Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Custom Jewelry Designer in Salt Lake City
At Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers, we have dedicated ourselves to the art of fine jewelry since 1972. Our commitment to quality and integrity has established us as a trusted name in Salt Lake City. We specialize in creating one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces using exquisite gemstones sourced from around the world. Our team of skilled designers guides clients through every step of the custom design process, ensuring personalized attention to detail. Located in Salt Lake City's historic Trolley Square, our showroom offers a relaxed atmosphere where customers can explore an extensive inventory of designer collections.

We pride ourselves on maintaining long-standing relationships with clients, treating each individual with the respect and care they deserve. Our expertise extends to jewelry repair, diamond selection, and special order creations. With over 50 years of experience, we continue to uphold our reputation for exceptional craftsmanship and customer service. Our knowledgeable professionals are always available to assist with inquiries or schedule personalized appointments. We believe that jewelry should tell a unique story, and we strive to make every client's experience as memorable as the pieces we create.
Services
Custom Jewelry Design Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Diamond Search Jewelry Repair
Details
  • Year established: 1972
Highlights and features
  • We have over 50 years of experience in custom jewelry design and fine jewelry sales.
  • Our in-house designers create personalized one-of-a-kind pieces with global gemstones.
  • We maintain long-standing relationships with top jewelry designers worldwide.
  • Our team provides expert guidance through every step of the jewelry creation process.
  • We offer exclusive access to Salt Lake City's largest selection of certified diamonds.
What people say
Excellent service Gorgeous original pieces Personalized attention Impeccable craftsmanship Knowledgeable staff
Services
Custom Jewelry Design
Our custom design process transforms your vision into unique wearable art. Clients work directly with master designers to create one-of-a-kind pieces using premium gemstones and metals. Each creation receives meticulous attention to detail, ensuring perfect execution of personal stories through jewelry.
Engagement Rings
We offer an extensive selection of engagement and wedding bands from renowned designers. Our experts guide couples through diamond selection and ring customization. Every piece combines superior craftsmanship with timeless elegance to mark life's most important moments.
Diamond Search
Our Diamond Search service provides access to thousands of certified diamonds. Clients receive expert guidance in choosing the perfect stone based on cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. We ensure complete transparency in diamond quality assessment and pricing.
Jewelry Repair
Our skilled artisans handle all jewelry maintenance needs, from simple repairs to complex restorations. Using advanced techniques, we preserve the integrity and beauty of heirloom pieces while maintaining structural safety and aesthetic appeal.
Luxury Collections
We showcase exclusive collections from top international designers like Roberto Coin and Simon G. Each curated piece represents the pinnacle of contemporary jewelry design, featuring innovative craftsmanship and premium materials sourced globally.
People
Steve Farr
Owner
With decades of experience in the jewelry industry, Steve Farr leads Payne Anthony Creative Jewelers with a commitment to excellence. He oversees all custom design projects and ensures every client receives personalized attention while maintaining the store's legacy of quality.
Questions
What custom jewelry services do you offer?
We specialize in complete custom design from concept to creation, including engagement rings, wedding bands, and unique statement pieces using premium gemstones and metals.
Are you part of Jonathan's Jewelry family?
Yes, we're now part of the Jonathan's Jewelry family while maintaining our distinct identity and commitment to Salt Lake City customers since 1972.
Do you carry certified diamonds?
Yes, we offer an extensive selection of certified diamonds with full documentation of quality characteristics and origin.
Can you repair heirloom jewelry?
Our skilled artisans handle all jewelry repairs, including delicate restoration of heirloom pieces while preserving their original character and integrity.
What are your store hours?
We're open Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 7 PM, with appointments available for personalized shopping experiences.
Do you offer jewelry appraisals?
Yes, we provide professional appraisal services for insurance and estate purposes with documentation from our certified gemologists.
Reviews (7)
Shelley Moss
Oct 06, 2021 Report
Im not sure the name of the man that helped me, but he very kindly and patiently checked my family jewelry to tell me if it was real or not. Once we found out that it was fake he talked to be about making custom pieces and about different stones and said that while the stones were fake, we could use the gold to trade for something new. He was very personable and although I was probably not the best dressed and Id had surgery on my hand the day before, he still was friendly and kind and happy to help. I feel like the bad reviewers on here forget that theyre jewelers and, from what I could
Brittney Bake
Aug 14, 2021 Report
Steve was so great! I took my mom to have her too tight wedding ring cut off and he was so polite, quick and gave us suggestions for when she decides what to do with it. Well be back in the future for any jewelry needs.
G. D.
Aug 06, 2021 Report
Our heartfelt thanks to Steve, Meri and Jeff for exceeding our expectations through out the process of updating my beautiful brides wedding ring! We have very high standards, and were fortunate to have found such a hidden gem of a jeweler! Wanting nothing to do with chain store jeweler options, we did much research on finding the jeweler that felt right. Without question, Payne Anthony checks all the boxes! Integrity, quality, work ethic and of course an amazing finish! We can't stop admiring her stunning one of a kind and unique wedding ring, which is truly a testament to their own high expectations
Aly Booth
Jan 29, 2021 Report
We purchased our diamond engagement ring and wedding bands from Payne Anthony 6 years ago. Weve had them serviced regularly and have had an excellent experience every time. The staff is friendly and helpful.
Adam Dziuba
Dec 23, 2020 Report
Steve is a very thoughtful, patient, and caring owner with whom you can feel good doing business with. Would recommend to anyone
James Fricke
Oct 27, 2020 Report
I can't recommend this shop enough even if just for the wide variety of jewelry available. My now fianc and I had been ring shopping for about a year and hadn't found the perfect ring. We weren't in any hurry and it seemed like every shop we went to simply wanted us to buy a ring and leave. We decided to look at custom rings and went to see Jeff at Payne Anthony. Never once did he rush us and he always had time for questions and was happy to take the time to make sure everything was perfect. For the next year he worked with my fianc to create a ring of her dreams for less than what we would
Kelly Ferrone
Oct 24, 2019 Report
I absolutely love this jeweler. They have the most unique selection. They have great pricing because they have everything from a few hundred up to tens of thousands. I'm a guy so jewelery is usually boring but I enjoy coming in to just browse. Got my wife's engagement ring here. We both couldn't get our minds off if it. In a few months we come back for my ring