Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Jewelry Store in Westlake Offering Fine Jewelry & Custom Designs
Founded in 1947 by Peter Yeager, a US Army-trained watch repair specialist and Graduate Gemologist from GIA, our family-owned business has served Northeast Ohio for over seven decades. We established ourselves as Cleveland's first gemology experts, expanding to Rocky River in 1991 and Westlake in 2006 to showcase global fine jewelry collections. Third-generation leadership from Jack Yeager, a GIA-certified gemologist with business expertise from Kent State, and Debbie Yeager from Baldwin Wallace University ensures continuity of specialized knowledge.Our services include custom design, jewelry repair, insurance appraisals, and ethically sourced diamonds, supported by technical proficiency in prong repair, stone setting, and pearl restringing. We maintain industry leadership through GIA-certified expertise, adherence to Kimberley Process standards, and sustainable practices using recycled gold. Client trust is reinforced through complimentary cleaning services, free gift wrapping, and layaway financing options.
Services
Engagement Rings
Custom Design
Jewelry Repair
Insurance Appraisals
Ethically Sourced Diamonds
Pearl Restringing
Watch Services
Estate Jewelry
Gift Wrapping
Gold Buying
Details
- Year established: 1947
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1947 with three generations of gemology expertise
- GIA-certified gemologists providing accurate insurance appraisals
- Ethically sourced diamonds meeting Kimberley Process standards
- Complimentary jewelry cleaning and gift wrapping services available
- Custom design capabilities with in-house goldsmith and renowned designers
Associations and certifications
- Gemological Institute of America (GIA)
Services
Jewelry Repair
Our skilled technicians handle all jewelry repair needs from basic resizing to complex stone re-setting. Services include prong replacement, chain soldering, and rhodium plating. We specialize in restoring vintage pieces while maintaining structural integrity.
Custom Design
Create unique pieces through our custom design service with in-house goldsmith collaboration. We transform ideas into wearable art using CAD technology and traditional craftsmanship techniques for one-of-a-kind jewelry solutions.
Insurance Appraisals
GIA-certified gemologists provide official documentation for insurance coverage. We offer replacement cost reports with detailed specifications accepted by all major insurance providers. Appraisals include digital imaging and material analysis.
Ethically Sourced Diamonds
We offer conflict-free diamonds following Kimberley Process standards. Our selection includes Canadian and Australian mined stones alongside lab-created options with identical optical properties at 30% reduced cost.
Pearl Restringing
Professional pearl restringing using knotted silk thread prevents damage and loss. Our experts handle delicate nacre surfaces while replacing clasps and restoring original luster through proper cleaning techniques.
People
Peter Yeager
Founder
US Army-trained watchmaker who became Cleveland's first GIA-certified gemologist in 1950. Established Yeager Jewelers in 1947, building a reputation for quality that continues through three generations.
Jack Yeager
Graduate Gemologist
Third-generation leader with GIA certification and Kent State business degree. Oversees inventory selection and maintains technical standards for repairs and appraisals since joining the family business.
Debbie Yeager
Business Manager
Baldwin Wallace University graduate managing daily operations since the 1980s. Coordinates customer service initiatives and special events while maintaining the store's commitment to personalized shopping experiences.
Questions
Do you offer custom jewelry design services?
Yes, our in-house goldsmith creates custom pieces from sketches or ideas. We also collaborate with renowned designers for unique engagement rings and special occasion jewelry.
Are your diamonds ethically sourced?
All diamonds follow Kimberley Process standards. We offer Canadian/Australian mined stones and lab-created alternatives with full documentation of ethical sourcing practices.
What jewelry repair services do you provide?
We handle resizing, prong replacement, stone setting, chain repair, and pearl restringing. Most repairs completed while you wait, with complex work finished within 7-10 business days.
Do you provide insurance appraisals?
GIA-certified gemologists offer official appraisals with digital documentation. We provide replacement cost reports accepted by all major insurance companies for items over $1,000.
What payment options are available?
We accept cash, checks, and major credit cards. Layaway plans available with 25% deposit and bi-monthly payments over three months. Gift cards available in any denomination.
Can you help with estate jewelry?
Yes, we offer estate jewelry evaluation, restoration, and modernization services. Our appraisers assess value while our technicians restore vintage pieces to like-new condition.
Reviews (6)
Marissa S.
Dec 15, 2021
Report
Amazing jeweler. Literally cant ask for a better place to shop for some quality pieces. Jack really takes his time to educate you on the pieces youre looking at to help you make the best decision. I couldnt have been happier with my experience & my friend says the same. My ring is being resized & I know they will take the best of care with it.
Rick K.
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Critical:Value
Took in some 14K gold items to sell. They offered a fraction of what they were worth in gold. Went down the street to Savvy Silver and got almost triple what Yeager offered. I would not take gold to them to sell, they really low-ball you with a lousy offer.
Took in some 14K gold items to sell. They offered a fraction of what they were worth in gold. Went down the street to Savvy Silver and got almost triple what Yeager offered. I would not take gold to them to sell, they really low-ball you with a lousy offer.
Jessica I.
Nov 29, 2021
Report
After my sapphire engagement ring was stolen, I replaced it with a lovely ring from a NYC-based jeweler. When it arrived, I found that the setting didn't work with my wedding band. I took it to Jack Yeager, who instantly knew what I wanted and produced a few mountings for me to try. They took the stone out of its current ring and placed it in the new one (ordered in my size so it fit perfectly right away). It looks 100% prettier in its new setting thanks to Jack's expert selection. He was good about explaining why he recommended the ring he did and giving me options as to style and material
Snow
Jul 12, 2020
Report
I would recommend them to any one! Go there they will treat you with respect! Prices are not crazy! The owner will take care of you personally and with respect! Lawayay is an option that he will give! If your jewelry has an issue it will be repaired with no questions asked! Go there if you want good priced stuff and first class care! I'm being honest! You will not be disappointed! I guarantee it!
Paul Endrei
Jan 05, 2020
Report
My wife Patti and I love Yeagars Jewelers! They have amazing jewelry and outstanding service and treat you like family! Paul and Patti
Dino Cuffari
Aug 05, 2018
Report
I lost the diamond from a ring my Father passed down to me. I went to Yeager Jewelers because i have had pleasure to do business with Jack Yeager over the years. He took the time to explain multiple options for a new diamond. He was able to get the perfect diamond for the ring. I know my Father is happy I wear the ring to honor him. Thank you.