Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Go-To Italian Restaurant in Hanover, PA
Sal's Pizza & Subs was founded in 1973 with a commitment to providing Hanover residents with high-quality Italian-American cuisine. Our family-owned business has served the community for over four decades, emphasizing fresh ingredients sourced from reputable distributors. We pride ourselves on maintaining consistent quality in our hand-tossed pizzas, homemade soups, and handcrafted subs while fostering a welcoming environment where customers feel like valued guests. Our dedication to excellence has earned us near-perfect ratings across review platforms, reflecting our unwavering focus on customer satisfaction.As a locally operated establishment, we remain dedicated to perfecting classic recipes while adapting to modern preferences. Our team combines culinary expertise with genuine hospitality to create memorable dining experiences for families and individuals alike. Through generations of loyal patrons and evolving menu offerings, we continue striving to be the premier choice for Italian-inspired meals in south-central Pennsylvania.
Services
Pizzas
Subs
Stromboli
Pasta
Salads
Sandwiches
Details
- Year established: 1973
Highlights and features
- We've served Hanover since 1973, perfecting our recipes for over four decades.
- Our menu features hand-tossed pizzas and homemade dishes made with premium ingredients.
- Family-owned business maintaining personal connections with local customers.
- Consistently earns near-perfect ratings from verified customer reviews.
- Offers both dine-in and takeout options with daily lunch specials.
What people say
Perfect crispness
Plenty of meat
Best tasting pizza
Drive-up window convenience
Bellylicious meatballs
Services
Custom Pizzas
Our hand-tossed pizzas feature fresh dough topped with premium ingredients like house-made tomato sauce, imported cheeses, and quality meats. Customers choose from classic combinations or create custom creations with 15+ toppings. Each pizza receives individual attention in traditional deck ovens for authentic results.
Hoagies & Subs
Handcrafted sandwiches use 12-inch Italian rolls filled with grilled meats, fresh vegetables, and signature sauces. Signature options include cheesesteaks with melted cheese whiz and cold cuts with provolone. All sandwiches come with customer-selected toppings and condiments for personalized flavor profiles.
Pasta Dishes
Traditional Italian pasta offerings include baked ziti with sausage, stuffed shells, and spaghetti with house-made meatballs. Each entre includes garlic bread and a side salad with house dressing. Custom options allow diners to add extra meat or choose from multiple pasta shapes and sauces.
Daily Lunch Specials
Time-limited lunch specials feature value meals between 11 AM - 4 PM. Popular options include one-topping 12-inch pizzas with soft drinks, cheese pizza slices with soup combinations, and budget-friendly stromboli portions ideal for quick midday meals.
Catering Services
Bulk catering options available for events up to 100+ guests include pizza trays, sub platters, and pasta buffets. Staff can prepare custom menus with 24-hour advance notice. Previous clients include local sports teams, school functions, and corporate events in the Hanover area.
Questions
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Tuesday-Thursday 11 AM - 8 PM and Friday-Sunday 11 AM - 10 PM. Closed Mondays for regular service.
Do you offer catering for special events?
Yes, we provide full catering services for parties and events with advance ordering options for pizza trays, sub platters, and pasta dishes.
Are delivery services available?
We offer takeout and delivery options from our full menu during regular operating hours for local Hanover addresses.
Do you have gluten-free menu items?
While we don't have dedicated gluten-free options, we offer alternative preparations for select dishes upon request during your visit.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept cash, major credit cards, and mobile payment options for both dine-in and takeout orders at our restaurant.
Videos
Reviews (6)
Stan B.
Dec 23, 2021
Report
My go to place for a great large bacon pizza. When I'm coming home from work after driving around people who don't use turn signals or cut you off and then drive 10 mph under the speed limit. I give Sal's a call when I cross the Pa line and the, pizza is ready when I get there.
Kathy
Nov 24, 2021
Report
Always very good pizza, I just wish you could order and pay online. My favorite pizza meat topping is their homemade sausage. It's the best!
Richie McKinley
Nov 03, 2021
Report
Good pizza and price is good nice place to eat when this covid is over and thing's get back to normal only take out at the drive through but that ok for us glad they are back open so thank you sal'sand your workers be safe and thank you for reopening.
Thomas Quinn
Nov 01, 2021
Report
Love the food. Manicotti, pizza fries, cheese steaks, pizza. Hot, fresh, great service, great delivery drivers, good prices.
Matt Norris
Sep 16, 2021
Report
The pizza and Italian cold cut subs are the only things I get at Sals because they are so darn good, I cant bring myself to explore the rest of their menu! There are several pizza shops in Hanover that are excellent and this is one of them. Ive been a customer for decades and will certainly continue. Im glad they are not far from where I live. Ive NEVER been disappointed there or had an issue that wasnt resolved. I dont feel like cooking tonight, so Ill be ordering from Sals!
Jenn Christian
Sep 10, 2021
Report
Absolutely the BEST Pizza you will ever eat. Marinara sauce has a nice taste and the cheese is perfection with a tint of salt. Fresh dough. They also have Mr Pibb.