promise guarantees customers the best possible offers based on current market values. Located in New Kensington, Pennsylvania, we serve Pittsburgh and surrounding areas including Natrona Heights, Lower Burrell, and Fox Chapel. Our mission remains to empower local residents with trustworthy, community-focused service while maintaining industry-leading standards.
Services
Gold Buying
Silver Buying
Jewelry Sales
Coin Appraisals
Diamond Evaluation
Precious Metal Testing
Estate Jewelry
Bullion Sales
Watch Purchases
Gift Card Redemption
Details
- Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
- We maintain an A+ Better Business Bureau rating for consumer protection
- Our price-match promise guarantees competitive offers based on current market values
- Certified scales and transparent pricing posted daily ensure accurate valuations
- Team includes jewelry experts with over 10 years' industry experience
- Seven consecutive Trib Total Media Readers' Choice Awards for Best Cash for Gold
Associations and certifications
- Better Business Bureau
What people say
Very knowledgeable
Fair pricing
Great service
Competitive payouts
Friendly staff
Services
Gold Buying
We purchase all types of gold items including jewelry, coins, and bullion. Our certified testing process ensures accurate karat identification and fair market valuation. Customers receive competitive pricing based on current gold market rates with optional price matching against written competitor quotes.
Silver Appraisals
We buy silver coins, bars, and jewelry with verification through magnet testing and hallmark inspection. Our certified scales measure in troy ounces with transparent pricing displayed daily. We accept pre-1965 US silver coins and various international silver products.
Jewelry Sales
Our inventory includes new and pre-owned designer jewelry from brands like Tiffany and Judith Ripka. We offer estate and antique pieces at wholesale prices, along with high-end diamond engagement rings. All items come with detailed documentation and valuation reports.
Coin Services
We specialize in US gold and silver coins, including American Eagles and foreign bullion. Our collection includes rare paper money, coin sets, and commemorative pieces. We provide expert authentication and market-based pricing for both modern and historical numismatic items.
Diamond Evaluation
We buy loose and mounted diamonds with verification through specialized testing equipment. Our evaluation considers carat, clarity, and market demand to provide fair cash offers. We maintain strict documentation standards for all diamond transactions per state regulations.
People
Jeremy Gugino
Owner
Co-owner with over 15 years in precious metals industry. Started in Florida before establishing New Kensington location. Focuses on community engagement and pricing strategy.
Jerry Gugino
Owner
Co-owner and local Sarver resident with deep community ties. Oversees operational compliance and customer relations. Ensures adherence to all state licensing and documentation requirements.
Jane Favero
Jewelry Specialist
West Deer native with decade-plus jewelry expertise. Manages inventory and provides detailed product knowledge to customers. Handles estate jewelry acquisitions and valuations.
Questions
What items do you buy?
We purchase gold, silver, platinum, jewelry, diamonds, coins, and select gift cards. See our What We Buy page for complete details.
How are prices determined?
Prices are based on current market values, item weight, and purity. We post daily prices in-store for complete transparency.
Do you offer price matching?
Yes, we'll match or beat written competitor quotes for identical items. Restrictions apply based on market conditions.
What identification is required?
Valid photo ID (driver's license or state ID) is required for all transactions per Pennsylvania state law.
Are transactions confidential?
We maintain customer privacy while complying with state-mandated documentation requirements for all precious metal transactions.
How long do I keep my items?
We hold purchased items for 5 business days to accommodate any potential ownership claims.
Reviews (4)
Martin Tierney
Dec 14, 2021
Report
This was our first experience selling our jewelry. Jerry was so nice and explained everything he was doing. And it was done right in front of us. He took his time and we never felt any pressure. We felt we got a good honest price for our jewelry. We would highly recommend CGB and definitely go back.
Terry Hormel
Dec 05, 2021
Report
I was very pleased with the service. I had some old sterling flatware to sell and some jewelry. I was pleasantly surprised with the money I received, Everything was up front and above board and done right in front of me. I would 100% recommend CGB! Receipt 26206
Dave Coleman
Oct 16, 2021
Report
Went to Community Gold based on reviews we read and had a great experience with Jerry and Jeremy. Had some gold jewelry and gold coins we wanted to sell. Straightforward and friendly and would recommend to anyone wanting to sell coins or jewelry. I will be taking my silver coins over soon.
Jeannie Skinner
Aug 04, 2021
Report
My husband and I recently visited Community Gold Buyers with some coin collections and silver pieces. We had been unsure of where to take these items for many years but opted to try Community Gold and Jewelry Buyers after reading great reviews. We were not disappointed. Jeremy was fantastic. He spent a lot of time reviewing our items all the while explaining and teaching us about the items and the process of evaluating them. He was upfront and honest. We were comfortable of the process and felt that we were well reciprocated for our items. I highly recommend Community Gold and Jewelry Buyers to