Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Legal Partner in Sidney, OH
Roberts & Kelly have built a reputation for providing skilled legal representation to clients facing complex challenges. Our attorneys specialize in family law, criminal defense, and personal injury cases, with decades of combined experience serving communities across Ohio. Roberta S. Fay holds board certification in family relations law, reflecting her specialized expertise. We maintain offices in Sidney, Lima, and Troy, offering personalized service while advocating for favorable outcomes through both settlement negotiations and courtroom litigation.

Our team's strengths are demonstrated through recognition including a Reader's Choice Award from the Sidney Daily News. We prioritize client education throughout legal processes, ensuring informed decision-making while protecting clients' rights and interests.
Services
Family Law Divorce Criminal Defense Personal Injury Child Custody Spousal Support DUI Defense
Highlights and features
  • We have decades of combined experience in Ohio family law and criminal defense
  • Our firm includes a board-certified family relations law specialist
  • We maintain offices in three convenient Ohio locations
  • Recognized with Reader's Choice Awards from the Sidney Daily News
  • We combine specialized expertise with personalized client service
Associations and certifications
  • Ohio State Bar Association Board Certified Family Relations Law Specialist
What people say
Board-certified expertise Aggressive criminal defense Exceptional service Positive outcomes Dedicated representation
Services
Family Law
Our board-certified family law attorneys handle divorce proceedings, child custody arrangements, and spousal support determinations. We represent clients in court filings and negotiations for property division, parenting plans, and domestic relations issues throughout Ohio. The practice includes complex matters like high-asset divorces and division of retirement accounts.
Criminal Defense
We defend clients against criminal charges ranging from misdemeanors to serious felonies. Our practice covers DUI defense, drug crime allegations, and violent crime charges. We protect clients' constitutional rights during investigations, plea negotiations, and courtroom trials while minimizing potential consequences like imprisonment and fines.
Personal Injury
We represent injury victims in automobile accident, truck collision, and medical malpractice cases. Our practice secures compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering through insurance negotiations or litigation. We handle wrongful death claims and work on contingency fee arrangements for client access to justice.
People
Roberta S. Fay
Attorney
Roberta S. Fay is a board-certified family relations law specialist with extensive experience in divorce and custody matters. Her practice includes high-asset divorce cases and complex property division. Recognized with Reader's Choice Awards, she provides strategic legal representation across Ohio.
Scott A. Kelly
Attorney
Scott A. Kelly focuses on criminal defense and personal injury litigation. He aggressively defends clients against felony and misdemeanor charges while representing injury victims in accident claims. His practice covers courtrooms across western Ohio communities.
Questions
What areas of law does Roberts & Kelly specialize in?
We focus on family law (including divorce and custody), criminal defense (DUI, drug crimes, violent offenses), and personal injury (automobile accidents, medical malpractice).
How does the firm handle out-of-town clients?
We serve clients throughout Ohio with offices in Sidney, Lima, and Troy. We offer flexible consultation options and represent clients in courts across western Ohio counties.
What makes Roberts & Kelly different from other firms?
Our attorneys combine decades of experience with specialized certifications, including Ohio State Bar Association Board Certification in family law practice.
Does the firm offer free initial consultations?
Yes, we provide complimentary initial consultations for family law, criminal defense, and personal injury cases at our Sidney, Lima, and Troy offices.
How are personal injury cases handled?
We work on contingency fee arrangements for injury claims, representing clients in automobile accidents, truck collisions, and medical malpractice cases throughout Ohio.
Reviews (6)
Maria Dietrich
Oct 21, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
He was the only lawyer that I could find on short notice..I think he was responsible price and got my stuff knocked down.
Michael Blankenship
Jan 05, 2021 Report
Very helpful, quick, and easily accessible. Answered all question in a very timely fashion. Highly recommend
Rodney Jones
Nov 06, 2019 Report
Good guy. Honest with my situation and what he could do. Got the result I paid for and was reasonable. Hopefully won't need him again but would call for sure if I did.
Lisa Jordan
Aug 24, 2019 Report
Great attorney. Stood up for my rights and did not back down. He made sure I knew everything I needed and texted me back when I had a question.
Greg Wilco
Aug 10, 2019 Report
I can't say enough good about Scott. Other attorneys didn't seem to care about my case and just wanted to charge me a lot of money to plead. That's if they would even return my call. Scott knew what he was doing, was there when I had a question, and got my case reduced. He even got my license back when everyone else told me it would be gone for a year.
Larry Davidson
Jul 27, 2018 Report
Attorney Scott Kelly is incredible. Lawyers typically have a reputation of being money-pits who don't have any regard for their clients. Scott is not that way. When I called him for a consultation, he listened with interest and offered guidance. He went out of his way to find answers for us. Not only that, his genuine concern for people and fight for justice is evident in the way he conducts himself. I'm very grateful for his concern and assistance. He is one of the good ones!