Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Jewelry Store in Oyster Bay, NY
Established in 1940, Smith Jewelers has been a family-owned cornerstone of Oyster Bay, NY, dedicated to providing exceptional jewelry services and products. Our expertise spans fine jewelry sales, custom designs, and meticulous restoration, serving clients across New York and Long Island. We pride ourselves on fostering relationships with artisans nationwide while supporting local talent, ensuring every piece reflects unparalleled artistry. Our services include custom engagement rings, wedding bands, jewelry repair, engraving, and insurance replacement, all backed by decades of trust. We specialize in personalized solutions, from heirloom restoration to contemporary designs, using platinum, gold, silver, and more. Our team offers expert evaluations, diamond setting, and polishing, emphasizing durability and beauty.

With a reputation built on attention to detail and customer-centric values, we remain committed to excellence in every interaction. Our showroom showcases exquisite collections tailored to diverse tastes, occasions, and styles, making us a destination for discerning clients. From pearl restringing to watch repair, our comprehensive services ensure lifelong care for your cherished pieces. We work directly with insurance companies to replace lost or damaged jewelry, maintaining quality and value. Our engraving options, including script and block fonts, allow for meaningful personalization of gifts and heirlooms. As a multigenerational business, we uphold traditions of integrity while embracing innovation in jewelry craftsmanship.
Services
Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Custom Jewelry Design Jewelry Repair Engraving Services Insurance Replacement Pearl Restringing Watch Repair Antique Refurbishing Silver Refinishing
Details
  • Year established: 1940
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned since 1940 with deep local expertise
  • Custom designs crafted by master jewelers
  • Full-service repair and restoration specialists
  • Personalized engraving and heirloom preservation
  • Direct partnerships with global and local artisans
What people say
Personal service Beautiful selection Trusted repair expertise Family owned Sparkles on my finger
Services
Engagement Rings
Our engagement rings combine timeless elegance with modern craftsmanship, featuring conflict-free diamonds and customizable designs. Expert consultants guide clients through selecting stones, metals, and settings tailored to individual preferences. Each piece undergoes rigorous quality checks to ensure lasting beauty and structural integrity.
Custom Jewelry Design
Transform ideas into heirlooms through our custom design process, where artisans collaborate on sketches, material selection, and prototyping. We incorporate family heirlooms or create entirely new pieces using platinum, gold, or silver. Advanced CAD technology ensures precision before final handcrafting.
Jewelry Repair
From minor adjustments to complex restorations, our repair services handle resizing, stone setting, and antique refurbishing. We use specialized tools for platinum, titanium, and delicate silver pieces, preserving original craftsmanship while enhancing durability for everyday wear.
Engraving Services
Add meaningful touches through machine or hand engraving, available in multiple fonts and languages. Services include inscribing dates, names, or symbols inside rings, customizing wedding bands, and commemorating milestones with precision on metal surfaces.
Insurance Replacement
We streamline insurance claims by sourcing exact jewelry replacements, documenting specifications, and collaborating directly with providers. Our inventory access ensures accurate matches for lost or damaged items, maintaining original quality and design integrity.
Questions
What jewelry services do you offer?
We provide engagement rings, custom designs, repairs, engraving, insurance replacement, pearl restringing, and watch repair services.
Are you a family-owned business?
Yes, we've been family-owned and operated in Oyster Bay since 1940.
Do you create custom jewelry pieces?
Yes, our master jewelers collaborate on bespoke designs using CAD technology and traditional craftsmanship.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Oyster Bay, Long Island, and surrounding New York areas.
Can you repair antique jewelry?
Yes, we specialize in antique refurbishing while preserving original design elements.
Do you work with insurance companies?
Yes, we assist with insurance claims for lost or damaged jewelry replacements.
Reviews (2)
Anne Biernacki
Nov 19, 2019 Report
GREAT PERSONAL SERVICE WITH EXPERT REPAIRS-EXCEPTIONAL KNOWLEDGE OF SETTINS AND GEM STONES'-MY ONE AND JEWLER I TRUST
Connie DeSalvo
Jul 05, 2018 Report
Local gem I've been going to since childhood with my Mom. Beautiful selection, personal service, repairs by people you can trust.