Business Details
19 Years
experience
Authentic Farm-to-Table Dining in Bethany Beach
The Penguin is a family-owned and operated restaurant rooted in traditional farming values and coastal living. Established through decades of agricultural heritage from Vermont and culinary expertise from the Eastern Shore, we specialize in farm-to-table cuisine using USDA-certified organic ingredients and locally sourced seafood. Our commitment to fresh, sustainable practices began with Katie Nutter McLeod's upbringing on an organic Vermont farm and evolved through our 2015 partnership with the Neumann family. We maintain strict quality standards, employing vegetable-based oil for allergy sensitivity and offering gluten-free options while preserving family traditions like our award-winning Vermont maple syrup and Cabot cheddar. Our chefs prioritize seasonal ingredients from regional growers and fishers, ensuring meals reflect both culinary artistry and environmental stewardship.With a team of experienced hospitality professionals, including third-generation restaurateurs, we blend personalized service with innovative menu development. Our renovated dining space maintains a welcoming atmosphere where families can enjoy meals crafted with the same care as home cooking. We actively support local agriculture by sourcing 100% of our produce, poultry, beef, and seafood from Eastern Shore suppliers when seasonally available. Our unique approach combines Vermont farm ethos with coastal culinary traditions, creating a distinctive dining experience that honors both heritage and modern dietary needs.
Services
Breakfast
Lunch
Farm-to-Table
Gluten-Free Options
Dinner
Local Seafood
Family Dining
Seasonal Menus
Details
- Year established: 2007
Highlights and features
- We source 100% USDA-certified organic meats and locally caught seafood
- Our menus feature produce from Eastern Shore growers during peak season
- Third-generation hospitality professionals manage daily operations
- We maintain Vermont farm traditions with modern dietary accommodations
- Award-winning breakfast includes organic, hormone-free ingredients
Associations and certifications
- USDA Certified Organic
What people say
Ridiculously good French toast
Attentive and friendly staff
Freshest ingredients available
Perfectly ripe avocado
Best bacon in the world
Services
Breakfast
Enjoy USDA-certified organic eggs, hormone-free meats, and locally sourced produce daily. Our breakfast menu features classic Eastern Shore dishes with modern twists using seasonal ingredients. Diners appreciate the Vermont maple syrup sourced directly from Katie McLeod's family farm.
Farm-to-Table
We maintain direct relationships with Eastern Shore growers and fishers to ensure ingredient freshness. Our approach prioritizes seasonal availability while supporting local agriculture. This commitment extends to dairy products, herbs, and specialty items sourced within Delmarva region.
Gluten-Free Options
Allergen-conscious dining includes comprehensive gluten-free menu options. We use dedicated preparation areas and maintain separate cooking equipment to prevent cross-contamination. Our staff receives regular training on dietary restrictions and safe food handling practices.
Local Seafood
Our seafood comes from sustainable Eastern Shore fisheries with daily deliveries of regional specialties. The menu features Maryland-caught crab, fresh-caught fish, and seasonal shellfish prepared using traditional methods. Chef Jeff Faille curates weekly specials based on market availability.
Seasonal Menus
Menus evolve with ingredient availability, offering spring ramps, summer corn, fall squash, and winter greens. Our culinary team creates weekly specials based on local supplier offerings while maintaining popular signature dishes year-round.
People
Katie Nutter McLeod
Co-Owner
Third-generation Vermont farmer with 40+ years agricultural experience, transitioned to coastal hospitality in 2007. Oversees ingredient sourcing and sustainability initiatives at The Penguin. Brings organic farming expertise from Nutter Farm heritage.
Mark Neumann
Co-Owner
Established restaurant operations in Bethany Beach in 2007 after decades of Eastern Shore vacation ownership. Manages business development while maintaining family hospitality traditions through three generations.
Jen McLeod
Partner
Former head server with 15+ years restaurant management experience. Specializes in event coordination and guest relations. Brings award-winning service standards from Ocean City hospitality background.
Lee McLeod
Partner
Kitchen operations expert with culinary systems optimization background. Elevated preparation efficiency at age 18 by reorganizing kitchen workflow. Maintains Vermont farm-to-table principles in modern restaurant environment.
Chef Jeff Faille
Executive Chef
Berlin, MD native with 20+ years regional culinary experience. Creates menus showcasing Eastern Shore ingredients while incorporating Vermont heritage elements. Specializes in transforming fresh local products into distinctive dishes.
Questions
What type of cuisine do you serve?
We specialize in Eastern Shore cuisine with Vermont influences, focusing on farm-to-table ingredients and fresh local seafood.
Are there gluten-free options?
Yes, we offer comprehensive gluten-free menu choices with dedicated preparation areas to ensure safe dining.
How do you source ingredients?
We maintain direct relationships with Eastern Shore growers and fishers, prioritizing seasonal availability and sustainability.
Do you serve dinner?
Yes, our dinner menu features USDA-certified organic meats and locally sourced seafood nightly.
What are your hours in winter?
We operate Friday through Monday, 9 AM to 2 PM from November through March.
Is the restaurant family-friendly?
Absolutely, we welcome families with children and maintain kid-friendly menu options and atmosphere.
Reviews (5)
Abby K.
Jan 23, 2022
Report
Went here in the off-season. It's very cute, and has a good menu, but you don't get large portions here. I ordered the "jumbo" breakfast wrap and it's hardly jumbo. I will say they have the absolutely best pancakes I have ever had. They are unique and incredible!
Matt H.
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Great pancakes bacon and eggs. Good wrap. Very good coffee. I'll be back. They have a lot very unique dishes but we didn't try those. Seemed a little pricey for the fare, but it's so close to the ocean that I get it. Great, friendly staff.
Jennifer Spindola
Sep 20, 2021
Report
The restaurant offers 100% pure maple syrup on pancakes. They also have this grilled almon BLT which is soooooo good. Who would have thought bacon and salmon combine perfectly together! this place!
Laura House
Sep 13, 2021
Report
Staff deserve a shout-out for very good service in addition to caring for a lady who collapsed outside their entrance requiring emergency aid. Staff was short-handed but managed to tend to patrons needs & we were understandably patient. Nice. Will return for breakfast again.
Kristen DeBoy
Sep 02, 2021
Report
Definitely worthy of a trip. Fast and friendly service. Good food, if a little overpriced. But, then again, that's probably what we get for eating breakfast in a resort town. The brisket bowl was definitely tasty!