Business Details
37 Years
experience
Expert Jewelry Appraisals Nationwide
Established in 1989, Jewelry Judge has built a national reputation as the premier network of independent certified jewelry appraisers. Our mission is to provide unbiased, transparent, and comprehensive appraisals for insurance, estate planning, divorce settlements, and personal knowledge purposes. Our team of highly trained gemologists and appraisers adheres to strict professional standards, ensuring each valuation includes detailed documentation with photographs and specialized diamond grading reports for stones over 1 carat. Unlike traditional jewelers, our business model exclusively focuses on appraisal services, eliminating conflicts of interest by never buying or selling jewelry.We prioritize client education throughout the appraisal process, offering valuable insights into the characteristics and value of each piece. With locations across multiple states and recognition from the Better Business Bureau, including multiple Pinnacle and Award of Distinction honors, we maintain a commitment to excellence that has served customers for decades. Our proprietary methodology combines technical precision with straightforward communication, delivering results that are both accurate and easily understood. Jewelry Judge remains dedicated to preserving the integrity of jewelry valuation through its specialized services and customer-centric approach.
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Diamond Valuations
Watch Appraisals
Gemstone Evaluations
Estate Jewelry Appraisals
Insurance Coverage Appraisals
Divorce Settlement Valuations
Engagement Ring Appraisals
Details
- Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
- We operate with complete impartiality as we never buy or sell jewelry
- Our appraisals include detailed photographic documentation and diamond grading reports
- Team consists of certified gemologists with decades of industry experience
- Recognized by Better Business Bureau with multiple excellence awards
- Transparent process educates clients while completing real-time appraisals
Associations and certifications
- Better Business Bureau
What people say
Professional expertise
Detailed documentation
Educational process
Transparent evaluations
Impartial service
Services
Jewelry Appraisals
Our certified gemologists conduct comprehensive jewelry appraisals for insurance, estate planning, and personal knowledge purposes. Each evaluation includes detailed documentation with high-resolution photographs and market analysis. Clients receive transparent explanations throughout the process while maintaining ownership of their items.
Diamond Appraisals
Specialized diamond grading services follow international standards for cut, color, clarity, and carat weight assessment. Stones over 1 carat receive detailed plotting diagrams for identification. The appraisal includes current market value determination based on certified grading criteria.
Watch Appraisals
We authenticate and value luxury timepieces from premier brands through mechanical inspection and market analysis. Services cover vintage models, modern collections, and limited editions. Appraisals document condition, functionality, and provenance for insurance or sale purposes.
Gemstone Appraisals
Comprehensive evaluation of colored gemstones including rubies, sapphires, emeralds, and fancy diamonds. Assessments consider origin, treatments, and the four Cs specific to colored stones. Detailed reports provide clarity on natural characteristics affecting market value.
Estate Jewelry Appraisals
Specialized appraisals for estate settlement purposes establish fair market values considering current market conditions and historical significance. Our reports meet probate requirements while documenting pieces for equitable distribution or charitable contributions.
People
Barry S. Block
Founder
Master Gemologist Appraiser with over 30 years of experience. Established New York's first gemology laboratory for jewelry appraisals. Developed proprietary methodologies now taught in industry certification programs. Recognized authority in jewelry valuation standards.
James L. Peddicord
Certified Appraiser
Accredited jewelry appraiser with specialization in antique and vintage pieces. Holds advanced certifications from multiple gemological institutions. Contributes to industry publications on valuation techniques and market trends affecting jewelry appraisal standards.
Richard B. Drucker
Senior Gemologist
25+ years experience in diamond and colored stone grading. Maintains active memberships in international gemology associations. Regularly consults with insurance companies on complex jewelry valuation cases. Known for technical precision in grading reports.
Questions
Why should I use The Jewelry Judge instead of my local jeweler?
We provide impartial valuations without selling jewelry, eliminating conflicts of interest. Our certified gemologists follow standardized grading procedures that meet insurance and legal requirements.
What types of appraisals do you provide?
We specialize in insurance appraisals, estate valuations, divorce settlement evaluations, and general jewelry knowledge assessments. Services cover diamonds, gemstones, watches, and all fine jewelry categories.
How long does the appraisal process take?
Most appraisals complete within 30-60 minutes depending on the number of items. Larger collections may require scheduling multiple appointments to ensure thorough documentation and explanation.
Do you have appraisers in my state?
We maintain locations in New York, Virginia, Illinois, Texas, Nevada, and California. Check our website for specific locations and appointment availability in your area.
What documentation do I receive?
Each appraisal includes computer-generated reports with photographs. Diamonds over 1 carat receive additional grading reports with detailed plotting diagrams for identification purposes.
Reviews (2)
Mr. T.
Mar 27, 2018
Report
So glad I found this thorough and honest jewelry appraiser in Princeton. Located right off Nassau street with ample parking. Top notch professional job and results were available in pdf so I could easily file them away online. I've never trusted appraisals by jewelry stores, especially if they're trying to buy or sell me something. Always better to get an unbiased 3rd party appraisal. Couldn't be happier and will definitely use again.
Thomas C.
Feb 23, 2017
Report
Barbara Nevius did an excellent job in judging and appraising the jewelry in my mother's estate. Very professional report, reasonable fee for service. Highly recommended. She also assisted my son and daughter-in-law in evaluating their engagement ring. Again, an excellent report for insurance purposes.