Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Bellefontaine for Custom Designs & Repairs
The Jewelry Gallery is a locally owned and operated full-service jewelry store dedicated to providing personalized, high-quality services and products. With over 15 years of experience in the industry, our certified bench jeweler Dave specializes in intricate repairs, custom creations, and enhancements, ensuring every piece is crafted to perfection. We collaborate with one of the largest jewelry suppliers globally, offering an extensive selection of fine jewelry, including rings, pendants, chains, and more, all at competitive prices.

Our team prioritizes education over aggressive sales tactics, guiding customers through every decision with integrity and expertise. We accept all major credit cards and provide additional services such as buying broken or scrap gold, silver, and platinum. Our commitment to excellence extends to in-house repairs, appraisals, and custom designs, ensuring every client receives a unique, satisfying experience tailored to their needs.
Services
Bridal Jewelry Custom Jewelry In-House Repairs Appraisals Watch Repairs Chain Repair Stone Setting Rhodium Plating Eyeglass Frame Repair Precious Metal Buying
Highlights and features
  • We offer in-house jewelry repairs by a certified bench jeweler with 15+ years of experience.
  • Our team collaborates with one of the largest jewelry suppliers globally to provide diverse options.
  • We specialize in custom jewelry creation using your own materials or ideas.
  • We provide free verbal appraisals and competitive pricing on all services.
  • We buy broken, worn, and scrap gold, silver, and platinum for your convenience.
Services
Bridal Jewelry
The Jewelry Gallery offers over 10,000 customizable bridal jewelry options, including engagement rings and wedding bands. Clients can select from various diamond shapes, cuts, and metals to create unique pieces. We also carry men's wedding bands in titanium, tungsten, silver, platinum, and gold, including his-and-hers sets.
Custom Jewelry
Our custom jewelry service allows clients to create personalized pieces using their own stones or materials. With over 5,000 loose diamonds and gemstones in stock, we offer in-house casting and design assistance to transform ideas into wearable art. This includes remaking heirloom jewelry into modern styles.
In-House Repairs
We provide comprehensive in-house jewelry repairs, including ring sizing, prong rebuilding, and chain welding. Our certified bench jeweler uses advanced equipment to restore items to like-new condition. Services range from free basic cleanings to complex structural fixes with detailed quotes.
Appraisals
The Jewelry Gallery offers verbal and written appraisals for insurance or resale purposes. Verbal appraisals are free for up to five items, while written appraisals cost $45 per piece. Our evaluations cover diamonds, gemstones, and precious metal items with detailed documentation.
Precious Metal Buying
We buy broken, worn, or scrap gold, silver, and platinum at competitive market rates. Our team evaluates items based on purity and weight, providing transparent pricing. This service offers clients a convenient way to convert unused jewelry into cash.
People
Dave
Certified Bench Jeweler
Dave has over 15 years of experience in jewelry repair and custom design. He specializes in intricate metalwork, stone setting, and restoration of heirloom pieces. His expertise ensures high-quality craftsmanship for all custom creations and repairs completed at The Jewelry Gallery.
Questions
What custom jewelry options are available?
We offer over 5,000 loose diamonds and gemstones for custom designs, including remaking heirloom jewelry. Our in-house casting allows complete customization of rings, pendants, and more.
What repair services do you provide?
We handle ring sizing, prong rebuilding, chain welding, and watch repairs. Most services are completed in-house with free estimates for complex jobs like shank replacements.
Do you buy used jewelry or precious metals?
Yes, we purchase broken, worn, or scrap gold, silver, and platinum at current market rates. Items are evaluated based on purity and weight for fair pricing.
Are your bridal jewelry prices negotiable?
While our prices are competitive, we offer a 10-day exchange policy for unworn pieces. This allows flexibility to adjust selections while ensuring value for custom bridal orders.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept all major credit cards for purchases and services. Financing options are not currently available, but we offer transparent pricing with no hidden fees.
How long do repairs typically take?
Most in-house repairs take 1-2 weeks depending on complexity. Urgent requests like watch battery replacements can often be completed the same day with no appointment needed.
Reviews (5)
Tera Kate Oglesbee
Dec 02, 2021 Report
Of course, any jeweler will have beautiful products but I prefer good customer service. He would not even look at me to answer my questions, very cold and short. Just because you sale jewelry doesn't mean you are above anyone. 15 years has taught you nothing but how to be rude. P.S....if you don't want dirt or mudd tracked in, clean your sidewalk instead of insulting and shaming a little 3 year old boy.
Jamie Sassen
Sep 13, 2021 Report
My Absolute favorite spot for Jewelry Repair!
Dave is Very Knowledgeable and prompt, turn around time is usually only a few days. And makes you feel taken care of. One of the few places that does in house repairs, instead of sending your Jewelry away to be serviced.
Liz Salyer
May 18, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Had clasp on a necklace replaced. They did the job quickly and for a reasonable price.
Miguel Medina
Apr 07, 2021 Report
Very friendly atmosphere. I felt welcome & my needs were met. I would definitely recommend for your jewelry needs
Aaron Myers
Jul 25, 2020 Report
Great staff, super helpful, fantastic experience and easy to ask questions to get exactly what you want!