Business Details
Experience Global Flavors at Rusty's Surf & Turf
At Rusty's Surf & Turf, we have dedicated ourselves to crafting a dining experience that seamlessly blends the freshest local seafood with bold international flavors. Our commitment to excellence is rooted in decades of culinary expertise, with a focus on sourcing the highest-quality ingredients from Hatteras Island and beyond. We pride ourselves on creating dishes that reflect global culinary traditions while honoring the rich maritime heritage of the Outer Banks. Our team, led by chef-owner Rusty Midgett, approaches every meal with a passion for innovation and a dedication to customer satisfaction.We maintain rigorous standards in food preparation and service, ensuring each guest receives a memorable and authentic dining experience. Our restaurant's reputation for superior quality and unique flavor combinations has been built through consistent execution and a deep understanding of our customers' expectations. We actively engage with the local community, supporting sustainable fishing practices and regional producers. Every aspect of our operation, from menu development to tableside service, reflects our commitment to culinary excellence and guest satisfaction.
Services
Seafood Dishes
Steak Entrees
Craft Cocktails
Wine Selection
Beer Selection
Highlights and features
- We offer chef-crafted dishes combining local seafood with international culinary techniques.
- Our team maintains rigorous quality standards for ingredient sourcing and preparation.
- We provide a unique dining experience inspired by global culinary traditions.
- Our restaurant supports sustainable fishing practices and local producers.
- We deliver consistently exceptional service in a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere.
What people say
Perfect meal
Superior service
Best Shrimp and Grits
Unforgettable experience
Superb quality
Services
Seafood Dishes
Our seafood dishes feature locally sourced catches prepared with global culinary techniques. Each plate showcases the natural flavors of Hatteras Island's freshest seafood. Our chefs expertly prepare dishes that balance traditional preparation with innovative flavor combinations.
Steak Entrees
We offer premium steak selections prepared to perfection using time-tested cooking methods. Our beef is carefully chosen for quality and marbling, complemented by house-made sauces and seasonal accompaniments. Each cut receives individual attention to ensure optimal doneness and flavor.
Craft Cocktails
Our bar program features expertly crafted cocktails using premium spirits and house-made mixers. Each drink combines classic techniques with modern innovations, offering both familiar favorites and unique creations. Our bartenders maintain rigorous standards for presentation and flavor balance.
Wine Selection
We offer a carefully selected wine list featuring both Old World and New World varietals. Our sommeliers choose each bottle to complement our menu offerings, with options ranging from bold reds to crisp whites. The collection includes both familiar favorites and unique discoveries.
Beer Selection
Our beer program showcases local and international craft brews across multiple styles. We maintain proper storage and serving temperatures to preserve optimal flavor profiles. The selection includes both traditional styles and experimental craft offerings.
People
Rusty Midgett
Chef & Owner
Renowned chef Rusty Midgett combines decades of culinary expertise with global travel experiences to create innovative seafood and steak dishes. His commitment to quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations has established Rusty's Surf & Turf as a premier dining destination on Hatteras Island.
Questions
What type of cuisine does Rusty's Surf & Turf offer?
We specialize in seafood and steak dishes infused with global flavors, combining local Outer Banks ingredients with international culinary techniques.
Are reservations required at your restaurant?
Reservations are recommended but not required. We serve dinner Wednesday through Sunday nights in Buxton, NC.
What makes your seafood dishes unique?
Our seafood dishes feature locally sourced catches prepared with global culinary techniques that highlight both traditional and innovative flavor combinations.
Do you offer outdoor seating options?
Yes, we provide both indoor dining and outdoor porch seating for guests to enjoy their meals in a comfortable setting.
What craft beverage options are available?
We offer craft cocktails, a curated wine selection, and both local and international craft beers to complement our menu offerings.
Reviews (7)
Chris Brownfield
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Went in and was seated in just a minute or two. Waitress was really knowledgeable about menu details. My wife and I both had the Mahi plate. Fish was cooked to perfection and flavor was amazing. Can not wait to go back again. If you are near Buxton, NC this is definitely a place to enjoy a meal.
Leann Tsou
Oct 29, 2021
Report
Paella was delicious! Seafood was fresh, and Hushpuppy with butter were so yummy
Pat D.
Oct 17, 2021
Report
I give credit where credit is due. One of the better dining experiences I've ever had. Hostesses and server were fantastic and accommodating with our kids. Our drinks and meals were great and even our 3 year old said "That was a really good dinner" on our way home. We will definitely be back for a few more margaritas and dinner!
John Forbes
Oct 14, 2021
Report
12 big LOCAL shrimp. Delicious. Fresh chef made chocolate cake. Very attentive staff . Make reservations early especially mid week off season (many closed. Covid. No Help).
Lisa B.
Oct 04, 2021
Report
We came @ 7PM on a Sunday, after making a reservation earlier. (It closes at 8; not 9) They were already sold out of some selections, but we were content with Steak & a cashew vegetable stir-fry-- cooked to perfection! It is the beach, so there are stairs to climb to come in, but also a ramp to the far right. Outdoor seating available, but was all full when we came. We were the only table in the bar area, and were immediately waited on. An experiment to be repeated, hopefully. The prices online were lower by a couple of dollars than the actual menu.
Ashley S.
Oct 03, 2021
Report
Food was AWESOME. A little pricey, but I mean what do you expect, vacation, beach, good time = money. We went apps for a light dinner. Hushpuppy crusted oysters with a Cajun remoulade(I didn't eat any but the hubby said they were good...not fishy at all ), fried green tomatoes(I could have eaten three plates of these; 4 good sized but not too thick slices with roasted shallot aioli, feta, fried country ham, and balsamic drizzle....)I am telling you TO.DIE. FOR, Tempura shrimp(for an appetizer it was perfect, crispy outside, perfectly done, large shrimp (4)with honey habanero sauce) the hubs also
Deborah Clark
Sep 25, 2021
Report
Our hostess Tayna and our waitress Liza were AWESOME! Very personable. And... Food with a tropical twist. And the best part, most of the Dining room is socially distanced that I felt comfortable doing indoor dining.