Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Professional Jewelry Appraisals in Indianapolis
As the owner of Noble Jewelry Appraisers, I bring 27 years of hands-on experience in the jewelry trade to provide precise and reliable appraisal services. My background includes working with established jewelry retailers like Wright Jewelers and Ringmaker.com, where I developed expertise in diamonds, colored gemstones, precious metals, and custom jewelry. I hold the prestigious Graduate Gemologist (GG, GIA) certification, which enhances my ability to deliver accurate market-driven valuations. Our services cater to insurance, estate, and liquidation needs, utilizing current pricing guides and NYSE metals market data to ensure transparency and fairness. We specialize in evaluating fine jewelry, watches, and gemstones, including vintage, antique, and designer pieces.

Our streamlined appraisal process prioritizes efficiency while maintaining meticulous attention to detail, including cleaning, measurement, photography, and formal documentation. Clients receive both physical and digital copies of appraisals tailored to their specific requirements. We understand the sentimental value of jewelry and approach each appraisal with care and professionalism. Competitive pricing starts at $85 per appraisal, with customized estimates based on complexity and volume. Appointments can be scheduled through our website, phone, or email, ensuring flexibility for our clients.
Services
Insurance Appraisals Estate Appraisals Fair Market Valuation Gemstone Evaluation Watch Appraisals
Highlights and features
  • We offer 27 years of specialized jewelry trade expertise.
  • Our appraisals use current market data and NYSE metals prices.
  • We provide detailed documentation with photography and measurements.
  • Competitive pricing starts at $85 per appraisal.
  • Appointments available via website, phone, or email.
Associations and certifications
  • Graduate Gemologist (GG, GIA)
Services
Insurance Appraisals
Insurance appraisals determine current retail replacement values for jewelry and watches. These evaluations protect your investment by ensuring proper coverage with insurance companies. Our Graduate Gemologist certification guarantees accurate assessments using market data and NYSE metals pricing.
Estate Appraisals
Estate appraisals establish fair market values for tax purposes or family asset division. We provide legally compliant documentation that reflects accurate market conditions. Our 27 years of experience ensure precise valuations for estate settlement requirements.
Gemstone Evaluation
Professional evaluation of diamonds, pearls, and colored gemstones includes quality analysis and market pricing. We use industry-standard measurement techniques while preserving stone integrity. Our GIA-certified expertise guarantees reliable identification and valuation.
Watch Appraisals
Comprehensive assessment of luxury watches considers brand, condition, and market demand. We document features and provide replacement value estimates for insurance purposes. Our process includes detailed photography and formal documentation.
Fair Market Valuation
Fair market value appraisals determine realistic selling prices for estate sales or divorce settlements. We analyze current market conditions to establish minimum expected returns. This service helps clients make informed decisions about jewelry liquidation.
People
Angela
Owner & Graduate Gemologist
With 27 years in the jewelry trade and GIA certification, Angela provides expert appraisals in Indianapolis. She previously worked at Wright Jewelers and Ringmaker.com, combining practical experience with formal education from Indiana University.
Questions
What types of appraisals do you offer?
We provide insurance, estate, fair market value, and loss evaluation appraisals for jewelry, watches, and gemstones.
How long does an appraisal take?
Most appraisals complete during a single appointment while you run errands, depending on item quantity and complexity.
What should I bring to my appointment?
Bring any existing documentation like purchase receipts, past appraisals, or gemstone certifications to aid accurate evaluation.
Are your appraisals legally recognized?
Yes, our Graduate Gemologist certification and formal documentation meet insurance and legal requirements for valuation accuracy.
How are appraisal fees determined?
Basic appraisals start at $85, with final pricing based on item complexity and quantity requiring evaluation.
Reviews (6)
Dani Yates
Jul 03, 2021 Report
Professional, personable, efficient service! Walking into her office its clear that that Angela knows what she is doing and has the credentials to prove it. We were able to get an item appraised and written up within a day. I will be coming back if I need something else appraised and would highly recommend her!
Marcia Reller
Apr 27, 2021 Report
I was looking for someone to appraise some rings for my aunts estate and found Angela Noble through a Google search. After calling several appraisers, I decided on Angela because she described her process with such passion and intelligence. She really knows the business, has high tech appraisal instruments and wants to do the best possible job for her clients. Angela's pricing is very fair and the printed appraisals she provided were exactly what the estate required. Her office was easy to find and I felt secure leaving my aunts jewelry overnight to be appraised. Ms. Noble is very conscientious
Ryan Bedel
Apr 18, 2021 Report
Angela has been great to work with over the last few months. She was extremely helpful as we worked through a difficult situation witha jeweler. She identified discrepanciesin what we had bought and were provided. With her information,we were able to get a full refund of our purchase. She also introduced us to Jeff West who did a fantastic job creating a new wedding ring to match the engagement ring. She's also been helpful with several appraisals we've brought to her.
Bryce Wark
Apr 01, 2021 Report
Top tier crenditials & professionalism. Goes above & beyond explaining any questions I had. I am beyond impressed with her & will only work with Angela in the future for appraisals!
Danette Hopkinsbey-Thompson
Feb 22, 2021 Report
I will call on Angela at Noble Jewelers anytime I have any jewelry that needs appraising. She very knowledgeable, have quick turnaround, meaning in most cases she can complete an appraisal within hours or 1 day. Most places I went to or called, wanted a week or two to appraise my ring. She explained everything to me and made me feel very comfortable. Oh and I believe my rings were given an excellent appraisal value.
Katherine Obbagy
Jan 24, 2021 Report
Angela was great to work with - she is extremely knowledgeable, detail oriented, and worked to get my appraisals done quickly. She made it easy to set up an appointment, and communicated all the necessary information I needed in a timely fashion. I highly recommend Noble Jewelry Appraisers for all of your jewelry appraisal needs!