Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
2 Years
experience
Authentic Italian Pizza in Lake Placid, NY | Nicola's Restaurant
Established in 2024, Nicola's Restaurant continues the culinary legacy of Lake Placid's beloved Nicola's, which originated in 1994 as the first modern Italian restaurant north of Manhattan featuring wood-fired pizza. Our founder, Chef Michael Nicola, immersed himself in Italian culinary traditions through extensive travels across Italy and major U.S. cities, mastering the art of using high-quality, simple ingredients to create authentic flavors. We maintain this commitment to authenticity through hand-crafted pizzas made in a garage-inspired industrial space that combines casual dining with old-world hospitality. Our open kitchen concept allows guests to witness the preparation process, from dough stretching to final baking in our wood-fired oven.

With a focus on family recipes and locally inspired ingredients, we deliver an experience that balances tradition with modern casual dining. Our establishment builds upon two decades of success from Nicola's original location while maintaining the same passion for quality that made our founder a local culinary icon. We prioritize creating a welcoming atmosphere where guests can enjoy both quick meals and extended family gatherings. Our menu extends beyond pizza to include carefully curated entrees that reflect Italian culinary traditions, all prepared with the same attention to detail. This dedication to authentic preparation methods and ingredient quality establishes us as a trusted destination for Italian cuisine in Lake Placid.
Services
Wood-Fired Pizza Chicken Parmesan Eggplant Parmesan Oven-Roasted Salmon House Salad House Dessert
Details
  • Year established: 2024
Highlights and features
  • We continue Lake Placid's longest-running Italian culinary tradition since 1994
  • Our wood-fired pizzas use recipes perfected through decades of Italian culinary exploration
  • We maintain strict ingredient quality standards from dough to final toppings
  • Our open kitchen concept offers unique dining experience with chef interaction
  • We combine authentic Italian techniques with modern casual dining atmosphere
Services
Wood-Fired Pizza
Our signature wood-fired pizzas feature hand-stretched dough topped with premium ingredients. Each pizza is cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven at optimal temperatures to achieve perfect crispness and flavor. The menu includes classic combinations like Margherita and custom options with house-made mozzarella and imported Italian meats.
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast sauted and baked with mozzarella and Parmigiano cheeses. Served with linguini marinara, this dish showcases traditional Italian preparation techniques. The chicken is hand-breaded daily using a proprietary blend of herbs and spices for consistent flavor.
Eggplant Parmesan
Breaded eggplant slices sauted and baked with mozzarella and Parmigiano cheeses. Served with linguini marinara, this vegetarian option maintains the same preparation standards as our meat dishes. The eggplant is sliced fresh daily and breaded using the same herb blend as our chicken entree.
Oven-Roasted Salmon
Fresh salmon fillets roasted to perfection and served over mixed greens with roasted red potatoes. The dish is finished with a house-made balsamic reduction and whole grain mustard sauce. This preparation highlights our commitment to using high-quality proteins and house-made accompaniments.
House Salad
Fresh mixed greens with house-made dressing, served as a complement to all dinner orders. The salad ingredients are sourced locally when possible, featuring seasonal vegetables and herbs. This simple preparation demonstrates our focus on quality ingredients and traditional Italian presentation.
People
Michael Nicola
Chef/Owner
Lake Placid's beloved 'Mr. Mike' has been perfecting Italian cuisine since 1994. His culinary journey began with extensive travels through Italy and major U.S. cities, where he studied traditional cooking methods and ingredient sourcing. He brings decades of experience to Garage Pizza's open kitchen concept.
Questions
What makes Garage Pizza's wood-fired pizzas unique?
Our pizzas use hand-stretched dough and premium ingredients cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven at optimal temperatures for perfect crispness and flavor development.
Are there vegetarian options available?
Yes, we offer Eggplant Parmesan with the same quality standards as our meat dishes, served with linguini marinara.
Do you offer catering services?
We accommodate parties up to 20 with complete dinner service including house salad and dessert.
What payment methods do you accept?
We operate as a cash-only establishment for all food and beverage purchases.
What are your operating hours?
We serve Monday through Friday from 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Can I watch the pizza-making process?
Yes, our open kitchen concept allows guests to observe the preparation from dough stretching to final baking.
Reviews (4)
Brian Gaugler
Aug 27, 2018 Report
Decent dinner. Didn't experience any of that which the low scorers are stating. Veal dinner and chicken were good but chicken parm was small in portions. Bread left a lot to be desired which for an italian joint is worth mentioning
Therese Evans
Aug 04, 2018 Report
We ordered take out last week and i was very impressed with the quality of the (freshly made) pasta and pizza.The woman who took our order (the wife of the chef) was extremely friendly and accommodating, and I found the food to be traditionally prepared, which I prefer (Italian-Italian - not American-Italian cuisine). The flavor combinations were absolutely perfect. My children loved it as well.
Courtney Ayukawa
Jul 23, 2018 Report
All of our pasta was luke warm...in temperature and flavour. We got the spaghetti with meatballs, broccoli rabe and chicken penne, salmon special, and the sausage con verde pasta. The salt and pepper shakers were used by everyone at the table because flavour was really lacking. There was also no fresh ground pepper or parmesan. Service was also slow; we only got bread when we asked for it and then it was then served with dinner but they took our bread plates away! It's okay though, we didn't eat the bread because it was stale. Overall, very disappointed and underwhelming.
Mellen Jay
Jun 15, 2018 Report
We ate here twice for dinners during the Ironman with young families and nervous athletes. Nicola's accomodated our big party at an open, spacious table and let us socialize for hours. We never felt pressured to leave. Food arrived quickly (hangry!) and the salads were crisp and fresh. Beautiful, big, wood-fired pizzas; flavourful and straightforward pastas, kid-friendly menu if you ask.